3 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
"In Search of"... a Better Book Than This, November 16, 2004
Richard Bartlett's "In Search of Reptiles and Amphibians" is a collection of stories from the field that attempts to relate the joy that herp enthusiasts (those who enjoy reptiles and amphibians) experience in their many adventures in search of these wonderful creatures, but fails to connect for several reasons.
As soon as you begin to read the book, you will notice countless errors (extra spaces between words, words missing or misspelled) that severely detract from the message the author wishes to convey.
Assuming you can trip over all the errors and still continue to read, you'll find that the author is a huge fan of adjectives. It is as if someone instructed the writer that a sentence is sub-par if it contains less than a dozen descriptive words or so. It appears as if the author were trying for Thoreau, but only achieves awkwardness.
Also, I see little more in the stories involved other than glorification of the author. The basic plot of virtually every anecdote is "I found something really interesting. Everyone look at me. You can't find them anymore, so don't even try." The stories are typically very short (2-3 pages) and in an attempt to come back to topic, a description of the species in question is presented after the ramblings.
Another thing that concerns me is that the author condemns the practice of collecting animals from the wild on several occasions throughout the book (Ch. 10, etc.), but in a subsequent chapter talks about keeping the only specimen of a species he has seen in 30 years (Ch. 11). Not very responsible (in writing or in practice), in my opinion.
If the reader is just starting an interest in reptiles and amphibians, then these stories might be of value. Anyone with more experience/knowledge in the field than a novice would do better to find something else to read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No