39 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Standard fodder from corporate mouthpiece that will put you in debt and keep you there, May 15, 2010
This review is from: Save Big: Cut Your Top 5 Costs and Save Thousands (Hardcover)
Chapter 1, "Buy A House ASAP"
After I saw this I immediately checked the date and was surprised and disgusted to see it was from 2010... Pure propaganda in this chapter. No mention of the risks involved, ie: how you could be underwater in no time, how if you get behind on your payments due to a lost job the banks take everything you've paid into the mortgage principle.
One point the author makes that isn't pure nonsense, "buying a house is a forced savings plan." Utterly true. But since we know this aren't we better just saving, and not paying interest for the privilege but EARNING it instead?
This book is filled with fuzzy, downright illogical math. Example:
Annual mortgage cost before tax deduction $14,777
Annual mortgage cost after tax deduction $12,242
BIG SAVINGS = $2,535
Uh, paying interest (on something you don't need) but getting a small kickback from the government equate to savings? It doesn't... Have no illusion your government encourages you to go into debt, especially with a mortgage. But does it really make sense to pay the banks $5 just to get $1 off your taxes? Such "savings" are quickly eaten up by associated costs and taxes.
Contrary to the corporate money experts, renting is not throwing money away. There are many benefits... For example money that you have in the principle of your house pays no interest or dividends. Say you have a $75,000 paid against your mortgage, that same $75,000 pays $250 a month at 4% (still available today in checking accounts, pretax) that can cover a good portion of rent... You don't have to worry about lawns, water heaters, losing your job and still making payments for the next 25 years, losing $150,000 of payments you've made. Plus you can move and walk away at anytime with no significant penalty.
I'm not saying never buy a house, not at all. I'm only pointing out the nonsense of this renters are fools mentality. Despite low mortgage rates, the housing market is still very highly priced and many (myself included) think it's due for further price pressure.
Chapter 2: CARS - The Cheaper Road
Very standard advice on cars here... I saw no mention of the best strategy that has saved me 10s of thousands: don't drive daily. Walking, biking and public transport -that is where the savings are... More savings on healthcare as well.
Chapter 3: CREDIT - Loans For Less
Again the obviously best policy here is to not have any credit card debt! But we couldn't expect such blasphemy from the corporate toolbox could we?
Bunch of babbling about credit score in this chapter. Which as someone who has saved more than enough to cover all my expense, I could care less. I only care insofar as my score can get me good credit cards which give bonuses and cashback. Something not mentioned at all. Check out the fat wallet finance forums for real info on credit cards.
Chapter 4: GROCERIES - Guerrilla Grocery Shopping
Ok! Finally a chapter I might learn something from, and/or might have info that doesn't seem solidly rooted in big banking interests!
Pack your own lunch, price matching (only works on processed foods), coupons (again bias towards processed boxed foods) = standard advice.
Stockpiling or buying when on sale and the author actually has some decent, if common sense advice in this section.
Grocery auctions? I have quite literally never heard of or seen this -and I worked in a grocery store all through college. Might be worthwhile, but again seems to be for boxed and processed foods.
What I've found the most helpful is learning to make from scratch. You learn skills and it works out cheap and it is much better for you... Gardening is a potential gold mine as well.
Chapter 5: HEALTHCARE Curing High Costs
More standard stuff in here. I'm fairly ignorant on this as I deliberately refuse to get involved in the sick care industry. Again NO MENTION of the best healthcare money saver, eating well and exercising. 80% of eating well is avoiding processed foods (even if they offer coupons!), walking is a very adequate exercise... Almost offensive the author doesn't mention the benefits, not the least of which being financial, of taking care of yourself.
In conclusion this book seems to be specifically designed to get you in debt and keep you there. The financial sector wants you to pay the dividends and interest for the rest of your life. The political establishment wants you docile, dependent and paying them taxes for the rest of your life.
There is another way. Save aggressively and invest with caution... Buy a house with cash after 10 years of savings; always living with copious, purposeful money in the bank. It's quite stress free. Or, make payments for 30 years - life; living paycheck to paycheck always wondering how badly your life will be shaken if you get laid off.
Checkout Your Money or Your Life, if you want to build a foundation for successful finance.
EDIT: looks like the only other real review in here is by bookshipper... The other reviews are most likely fake, and are likely written by the author or some outsourced tools.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
We REALLY saved big with this book!, January 6, 2010
This review is from: Save Big: Cut Your Top 5 Costs and Save Thousands (Hardcover)
I would heartily recommend this book for any one who might ever buy or sell a home, drive a car, need healthcare, buy groceries, or use a credit card... in short, just about anyone could save big using the tips in this book!
My husband and I were fortunate to read the home-buying section of this book just as we were in the process of buying our first home. We had no idea how many aspects of buying a home were negotiable. Using the ideas in this book, we negotiated a better mortgage interest rate, successfully got rid of "junk" fees added on by our bank, and eventually closed our house with almost NO closing costs. This allowed us to have some money in our account to begin making all the little changes to the house that we otherwise would have had to wait months to do. What we appreciated most was that the tips in the book were easy to understand, and we didn't have to become real estate experts in order to feel good about our purchase. When you see the potential savings on paper, it's hard not to at least TRY to get a better rate or price, and more often than not we were successful!
Throughout this book, there are countless real-life stories about people who are spending more than they need to on the necessities of life. The author walks through how we can all save huge amounts of money without having to scrimp and save and give up things we love. I feel better treating myself to coffee or a yoga class knowing I saved thousands of dollars on my home purchase. The other aspect of this book that I loved was the sheer amount of research that was done to compile a massive list of resources. The author provides countless websites throughout the text to make the most of her tips. If I had tried to find all of this information online, it would have taken me weeks and I'm sure I would have missed some important tips. This book boils down a huge amount of information into something entirely usable and helpful. The bottom line is, it's so easy to save a lot of money; you just have to know where to start. This book will show you how.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No