Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A thought provoking diversion, March 28, 2002
I have been a fan of Stephen Coonts's writing since I picked up "Flight of the Intruder". His excellent character development, thought provoking plots, and fast pacing is exactly what I like in a novel.
"Saucer" opens with a mystery and it ends in a mystery. In between it takes the reader and characters through a whirlwind of greed, deception, discovery, murder, government conspircy, politics, love, loyality, and ethics. Mr. Coonts does an excelent job placing his characters in very difficult situations, then giving readers enough time to ask themselves what they would do before moving foward with the story. While slowing down the pace, the anticipation and reflection on the characters' situation added tremendously to the story.
While this story of fantastic technology and flying sacuers pushes into science fiction, Mr. Coonts firm grasp on the ethics and challanges of possessing this technology brings the novel back into the realm realistic fiction.
I really liked this book, but I did have trouble connecting with the characters. To me, the characterizations seemed a bit more shallow, more static than the dynamic shades of grey found in Mr. Coonts other works.
Overall, this is a very thought provoking diversion that takes the reader on a wild ride of a story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Juvenile, but a good fun read!, April 15, 2004
I'm sure I would have loved this book if I were 16 years old. I'd have given it 4 or 5 stars and thought that the 22-year-old hero, Rip Cantrell, was "too cool for school", as Rip himself puts it. Unfortunately (?), my age is such that I review books based on how I think most adults will see them, and I'm afraid that results in me labeling this book as being "juvenile" and giving it only 3 stars. Rip Cantrell finds a real genuine flying saucer buried in the sands of Northern Africa. Together with a couple of other guys he digs it up. The flying saucer is 140,000 years old! And it still works!! All it needs is some fuel, which happens to be plain water!!! A pretty woman turns up and Rip demonstrates his savoir-faire by insulting her. "Do you really like him or just need sex?" he asks her when she admits that she has had something going with the guy she's together with. We can rest assured that this love-at-first-sight relationship will blossom and become a major driving force in the story. Everyone wants the flying saucer, especially the American military and an Australian media mogul (very loosely based on Rupert Murdoch), and both are willing to use serious force to get what they want. Soon Rip and the pretty girl are on the run, flying the saucer on a fantastic journey across continents and oceans. And then things start to get really exciting. After the public becomes aware of the existence of the saucer there is widespread panic. The military and the politicians are all up in arms, and are depicted as being a bunch of idiots. So it's not just exciting but also rather humorous at times. Actually, the book presents a fairly good story, and I liked it. But the tone is definitely juvenile. And what is one to make of a statement like this: "This thing is so damn up-to-date that it hasn't been invented yet." Not a book that makes you think very hard, but a good fun read, especially if you haven't had your 20th birthday yet. Incidentally, on Stephen Coonts' web site he says that he's working on a sequel. Rennie Petersen
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Cringeworthy sci-fi, September 16, 2006
I admit it. I didn't read the reviews of this book before picking up Saucer. If I had, I would've been clued in to the obvious flaws in this book. Namely, the most irritating mary-sue character I've read this year: Rip Cantrell. Rip Cantrell is a young man with a genius IQ, the ability to outhink experts, fly saucers and, punch out Australian terrorists. Not only that but he's a complete smug jerk. My eyeballs began to roll when he pulled the Airforce officer off his feet, breaking his hip. When asked later, Rip replies smugly: "He got mouthy."
I could only get to the part where Rip kisses the lady air force officer before my ability to suspend my own disbelief disappated entirely. The only reason I might read another Coonts book is if it featured Rip Cantrell getting mauled by a pack of wild pigs.
This is a classic case of an author making one character so perfect, so superior, so annoying that he actually alienates readers. That and the science fiction elements were really really the most cliche I've ever read.
1 star. Lame in every way that counts.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|