4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Younger kids enjoyed it, looked spectacular but the editing not great, October 8, 2009
This review is from: The Secret of Moonacre ( Le secret de Moonacre ) ( The Little White Horse ) [ NON-USA FORMAT, PAL, Reg.2 Import - United Kingdom ] (DVD)
There were so many pluses in this film. It was spectacularly filmed. The settings and houses used were perfect. Set in semi Wilderness there was a wild and untamed look to it, but it was also civilised enough to see that it was a place in decay. It is the valley of Moonacre which has been beset by a curse from the Moon Princess because of the greed of two families. If the families cannot get rid of the curse by the 500th rise of the full moon then the entire valley will be destroyed. ONly a true Moon Princess can break the curse. And that Moon Princess is played by Dakato Blue Richards.
Left an orphan by the untimely death of her father, she returns to Moonacre with only her governess and an old book as her legacy. Her father having gambled her wealth away. They are attacked on the way by ruffians but manage to escape ok but at the Mansion of Moonare are met by her mildly forbidding Uncle and his rather dark dog who is 'unlikely' to attack a Merryweather.
The house is a wonderful picture of mild decay. the creamy plastered walls are gorgeous, for all those of you who want to discover your inner shabby chic. And while the costumes are outlandish John-Paul Gaultier interpretations of bustled late Victorian fashion they are rather charming. In fact much of the forbidding aspect of Moonacre is removed by the strange but extraodinaruly bright costuming. Contrasting that with the workers in the field - they have plumped for Medieval wear - leather caps and black clothing.
The Merryweather's enemys are rivals in the valley the Denils (Sorry I can't remember the name!) are also in medieval style clothing, they dine in old style banqueting halls, and Tim Curry does a great evil turn as the head of that household. The boys of this household form a strange little ruffian gang which has been costumed straight out of a Clockwork Orange - complete with eye makeup and bowler hats. Rather disconcerting.
As the true blue Moon Princess only she can see where the Moon Pearls have been concealed and prevent the curse from destroying the valley, but she has only until the very next moonrise to do it.
It is not entirely clear why she is motivated to do things in the movie, although it is clear in the book. And some of the editing, and story motivations are lacking. Why should she need to sneak into the Denil's fortress to present them with the key? Why does the older moon princess suddenly decide that they should split up when searching for her? Why does no one notice the governess is missing before presenting her at the end of the book.
There seems to be a big production of the Moon Princess in Bare feet, but this isn't really explained. And why does the Moon Princess have to jump into the sea, and why is she saved?
The movie looks great, and my littlest one who couldn't sit through Ice Age 3 or Up without demanding to be taken out because she was too scared - sat through this movie like a lamb. She was enthralled by it. The scary bits weren't that scary, and the colour and action was clearly engaging.
However for older watchers I think the flaws in the movie will be too great to be glossed over by Ioan Gruffud's incredible screen Charisma.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Dakota Blue Richards (of "The Golden Compass" fame) as Spirited Heroine, February 22, 2010
This review is from: The Secret of Moonacre ( Le secret de Moonacre ) ( The Little White Horse ) [ NON-USA FORMAT, PAL, Reg.2 Import - United Kingdom ] (DVD)
"The Secret of Moonacre" is the filmed adaptation of the fantasy novel "The Little White Horse" written Elizabeth Goudge. Originally published in 1946, the book had been turned into a TV mini-series in 1994 as "Moonacre." This new feature film stars Dakota Blue Richards, known for her praised portrayal of Lyra Belacqua of "The Golden Compass," as Maria Merryweather, a spirited heroine of the story. The film is directed by Gabor Csupo, director of "Bridge to Terabithia" (2007), but his new film is not just as emotionally involving as his previous effort.
Set in Victorian Britain, the story follows Maria Merryweather (Dakota Blue Richards), whose father suddenly passed away. Left penniless and orphaned, 13-year-old Maria moves to her uncle's Moonacre Manor with her nurse Miss Heliotrope (Juliet Stevenson). Maria's moody uncle Sir Benjamin Merryweather (Ioan Gruffudd), who strictly forbids Maria from going into the woods, seems to be hiding a secret or two about the estate and its legend. In this quiet valley Maria senses mysterious powers going on, as well as some danger coming.
Other characters include Coeur De Noir (Tim Curry), Robin De Noir (Augustus Prew), Loveday (Natascha McElhone) and a big black "dog" Wrolf. Long-lasting feuds and romances are also implied.
"The Secret of Moonacre" should have been a great fantasy movie, with Dakota Blue Richards as the feisty, smart and independent heroine. Unfortunately, though her character remains likable and delectable, the film's underwritten script doesn't offer her chances to show what Maria really can do, or wants to do.
What is worse, Moonacre hardly looks mysterious; Special effects (especially that of The Little White Horse, original title of the film) needs improvement. Action scenes greatly suffer from the uneven pace and choppy editing. The filmmakers cannot settle on a consistent tone with silly jokes and weak romances.
At the time of writing this review, the sequel to "The Golden Compass" is not likely to materialize, so it is only natural that those who are impressed with Dakota Blue Richards like me would expect something refreshing or charming as her Lyla Belacqua here. Though Dakota Blue Richards again provides a strong performance as the young heroine, "The Secret of Moonacre" needs a bigger budget and a better screenplay.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
