From Publishers Weekly
Set during the summer of 1947, Matthews's (John Riley's Daughter) stirring novel at once captures the period nuances of life in post-WWII South Carolina and limns a timeless portrait of family sorrows and secrets. Fourteen-year-old narrator Afton's brother, Francis, perished two years ago at age 18 on a battlefield in Europe. When her mother's silent, mysterious brother, whom Afton never knew existed, comes to visit, Afton suspects that her mother is harboring secrets from the past. Mama will say only that Bailey has been through "an ordeal" and needs time "to get on his feet," and asks Afton not to mention Bailey's arrival in her letters to her father, at sea with the merchant marines. Matthews deftly and subtly draws a parallel between Francis and Bailey: Afton notices that her mother's face lights up when she talks to Bailey, the same as it did when she spoke to Francis, and her mother even offers Bailey her brother's room. The heroine dreams at night about her brother "cold and hungry in his grave," and wonders if it is wartime experiences that haunt the man as he paces incessantly in Francis's room. The girl blames herself when Bailey is falsely suspected of murder, after which Mama discloses the cause of his unhappiness. In a poignant, pivotal moment, Afton's unfailingly candid, credible voice articulates both her guilt and the sense of loss that she and her mother share ("And then it hits me so hard I feel as though my heart might burst. Mama loves Bailey the way I love Francis. She probably thought he was dead. Then she looked up one day, and there he was again"). A hopeful ending caps this gracefully crafted fiction, starring a memorable heroine and a strong supporting cast. Ages 11-14.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Gr 6-8-Set in South Carolina during the summer of 1947, this novel explores family and small-town dynamics from the perspective of 14-year-old Afton. Her father works for a shipping company out of Charleston and her brother was killed in the war. The girl and her mother have a tempestuous relationship, and the arrival of an uncle whom her mother had never mentioned before strains things further. She is told to be understanding toward Bailey because he has suffered terribly, but she is fearful of this odd, mournful man. The nosy townspeople assume he was a prisoner of war, but Afton becomes consumed with finding out about his past and why her mother is so secretive about it. The murder of a local woman sets things in motion, and because of some of the things Afton has told her best friend, Bailey, who served time in prison, is accused of the crime. The real murderer is found, but Afton's mother is terrified of how people will react to the scandal. When Afton realizes what the years of keeping secrets have done to her mother, she decides to confess her own part in exposing Bailey's story. The mood of the book is like a storm brewing, blowing through town and then clearing the air, a metaphor that the author uses throughout. The resolution comes quickly, and not all questions are answered, but there is a sense of hope that the family will weather the storm and survive. A thoughtful read that should be appreciated by those who enjoyed Patricia Reilly Giff's Lily's Crossing (Delacorte, 1997) and Mary Downing Hahn's Stepping on the Cracks (Clarion, 1991).
Cheri Estes, Detroit Country Day Middle School, Beverly Hills, MI
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.