Schoenberg: Piano Concerto

Arnold Schoenberg (Artist), Anton Webern (Artist), Alban Berg (Artist), Pierre Boulez (Artist), Mitsuko Uchida (Artist), Cleveland Orchestra (Artist) | Format: Audio CD

Product Details

• Audio CD (April 10, 2001)
• SPARS Code: DDD
• Number of Discs: 1
• Label: Philips
• ASIN: B000058BGZ
• In-Print Editions: MP3 Download
• Average Customer Review: 5.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (12 customer reviews)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #16,468 in Music (See Top 100 in Music)
  • #1 in Music > Classical > Historical Periods > Modern, 20th, & 21st Century > Instruments > Keyboard > Piano
  • #8 in Music > Classical > Historical Periods > Modern, 20th, & 21st Century > Forms & Genres > Sonatas
  • #33 in Music > Classical > Forms & Genres > Sonatas > General

Editorial Reviews

From International Record Review - subscribe now

Mitsuko Uchida has been a committed exponent of Schoenberg's Piano Concerto for over a decade now. It is a work which remains controversial in its adaptation of the serial method to an almost Brahmsian harmonic palette, wedded to a formal approach that takes up the integrated design, and textural richness, of Schoenberg's pre-atonal works. Certainly in terms of the balance between soloist and orchestra, this recording clarifies the often capricious interplay to a degree previously unheard on disc (and most likely in the concert hall too).Interpretatively, it combines Pollini's dynamism, without the hectoring touch that creeps into the Adagio's climactic passages, and Brendel's lucidity, avoiding the deadpan feeling that pervades his final Giocoso. Uchida is mindful of the concerto's wartime context, and the opening Andante builds to an intensity matched by no other modern recording: clearly life which was so easy cannot remain so. The brief but violent Molto allegro has a gritty intensity; as elsewhere, Boulez now seems happy to give the music a degree of rubato that allows it room to breathe, without compromising its long-term cohesion. The Adagio has a cumulative expressiveness, without false pathos, the rhetoric of its central cadenza (track 3, 1'54") maintaining an almost Classical poise. Only in the march strains of the Giocoso is there a slight loss of focus, but this is arguably as integral to the music as is the shade of C major that inflects the orchestra's last defiant gestures. Of the solo piano works, Schoenberg's Op. 11 will be familiar to Uchida fans. The respective portmanteau-like format and expressive Angst of the first two pieces have not been served better since Pollini's classic 1975 account, though in the tumultuous third piece, Uchida's textural precision does allow the music's intensity to uncoil. The first and third of the Op. 19 miniatures are again marginally too deliberate, though the Mahler evocation of the final piece is matchlessly atmospheric. Subtlety and patience pay dividends in the Tristan-esque yearning of Berg's sonata, given a formal clarity almost in spite of itself, while being more spontaneous than Pollini. The symmetries inherent in each movement of the Webern Variations are faithfully delineated, culminating in an extraordinarily inward account of the final section's coda. This is an account to rank with Pollini and Zimerman as an exposé of the performer's individual sensibilities.Strongly recommended then, with a final thought to Philips that it has, in Viktoria Mullova, probably the greatest living exponent of Schoenberg's Violin Concerto. How about this as part of a complementary disc of violin music from the Second Viennese School?Graham Simpson

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

38 of 39 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent rendition of Schoenberg's Piano Concerto, May 29, 2001

By 

"janus_kreisler_sachs" (the Midwest, USA) - See all my reviews

This review is from: Schoenberg: Piano Concerto (Audio CD)

Alfred Brendel has done three recordings of Schoenberg's Piano Concerto, and I own two of them (the DG one with Kubelik and the much later one on Philips, the latter nla). I previously thought Brendel's latest recording (with Gielen at the podium) to be the last word concerning this concerto, but I was wrong. Uchida and Boulez are much more fiery, employing a very wide spectrum of dynamics and articulation (which Schoenberg's scores demand). I thought the first movement was a bit sluggish at first, but it works beautifully, and the more contrapuntal variations are more clearly focussed because of the added spaciousness (though not even Boulez's legenday ear could clarify the very thick textures of some passages). The second movement has a greater sense of angst and conflict than Brendel and Gielen, and the third movement more pain. Brendel and Gielen are more playfully nonchalant in the last movement. Uchida and Boulez seem to portray the movement as having an eerie undurcurrent, as if the troubles of the second and third movements are still kept in mind.

The solo piano items are also very good, though I have some reservations. It surprises me that Uchida executes a crescendo instead of the printed decrscendo in one passage of Op. 11 No. 1 (Uchida is usually very faithful to the score). But Op. 11 No. 3 is incredibly intense, more so than the recordings by Gould or Pollini (though Pollini's recording is on the whole very good). Op. 19 is performed with utmost sensitivity and warmth -- the bells of the last piece are exquisitely voiced and controlled. Webern's Variations are also warmly expressive -- the third movement's closing variation seems to disappear into the ether (as it should), but the second movement is rather slow, diminshing the sense of manic energy that it should have. Uchida's performance of Berg's Sonata is one of the finest ever recorded. She takes Berg's numerous tempo changes to heart and follows them more closely than any other recording I've listened to (compare Pollini, for example). The result is very intense yet also very coherent, as it should be.

Those of you who love these works (as I do) should not hesitate. This is the best recording of Schoenberg's Piano Concerto so far.

33 of 34 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Among Uchida's Best, December 26, 2004

By 

Jeffrey G. Jones (Northern California, USA) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)    (REAL NAME)   

This review is from: Schoenberg: Piano Concerto (Audio CD)

A little perspective: I am a 21-year old pianist who has made it his obligation in the past couple of years to thoroughly internalize Schoenberg's Op. 11 and 19, both of which are found on this CD. I am a stickler for following every little marking Schoenberg wrote, but I see a lot of room for creativity, too. My reference recordings have been those of Charles Rosen and Maurizio Pollini, both of which I hold in high esteem for their clean precision and abstract imagery. For the Berg sonata, I am partial to Maria Yudina's exuberant (and hard to find) recording. For the Webern variations, Richter's live performance in Vienna is my favorite. The Concerto is new to me, but I pulled out some recordings from the library to compare it to - Gould, Brendel, Ax, Peter Serkin.

Besides this disc, I have also heard Uchida albums of Schubert, Debussy, Mozart, and Chopin. I find that her playing tends to be dark-hued, dimly lit and compellingly non-intuitive, with an amazing command of passages calling for gossamer textures. She can also use impossibly slow tempi at times, coming up with conceptions so expansive that you can stick your head in between the notes. Both of those qualities make her Schoenberg Op. 19 quite different from the others I've heard, but the concept of space is the more striking and memorable. Uchida seems to be convinced that it is the silences in these tiny pieces that gives them their meaning, and long ritards to silence mark almost every bar. Yet the pieces never fall apart, because this is entirely in their character. It's a free interpretation, to be sure, and not one which is 100% faithful, but it's highly sympathetic and quite effective.

Her Op. 11 is more conventionally beautiful, and it's also easily the best I've heard. Never mind the fact that Uchida's hands could never actually span the gigantic chords in the third piece - the editing job is seamless and the musical content is what's important. These readings are far more humane than those of the ferocious Pollini, and the Romantic warmth bleeds through even though the sound is not plush. The influence of Brahms on Schoenberg can clearly be heard through this truly stellar reading.

The Berg Sonata is merely good. There are some beautiful moments and there is some real tension here, but Uchida seems to see this as a conventional sonata-allegro movement packing a few extra pounds around the middle, and that's exactly how it comes off. The Mahlerian drama is muted - I think it takes someone as incandescantly insane as Maria Yudina to really do it justice. Uchida certainly follows Berg's markings more closely than Yudina does, but they're not well enough internalized and so they don't have the effect that they should have.

The Webern is a welcome addition. Too many recordings of Webern have an excessive cleanliness to them which makes them alienating and creepy. This, on the other hand, is warm in the same way that Uchida's Schoenberg Op. 11 is, imbuing this fragmentary, elusive music with a real soul.

The Concerto is the most complex piece on the album, and this performance, by Uchida at the piano with Boulez conducting the Cleveland Orchestra, is the hardest for me to judge. No doubt that it is fearsomely difficult to play, and she does a fantastic job. Every page bristles with new and different difficulties, but these are not merely pianistic bells and whistles like you hear in Rachmaninoff or Prokofiev. The importance Schoenberg puts on each awkwardly placed note makes this piece doubly difficult to execute. Uchida's overall conception is smooth and highly intelligible, with a fantastic sound. The only thing it really lacks is style. The Haydn-esque finale is rather flat compared with any of the other major recordings, such as Gould or Brendel just to name a couple. Although the form is there, the spark of life is a bit weak. Nonetheless this is a high-quality recording.

There is much to recommend this CD, and there is more than enough original contribution here to merit a listen by anyone interested in the Second Viennese School. Go pick it up!

31 of 33 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars A Great Work, November 2, 2001

By 

Jack Jones (Woodland Hills, CA United States) - See all my reviews

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: Schoenberg: Piano Concerto (Audio CD)

If you're a fan of Schoenberg in general, or the piano concerto in particular, there is no need to hesitate with this wonderful recording. This may be my favorite 20th century piece and it's certainly the version I like best. Previously my top contender (now sadly out of print) was Pollini with Abbado and the Berlin Philharmonic. It is another great version worth hearing, my only real complaint there being that you can hear the numerous edits where they cut and pasted the performance together. That problem does not exist here with Boulez and Uchida. The piano concerto is a dense, contrapuntal work and Boulez makes sure that none of the parts get lost. Uchida's playing is superb, concise yet emotional. The Cleveland Orchestra shows no strain even in this works difficult passages. The only thing that strikes me negatively about this Uchida/Boulez version is that the second movement seems a bit fast to me but it works.

For those who are not yet fans of Schoenberg, this is a great place to start. I see the piano concerto as the highlight of Schoenberg's 12-tone output, though some would argue for Variations for Orchestra, op. 31. What attracts me to his music is that Schoenberg, more than being the post-Romantic composer evident in his first ten tonal published works, is really a "hyper"-Romantic. Bigger than life, rich orchestrations, sweeping melodies and thick harmony. And though he has the firmest command of music theory, structure, etc., it is the emotional impact of this piece that really shines through for me. By using 12-tone harmony he is able to change moods on a dime and can express horror and delight in ways tonal music cannot.

In addition to the concerto you get hear his first atonal piece, a great op. 11, the short but wonderful op. 19, and the two main solo piano works of his well-known students Webern and Berg. The Webern is a masterwork in balance and is fantastic here. I now own two copies of the Berg and it still doesn't strike me, but perhaps in time.

This is a great cd.