From School Library Journal
Grade 5-8. In this third book in the series, Wolfgang is now the leader of the club and is recruiting new members to play in a band. With the addition of a tattooed guitar player, the boys form the first punk-jug garage band, "Scratch and the Sniffs." The plot revolves around the growth of the band and the difficulties the boys encounter finding places to play. Eventually, they perform in front of a subway station and at a Goodwill collection box. While the format indicates a young audience, beginning chapter book readers won't relate to the situations. For example, at one point the narrator suggests the name of the club should be the "He-Man Couldn't-Get-A-Date-If-We-Wanted-To Club." More sophisticated teens are likely to find the story uninteresting and the characters undeveloped. A book that may find a limited audience among older reluctant readers.?Ann M. Burlingame, North Regional Library, Raleigh, NC
Copyright 1997 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 5^-7. The misfits of the He-Man Woman Haters Club are back, and they've recruited two new members: Scratch, a stringy guitar player, and Cecil, a gentle and synaptically challenged boy with the inappropriate nickname of Killer. The club changes leaders with each installment of Lynch's series, and this time, it's wheelchair-bound Wolf at the helm. He decides the He-Men need to start their own band. Playing a cacophonous mix of guitar, drums, triangle, and washboard, Scratch and the Sniffs dub their sound jug-punk. Their first concert lands them a music video deal, but dreams of stardom crumble when they find their "producer" is only trying to get on
America's Funniest Home Videos. Lynch keeps the pace fast and the humor sharp; he flirts with a rougher edge here by making the enigmatic Scratch homeless, but he doesn't press the issue, and the tone stays light. Scratch's disappearance at the end of this novel is sure to make readers eager to read the next installment.
Randy Meyer