From School Library Journal
Grade 5-7-This novel lacks an authentic voice or style. Alex Isaacson, 15, is trying to unravel the mysteries of his bizarre family life. Why did his father disappear 12 years ago? Why has his mother, a desperately obese telephone psychic, refused to get out of bed since then? Why is his Uncle Barnard always painting strange pictures of frogs? Alex eventually learns that his relatives' devastating secret concerns a sister he never knew he had, but his journey is not emotionally involving. None of the characters or relationships are fully fleshed out, and the protagonist is annoying rather than endearing. While it's fine for readers to know that The Wizard of Oz is Alex's favorite movie, it's an intrusion to have an "Oz" reference on so many pages.
Ronni Krasnow, New York Public LibraryCopyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 6-12. Barwin's first young adult novel has a resonance and youthful wit that teen readers will relish. Since his father abandoned them years ago, 15-year-old Alex has cared for his mother, an obese, taciturn telephone psychic who got into bed after her husband left and has never gotten out. But Alex is no longer satisfied with his daily lot or his mother's silence. He wants answers about his father and his family. His goal seems in reach after he connects with his father's strange, possibly psychotic uncle and begins a literal and figurative journey that leads to some shocking revelations. Alex is a good kid with a clever sense of the macabre, and, thanks to his family circumstances, an unusual perspective on the world. These characteristics, coupled with some ingeniously cryptic e-mail and an extended Wizard of Oz metaphor (derived from Alex's playing the saxophone for a school performance of the work), blend together to take readers on a quirky adventure through an unusual teen's unusual world.
Roger LeslieCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved