15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A beautifully nuanced performance, March 18, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Schütz - Musikalische Exequien / Mellon · de Reyghere · Zanetti · Crook · Fouchécourt · Lamy · Machart · Kooy · Lika · La Chappelle Royale · Herreweghe (Audio CD)
Somebody from Houston, TX, below, gives this recording three stars because of the very characteristic which, in my eyes, makes this recording so wonderful. Buy this disc and judge for yourself which one of us has it right. My Texan friend doesn't like the one-voice-per-part approach taken by Herreweghe on this disc. I, on the other hand, happen to prefer a small chorus composed mainly of the soloists themselves to a large, more impersonal, chorus. Moreover, small "choruses" formed by the soloists singing together were very common at the time most of baroque music was written. In fact, a large free-standing chorus was a rarity. When Handel sometimes employed such choruses, it was newsworthy enough to be reported in newspapers. So Herreweghe here is simply following the authentic performance tradition. There are still people who object to the whole practice of period performance. They are entitled to their view, but many of us are very thankful to conductors like Herreweghe for bringing baroque music to us in its original guise. This is a wonderful recording. In addition to Musicalische Exequien, it contains several motets and mini-cantatas from Geistliche Chormusic and Kleine Geistliche Concerte. Herreweghe recently revisited some of these pieces with Collegium Vocale (the CD is entitled Geistliche Chormusic). By the way, my Texan friend might like this second version of Geistliche Chormusic better: it is based on choral singing, and it is some of the most nuanced and spiritual choral singing there can be. I suggest that you buy both of these recordings. Only three motets overlap (SWV379, SWV391 and SWV386). One of them, SWV379 (So fahr ich hin zu Jesu Christ) is so preternaturally beautiful that you will want to own as many versions of it as you can. The soloists on the Geistliche Chormusic CD are Agnes Mellon, Mark Padmore and Peter Kooy. All of them have been performing Schutz's music for years. Combined with Herreweghe's, their collective insight into Schutz's music resulted in a truly outstanding recording. I have recently come by another Schutz recording which I greatly enjoyed: Schutz's Lamenti & Concerti (Musicalische Compagney). I think the group is now defunct, but back in the mid-80's they used to have some pretty impressive vocal group: Padmore, Cordier, Ragin and van der Kamp. Definitely buy it if you find it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Fine performance of beautiful works, November 17, 2007
This review is from: Schütz - Musikalische Exequien / Mellon · de Reyghere · Zanetti · Crook · Fouchécourt · Lamy · Machart · Kooy · Lika · La Chappelle Royale · Herreweghe (Audio CD)
These are sensitive, nuanced performances of wonderful pieces-- but they are not my favorite. These seem just a bit languid to me, compared with John Eliot Gardiner -- my preference is for his more rhythmically driven interpretation. But that's just my preference. These are beautiful realizations of this not-well-known-enough music.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Espiritualidad, patriotismo y sensibilidad: todo en uno, May 1, 2004
This review is from: Schütz - Musikalische Exequien / Mellon · de Reyghere · Zanetti · Crook · Fouchécourt · Lamy · Machart · Kooy · Lika · La Chappelle Royale · Herreweghe (Audio CD)
Esta breve antología a la obra de Schutz con gran maestría unifica la más pura y elevada espiritualidad teutónica cristiana, los más vivos y exaltados sentimientos patrios alemanes, y la sensibilidad extrema, lírica y estética propia de los más grandes maestros de la música.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No