21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A thoughtful look at our early beginnings, January 21, 2001
This review is from: The Scars of Evolution (Paperback)
I think Elaine Morgan has got it right!
RiverForest Press, in Bainbridge Island, Washington, recently sent me a review copy of the book, "The Passionate Ape," by Craig Hagstrom... In it, he gave a favorable mention to Elaine Morgan's books, "The Aquatic Ape," and "The Descent of Woman." I ordered both from Amazon.com, but also ordered "The Scars of Evolution" since it was most readily available. The reason for my interest was that she apparently advocates the Aquatic Ape Theory (AAT) which I have thought to be the only reasonable theory that adequately explains our relatively hairless bodies, bipedal stance, subcutaneous layer of fat and several other characteristics, since first I heard of it in a very brief mention in Desmond Morris's book, "The Naked Ape," many years ago.
When Morris said, and apparently believed, that our early ancestors dropped from the trees of their receding arboreal African habitat and hit the savannah running, shedding their fur as they ran to cool off, I thought the idea ludicrous. If that were so, why would they keep their layer of subcutaneous fat, the only purpose of which is warmth? And, if speed were their goal, why go bipedal. The fastest animals on earth are quadrupeds, and are covered with fur. Compared to quadrupeds, bipeds are slow and clumsy.
This book is the exposition of the aquatic ape theory for which I have been looking ever since. It is a masterful illumination of the theory, addressing elements that I had not even considered. Morgan, whose educational background and formal training in anthropology are not mentioned in the book, sad to say, is quite obviously highly qualified to comment. Her evident knowledge of anthropology and paleontology is exceeded only by her extensive knowledge of human physiology. She speaks with the easy assurance of a physician on arcane subjects such as the sebaceous glands, the vermiform appendix, sweat glands and the spine and her statements are easily checked for veracity, and obviously highly germane to the subject.
It is rare to find such a slim volume (less than 200 pages) with so much information.
Morgan points out that which should be obvious to any thinking person: evolution does not have any goal, it is rather reactive to the environmental forces brought to bear on the organism. Furthermore, not all evolutionary changes redound to the long-term advantage of the species. The organism, and the species, seeks only survival in the current circumstance. Whatever mechanism for survival works, over time, becomes the favored one for the group. Over hundreds or thousands of generations, the changes in the organism that result are what we call evolutionary.
The Aquatic Ape Theory postulates a re-entry period for that group of primates that became our early ancestors. Probably, it is theorized, they lived in shallow water when their environment was inundated, and after a long time returned to a terrestrial lifestyle. The theory explains much that is inexplicable by the so-called "Savannah Theory" so dear to the hearts of most anthropologists.
This is an exciting book, well written and well-thought-out.
Joseph Pierre
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
28 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An aha experience; and a challenge to the establishment!, April 14, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: The Scars of Evolution (Paperback)
Many years ago I read Elaine Morgan's Descent of Woman and was surprised at its quality and amused at her parody of the speculations by the traditional anthropologists, as found in the best sellers by Morris, Audry, and Lorenz, on the origins of us humans as humans. The anthropologists had seemed unimaginative and not altogether logical in their speculations on the environment and behavior of our immediate predecessors-- in a word, they seemed klutzy. Now I read Scars and realize that Ms. Morgan was not doing a parody but sincerely developing an alternative explanation centered on the Aquatic Ape Theory. This more mature work has facts that will grab you and ideas that will stick with you. Ms. Morgan is a writer and the book is written for all of us, so it reads well. But what makes this an outstanding book are two things: 1.She systematically puts together many facts and ideas, some highly speculative, some inarguably true, some striking, some pedestrian, into a whole that is greater than the sum of its parts and therefore logically dificult and perhaps impossible to refute. 2.She systematically addresses each alternative argument and each argument that has been used to attack her ideas and counters it. Do not be misled; this slight, easy to read book by a non-professional anthropologist is important. The anthropologists in this area have a history of internal strife marked by dogmatism and contentiousness. You can bet they react in this way toward Ms. Morgan, although they prefer to ignore her, a non-professional anthropolgist. But after Scars they may not be successful, and anything you can do-- such as asking questions of anthropologists and questioning the answers you get-- will be a plus. For her ideas deserve full and careful consideration and a scientific search for evidence that will support or abolish them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Worth your time, January 26, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: The Scars of Evolution (Paperback)
Elaine Morgan, the successful Welsh screenwriter, has made a second career out of defending the Aquatic Ape Theory, first proposed by Sir Alister Hardy in the early sixties. Sadly, "The Scars of Evolution/What Our Bodies Tell Us About Human Origins" does not have many of the qualities that made her earlier books, "The Descent Of Woman" and "The Aquatic Ape" so much fun to read.
"The Scars of Evolution" continues the ongoing saga of the Aquatic Ape Theory, which hypothesizes that our proto-human ancestors spent a significant period of time in an aquatic or semi-aquatic environment. The evidence in favor of this theory is mostly indirect, but it is appealing, unless you are a paleontologist with a career invested in more traditional explanations (Danny Yee's interviews are more detailed, and a running debate is on one of the Usenet groups).
Morgan, who is a delightful writer, seems to be devoted to sounding more scientific in this book, and the delight and fire shown in her two previous books on the subject is subdued. It's a shame, and also a mistake. She isn't a scientist (although she's amazingly well-read), and will never attain credibility in the hidebound world of paleoanthropology, so what she loses in readability she is unlikely to recover in advancing her cause. If you haven't been exposed to this semi-obscure controversy over human origins, "The Scars of Evolution" will give you the gist of it--but if you want to enjoy the experience, start with "The Descent of Woman".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No