From School Library Journal
Starred Review. Kindergarten-Grade 3—"It's the same old story. Wolves are crusty, lazy, and mean. They howl, they chase, and they make a mess. We know all about big bad wolves and their nasty ways…Don't we?" The Scallywags are so irritating that after they ruin the animals' photo session, the bears, pigs, and sheep, etc., decide not to invite them to do things together anymore. The chastened wolves resolve to learn manners but completely overdo it: they are so changed that their friends do not recognize them—in fact, the animals start to wish they had the old Scallywags back. This hilarious story is accompanied by equally lively and humorous pictures that fill the pages with images worthy of close perusal. Each of the slovenly wolves has a distinct personality, as do the other animals. The spread of them attempting to hide while spying on their friends to learn good behavior is wonderful. The book's format sets the mood well with words scattered over the pages in different sizes to emphasize the fun. A thoroughly delightful romp.—
Judith Constantinides, formerly at East Baton Rouge Parish Main Library, LA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
*Starred Review* The animals in the neighborhood are disgusted by the Wolf family, known collectively as the Scallywags. They spoil things with their shenanigans; they throw their food and nibble on napkins; and, yes, they smell. After the wolves are sent packing, they finally take the criticism to heart. When one wolf suggests that they all improve their manners, he is reminded, "We don't got no manners." Yet they make the effort to learn some, and before long, they are so polite and nicely dressed that they aren't recognized when they show up for a meal. At first the other animals are delighted with their "new" friends, but when the wolves admonish the pigs to stop slurping their soup and the geese to quit honking with food in their mouths, the group begins wishing for the Scallywags to return. And soon enough, they do. There's fun on every page here, in the text with its sly asides but especially in the art. Melling turns cartoon-style art, which in lesser hands would seem ordinary, into an art form. There are no generic wolves here; each is individualized, and hilariously so. For instance, as the wolves try to get some "couth," one is shown with curlers in its fur, another is brushing its ears with toothpaste, and still another is pouring tea--into tin cans. Handsomely designed with thick, generously sized pages, the book has the potential to become a real fan favorite.
Ilene CooperCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved