14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good, but inaccuracies are worrying, October 27, 2010
Veronica Buckley's biography of Francoise d'Aubigne is readable and engaging, but has some flaws which make me hesitant about giving it a wholehearted recommendation. These relate to complete misunderstandings of French history. The recurring one is that the author seems to think that the French Parlements were the equivalent of the English Parliament. This occurs mostly during the chapters covering the Fronde, and again when she speaks of Louis XIV's contempt for Charles II being bound by his Parliament's control of supply, contrasted with Louis's "toothless Parliament". This is nonsense. The French Parlements were courts of justice; they were in no way representative bodies, and their attempts to influence royal policy came from royal edicts having to be registered with them to be passed as law. Remonstrations or discussions of the edicts were used to try to change or prevent their passing. That the writer seems oblivious to this (a major historical fact of the time, if not of Mme de Maintenon's life) doesn't inspire confidence in the rest of the book. Nor does her apparent belief (it may be bad wording) that the doctrine of predestination originated with Jansenim - one would have to ask whether she is aware of Calvinism's century-long history - nor the claim that Tallemant des Reaux is an accurate source. His Historiettes are gossip, salacious scandal-mongering and demonstrably false in many places, and major historians of the period have agreed that they should be treated with great caution (see A. Lloyd Moote, "Louis XIII, the Just" end note).
Despite this, I am enjoying the book (although it won't sound like it, after that!) but I do suggest reading it with caution. There is also one plate that needs further investigation: the picture claimed to be of Louise la Valliere is of a young girl from the 1680s or 90s, so if it represents La Valliere (1644-1710) it is an imaginary portrait. Read the book for an overall view, or an introduction, but don't take it as gospel, is my opinion.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Literally from rags to riches in the court of the Sun King, October 7, 2009
This review is from: The Secret Wife of Louis XIV: Françoise d'Aubigné, Madame de Maintenon (Hardcover)
In her youth Francois d'Aubigne was probably the least likely person you would ever have selected as potential wife to King Louis XIV of France but hers is a true life story of rags to riches on a grand scale in 17th century France. It's also proof that real history can be stranger than fiction.
Born in a prison to the daughter of a prison warder and her father who was imprisoned at the time (he was a real scoundrel) she was partly bought up by loving Huguenot relatives - which is rather ironic as the worst part of her legacy has been the shouldering of the blame for the later persecution of the Huguenots - Francois lead a very unstable and varied childhood which took her part way around the world and resulted in dire poverty despite her minor noble status. She managed to escape the extremes of her family life through marriage to an unlikely poet and eventually gained a court post after his death through the influence of friends....and from thereon the rest is history.
I found this a very enjoyable biography. Buckley has a fluid way of writing and while not everything in Madame de Maintenon's life can be included in this book I still felt that I was fortunate to have picked up a book on her life that was so readable and informative and I had a great feeling that this was a woman who should only have commanded respect in life (though not everyone did like her) - if you are looking for a good biography of Madame de Maintenon this is highly recommended. Previously I had only read fiction on Madame de Maintenon
The King's Way and it was good to read the facts to back it up.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An Extraordinary Woman, March 31, 2010
This review is from: The Secret Wife of Louis XIV: Françoise d'Aubigné, Madame de Maintenon (Hardcover)
I learned of Madame de Maintenon two years ago from Antonia Fraser's
Love and Louis XIV: The Women in the Life of the Sun King. After all his flirtations, liaisons and children I was surprised that at the end of his life that he would have a very close relationship with a plain, older woman of substance. I looked for something more on her at the time, but found very little. I was glad to stumble on to this book.
Veronica Buckley puts it all together. She has an excellent grasp of history and gives good descriptions of the economic and political backdrop for this saga.
The power and wealth of the autocratic king permeates all of France. Louis XIV has the power to set a tax rate and chose who will pay it. While workmen may make 1000 livres a year, he accords over 200,000 livres/year to a former mistress and hands out positions, pensions and titles to the many others who curry his favor. He has no trouble ordering a religion and assumes everyone will change their beliefs by royal decree and pressure. No one questions his wars or asks, if indeed, France had won them.
Francoise, born in a prison, eventually lives among all this wealth and power. Having seen the precarious position of the courtiers she does not seek a liaison with the King. It comes as an offer that cannot be refused. Frasier, in her book, shows Francoise to be more of an advisor to the king. Veronica Buckley emphasizes her attempts to do good works.
The author shows the pleasure and pettiness in court life. Rank is very important and everyone tries to please the king. There is a lot on the role and influence of religion and the clergy. Francoise's elevation from child care to her new dubious status is fuel for gossip and she has to behave very carefully.
Francoise focuses on her charities. She tries to improve the lot of her poor non-Catholic family, and this is not easy. The king readily provided funds for Francoise's plans for a school for impoverished girls of noble blood (girls like her). Being an autocrat, the king's choice of location was followed. The book shows the problems with this location and in determining the school's role, in hiring the right teachers, developing a curriculum and setting admission criteria.
I'd like to give this book 5 stars for the research and the importance of the work. While it is very readable, it is also very wordy. There are pages describing what Francoise might have felt (although they are not written with qualifiers). There are overly long sections such as those on poisoning, the construction of Versailles and other background areas. While this material was well written, I was impatient with it because I wanted the story to move more quickly.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No