From School Library Journal
Grade 3-6–Elementary school student Tiernay West is a wonderfully eccentric character who is determined to find buried treasure, become a true adventurer, and right past wrongs. She knows that other kids think she's weird but she is confident that she is on the right track to becoming a world-renowned explorer. She is not adept socially but becomes friends with Kevin, the son of her mother's boyfriend, and they spy on a bully to try to find the Revolutionary War sword that was stolen from a local antique shop. Easily able to justify anything so long as it aids an investigation, Tiernay and Kevin are placed in real peril when she spies on nasty Daryll Jensen. Excerpts of Tiernay's internal monologue start many chapters. One cannot help but laugh at the melodrama inherent in the protagonist's determined personality. Tiernay is an irrepressible role model in her unwavering self-confidence, intellectual curiosity, and sense of humor. Like the waiter who remembers she likes her soda with lime, cherries, and lemon wedges, readers will not forget Tiernay West anytime soon.
–B. Allison Gray, John Jermain Library, Sag Harbor, NY Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 3-5. Irrepressible middle-grader Tiernay West longs for her divorced father, who travels the globe doing research for his adventure novels. Donning a straw hat that she fancies an adventurer would wear, she eavesdrops on her mother and their neighbors, eager to find a mystery. After overhearing rumors about Revolutionary War gold buried in their Connecticut town, she leaps into action, and with help from her mother's boyfriend's geeky son, she sets out to find treasure--discovering something about her family roots along the way. The plot's connections are a bit tenuous, and readers may lose interest in the story's genealogy angle. But Tiernay's fierce self-confidence and individuality will appeal to many readers, and veterans of clique warfare and bullying will cheer her on as she exposes the school's biggest creep. Simner tucks some lessons about responsibility, peer pressure, and accepting help into the story, so teachers may want to use this in character-education units.
Gillian EngbergCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved