6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Now this is more like it..., May 12, 2005
This review is from: Schism: Part One of Triad (Saga of the Skolian Empire) (Pt. 1) (Hardcover)
After Skyfall, with its cliche Roca/Eldrinson romance plot, I was a bit apprehensive about what I'd find in this book. Happily, I can report that this novel is a definite improvement over the last one.
While it does deal heavily with Eldrinson and Roca again, this time Roca comes across as a person, rather than a perfect fantasy romance heroine. And Eldrinson actually grows as a character; he starts out as quite provincial and sexist, and is forced to open his eyes to the realities of the harsh universe he lives in. Eldrinson's never been a favorite of mine, but in this book I enjoyed reading about him.
There is a very strong focus on Soz, Roca and Eldrinson's daughter who in earlier books was a great warrior and even became the leader of the Skolian military (Primary Inversion, The Radiant Seas). In this book, a much younger Soz defies her father and goes to the Skolian Jagernaut military academy. Even in her youth, she's a terrific character, with a nice balance of strengths and flaws. I found her reaction to all the pressures she was under quite believable, especially near the end where she behaves in a way that will be recognizable to overstressed students and cadets everywhere. She gives in to temptation, justifies it to herself, but comes clean in the end.
Kurj, Roca's eldest son, also comes across as more of a person than he has in the past. While I like that he's getting more development and is no longer being treated as an unfeeling antagonist, I do fear that he will become less intriguing with too much exposure. After Spherical Harmonic, I found Dyhianna Selei to be more sympathetic but much less interesting. I'd hate to see Kurj go the same way.
We also get some background on Soz's older brother, Althor.
There was a lot of development done on Shannon (another of Roca and Eldrinson's many children) and his relationship to the Blue Dale Archers. The Archers are fascinating (if a bit elvish *G*), but again, too much exposure will probably make them less intriguing. Sometimes the mystery is more interesting than the explanation. I thought we got a good balance in this novel, though. Still, I look forward to finding out more about why the old Ruby Empire engineered the Lyshriol system and its occupants. This mystery has only grown over the last few novels, but I'm enjoying it immensely.
Once again, a member of the Skolian royal family is captured and tortured by an Aristo. That part seemed rather repetitive, as this is a common occurrence in Asaro's books. By the time she's through, that whole family is going to be completely traumatized and dysfunctional. *G* However, in this case it is done so that Eldrinson's character can change and grow, so I'm not going to complain too much.
Overall, this book was a good read. We got a lot of character background and development. There was a decent amount of technical science fiction, but nothing too overwhelming. Asaro's last couple of books only included the science fiction aspects as set dressing, so seeing the advanced tech treated with some depth and as integral to the story was nice.
To sum up, I enjoyed this book and would even recommend it as a good entry point into Asaro's Skolian Empire series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another Excellent Addition to the Skolian Saga, January 17, 2005
This review is from: Schism: Part One of Triad (Saga of the Skolian Empire) (Pt. 1) (Hardcover)
Schism is another excellent entry into the Skolian universe of books. It features one of my favorite characters - Sauscony - that Asaro has created. The manner in which Asaro has written these books (this is the tenth novel), moving many years backwards and forwards in time and shifting from character to character as she fills in the stories of the Ruby pharoh clan gives one an interesting and sometimes dizzying perspective on the characters. One would think that already knowing a particular character's fate would make a story about the early years of that character less than compelling, but Asaro pulls it off. As ever, I am looking forward to the next entry in this saga.
P.S. Amazon Readers/Buyers beware. Beware reviewer Harriet Klausner, who supposedly read reviewed many thousands of books on Amazon, including this one. She always gives four or five stars (usually five stars) and her reviews are utterly formulaic, making one wonder if she/he/they actually read the books. In any event, how can anyone love every one of the thousands and thousands of books she/he/they have supposedly read?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Asaro's back on track, February 10, 2005
This review is from: Schism: Part One of Triad (Saga of the Skolian Empire) (Pt. 1) (Hardcover)
This book is a bit different from the more recent entries by Asaro in her Skolian series, better. For all of us who have not been thrilled by her trend toward sexy romance, Asaro returns to complex sci-fi in Triad. We learn about the military and the commitment required of cadets at the academy as seen through the experiences of the 17-year old Soz, a novice, whom we already know will be the future leader of the Skolian Empire. We also begin to understand the personal conflict Soz has with her father over her decision not to marry and stay on her home world, but to pursue a career in the military that will put her in harm's way during the coming war.
This book is not a good place to begin the series. Triad is a backstory. (I prefer to start with Primary Inversion.) Asaro does not publish this series in chronological order. The books may be about any one of the 15 or so main Rhon characters during three generations at any point in their lives. If you have read any of the other books in the series you know how the story began in Triad turns out. Rather, Triad fills in gaps in the Valdorian family saga and helps us understand why they are the way they are. They do not always behave as I would have expected them to. After all, they are Rhon and considered royals. Eldrin is more close-minded. Soz is more hotheaded. Kurj is more human. Althor is more confused. Shannon is more complex. In some ways it is very comforting to know that things are going to work out for these people, at least for a while. I found this book to be much more interesting than I expected. I cannot wait for the next installment. I just wish the books had better cover art. No sex or sexy thoughts in Triad; some general references to bi-sexuality and homosexuality.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No