Customer Reviews

Secret (Standard Edition) DVD

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

The 2007 Hong-Kong / Taiwanese film "Secret" is one of the recent pleasant surprises for me. I know Jay Chou has been a big star in the music scene of Asia, but I never thought he could make such an emotionally engrossing film. Those who were disappointed with his rather colorless performance in "Curse of the Golden Flower" will be amazed to see Jay Chou as gifted storyteller in "Secret," his debut as director.

Not much should be revealed about the story of "Secret." I only say it starts as a romance. Jay Chou plays a new student at art school, Ye Xiang Lun. In the old school building he encounters a beautiful girl student named Lu Xiao Yu (fantastic Lunmei Kwai) playing a mysterious tune on piano. Asked about the strangely absorbing song, she answers playfully, whispering to him that it is "a secret," a secret that cannot be told.

Yes, the romantic love story has a secret which no one should know. I'm sorry that I cannot disclose even the nature of it. All I can say is, when you think you know everything, you haven't even got a clue. Perhaps you should enjoy the love story of the two likable leads and you will see what I mean by and by.

Anthony Wong plays the father of Jay Chou's character (as in "Initial D") and gives a comical touch to the film's slightly nostalgic world. There is a "piano battle" sequence that might remind us of "The Legend of 1900" (but done with less bravura), which is an enjoyable scene and also a showcase for Jay Chou's musical talent. Jay Chou's approach as director is surprisingly orthodox and he seems to always keep in mind that his goal is telling a good story. And he is very good at that.

Beautifully shot "Secret" is a refreshing and well-told romantic story with originality. Strongly recommended for anyone who loves good romance.

This movie certainly exceeded my expectations. I can't say much about the film without giving away the plot, but take my advice: if you like romance movies, you will love this.

I love movies with excellent soundtrack. This movie is no exception. Every song in this movie is beautiful. After watching this movie, I spent hours on the internet looking for the sheet music to this soundtrack so I could learn how to play them. The plot itself was also touching as well. I was glad it had a good ending.

Jay Chou wrote this story, composed most of the music for it, directed it and acted the lead role. The love story is good, with a twist of course, but what really makes me love this is the music. It's gorgeous. I listen to it over and over. This showcases three talented pianists, Jay himself being the best. He made it fun to watch them play. He also plays cello beautifully, and you will hear it briefly here.
As others have said, the cinematography is beautiful too. So far, the best movie I have.

I would like to add that, although difficult to determine why---with multiple viewings the love story becomes more and more enhanced and gets deeper and deeper---again, it's like a magic film for that reason. I would also like to echo the reviewer who said "When you think you know everything"....the mystery is is good!

This is an entertaining flick and an excellent Blu-ray Disc. The movie has some surprising plot twists, but I can't really say any more without spoiling it. Jay Chou (INITIAL D, CURSE OF THE GOLDEN FLOWER) both directs and stars in this film, and he acquits himself surprisingly well. The English subtitles are fine. Recommended.

one of the best films i have seen in a long time, secret is engrossing, beautiful, and haunting. the cinamatography is well done and i love how music is woven throught the strands of the story.
jay chou exceeds expectations as an actor and this is a triumph for his debut as a director. i hope to see more like this from him.

Excellent movie for middle schoolers who are learning Mandarin to watch and compare with popular love story movies such as Twilight and New Moon. Better music too.

Having seen the film before I knew there were different/better versions of the subtitles; although not perfect they complemented the romantic atmosphere of the film better than the ones on the DVD - though these are more complete.

The actual storyline is fantastic. A romance with a twist and plenty of adept piano playing.

The movie I received shipped instantly. It is sealed and brand new just like in the inscription. GREAT BUY!

One of the best movies ever made, i enjoyed every moment..
the most beautiful way to fall in love and find love even 20 years ahead or before'