From School Library Journal
Grade 8 Up–Grace Stanley returns to high school a different girl after a tragic summer during which her brother died in a car crash running an errand in her place. She drops her friends and catches the notice of a fast, wealthy crowd. Drinking, designer shopping with her emergency credit card, clubbing on a fake ID, and making out with basketball captain Dylan all seem to blur her pain. While her parents insist that church, charity, and speaking with their pastor make them better able to cope, Grace feels angry and estranged from God. Her parents condone a church concert to benefit the homeless and honor her brother's memory, but Grace feels betrayed that the remnants of Matt's band would play without him. Meanwhile, her math grade plummets, relations with her family weaken, and she loses face with the in-crowd by getting sick after drinking and drugging. Enter Philomena, an odd new girl at school, to save the day: a self-proclaimed sort of guardian angel sent to help Grace pull it together and restore her faith. The plot is predictable, and characterization remains two-dimensional; while the writing is serviceable, the redemptive theme is heavy-handed and the ending is saccharine. Better choices about losing a beloved family member are Sarah Dessen's
The Truth about Forever (Viking, 2004) and Sis Deans's
Every Day and All the Time (Holt, 2003).–
Suzanne Gordon, Peachtree Ridge High School, Suwanee, GA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
After Grace's brother, Matt, dies in an automobile accident, her mother buries herself in church activities and her father retreats to a basement hideaway. Left on her own, Grace has difficulty navigating her grief. She deserts her longtime friends, falls in with a fast crowd, finds escape in alcohol, and neglects her schoolwork. Enter a strange, prescient girl named Philomena, who seems to pop up at pivotal moments. Philomena's appearances are few at first, but as Grace reaches a crisis, they become more frequent. With Philomena's help, Grace corrects her course and comes to understand that her helper is not an ordinary teen. The religious underpinnings, not fully revealed until the conclusion, may surprise some readers, considering the book's edgy cover. But those who recognize Spencer as coauthor of the Cape Light series will expect this to have a Christian theme. Direct interested readers to Caroline Cooney's
A Friend at Midnight (2006) and the other titles in "Read-alikes: Crises of Faith" [BKL D 15 06]
Holly KoellingCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved