Most Helpful Customer Reviews
28 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Worst Crime in History., March 10, 2010
As other reviews, I agree that the book has been well written, though repetitive towards the end- but an easy read. I was able to finish it in a day.
I think Glatt just compiled all the articles that were produced since the case went public. I doubt anyone has any information on Elisabeth's dungeon diary or court testimony.
Without any of those, you will not be able to get the details on this case. If you really want to get this book, just wiki it and read the footnote articles. I doubt you'll find anything new in the book.
This is the worst crime in history. I doubt anyone can top it with anything else. Nothing is comparable.
I have one question I wish someone can answer: How is she sane?
24 years, 3,000 rapes, living in a basement, no sunlight, no fresh air, no freedom, not knowing if 'the monster' will come, not knowing what to do if he died, bearing 7 children, seeing one child die in your arms, having 3 children taken away from your arms, living with 3 children- possibly seeing one of them raped by her father/grandfather (doctors were not able to confirm that Kerstin has been raped by Josef Fritzl) yet caring for them... Need I say more?
What I like about the book is the explanation of the psychology behind Josef Fritzl's actions. When the reader is given reasons why someone would commit such an act- it settles something within them- to know, things like this don't happen at random and for no reason.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
So much more to the story, January 26, 2010
"Secrets in the Cellar" is an excellent book, very well written. Some parts were difficult to read, yet the story is fascinating and so hard to put down. How was it that Josef Fritzl was able to maintain his secret? It seems impossible to build a dungeon, imprison his daughter, Elisabeth, bring in her children to raise, all without anyone including the renters and his wife ever knowing. "How?" is the question everyone wants to know.
John Glatt starts from the beginning, the childhood of Josef Frizl. He paints a portrait of Josef's double life during Elisabeth's ordeal. Glatt also details how Elisabeth raised her children and the effects of their imprisonment mentally and physically. There was more to the story than I had ever read in the papers. Included are details about the aftermath, Elisabeth's relationship with her mother, the children's therapy and how they are healing. Glatt covered so much, yet the story flowed seamlessly.
I highly recommend this book for anyone interested in the Fritzl case. It will not disappoint.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
26 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The devil is to nice of a name for Jozef Fritzl!, March 10, 2009
This review is from: Secrets in the Cellar (Mass Market Paperback)
In my opinion and reading true crime books, there are few cases that boggle the imagination and the case of Jozef Fritzl imprisoning his teenage daughter Elisabeth for 24 years and fathering her seven children is mind blowing.
Unfortunately for us, the author wasn't allowed contact with the victims who are secretly guarded against tabloid photographers and journalists all wanting her story. When the case broke out, everybody in the media preyed on the small Austrian town of Amstetten to find out how this man could be so diabolical, cruel, methodical, and truly evil. I have read about hundreds of books on true crimes and this one is truly horrifying.
He showed no mercy towards his daughter or his granddaughter, Kerstin, whose deathly illness helped free them. The author does an above average job in explaining the events but it's difficult when you are unable to communicate with the victims themselves and that's not his fault in the least.
He has plenty of willing and some unwilling to go on record of a man who terrorized his entire family and the community and I don't blame them. The death penalty would be too good for him. For 24 years, he didn't allow his daughter and children/grandchildren to enjoy the basic necessities of sunlight and fresh air.
Elisabeth's actions and survival is amazing because I think many of us would have done ourselves in if we were ever in her shoes. I admire Elisabeth's strength and determination to help her children think of their imprisonment as a game rather than real.
For Jozef Fritzl, I wanted to know more about the man's background. I felt that I didn't get enough information to analyze his motivations for imprisoning his own daughter. I hope that Austrian government puts him a jail cell smaller than his daughter's prison. Unable to act out his perverse sexual fantasies with a living partner, even prostitutes were frightened by his demands and wishes during paid sessions despite the money. Jozef Fritzl will have to answer to a higher power for his actions on earth.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|