Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
An average Dragonlance novel, April 5, 2008
The Sellsword by Cam Banks is the first novel in the Anvil of Time series, set in the world of DragonLance. It is Mr. Banks first novel, however, he does have a short story that was included in the anthology Dragons of Time (Dragonlance Anthology) that story is called `Chain of Fools'. The second book in this series is scheduled for release in November, 2008 and is called, The Survivors - it is being written by Dan Willis, the third book is scheduled for release in March, 2009 and is titled Renegade Wizards and is being written by Lucien Soulban.
The plot of this book, at least to start with, is about a Sellsword who accepts an assignment from a local lord. Little does he know that this is anything but a simple assignment. There are an assortment of mishaps, near-misses, and run-ins with people from his past. There are also a couple subplots woven into this story as well. Such as, just what the relationship between the Sellsword (Vanderjack) and his sword, the designs of an evil mage and what his scheme really is about, lastly, there is the subplot of the Dragon Highlord Rivven and what her many plans are and how they affect Vanderjack and his companions. Plot wise, for a Dragonlance book, it is about average if not a little lacking. The entire plot, at least for me seemed rather shallow and only we I got to the end did it really pique my interest. Before the ending, I was apathetic to it. It is not a bad plot, but there is really nothing here that made me sit back and say wow either.
The characters are equally as average. Sure, they each have some uniqueness, but I found myself not really connecting with them throughout the novel. Characters such as Vanderjack, Theodenes, Gredchen, Rivven, Star, and Cazuvel are all decent characters but nothing about them really stood out for me. I don't mean that they are flat characters, but I think some of the feelings I have derive from the fact that even though there are many events, it seems that perceptive readers will be able to gather the outcome of the book fairly early. If you are looking for surprises from characters, they are few and far between in this novel. While there are hints of greatness with these characters, it seems that they fall just short of that extra level to be memorable.
A couple criticisms about this novel are;
1 - There is a great deal of humor in this novel. At times it fits perfectly, yet, at other times it seems really forced and doesn't mesh with the events that are occurring. Don't get me wrong, I love humor in fantasy novels, in fact I have often said I wish there were more of it, yet this may be the case of too much of a good things ruins it. After a while, I honestly because frustrated with some of the attempted humor.
2 - I wish there was more character development, or at least something to make these characters more memorable. As a long time fantasy reader, I felt a little cheated that these characters didn't seem to reach their full potential. They did just enough to get through the story, but that extra stuff wasn't really there.
Some of the brighter spots of this novel are:
1 - Mr. Bank's prose is fluid and easy to read. For the most part he allowed the story to speak for itself. He provided enough description, without over doing it allowing the reader to see both his vision, but also the reader's vision as well. It was a nice balance.
2 - The ending proves that Mr. Banks did have a solid vision for this novel and was able to tie everything together nicely. I think with some more practice and the honing of skills, Mr. Banks will weave start to weave stories that are both interesting and impactful. It's only a matter of time.
I realize this is Mr. Bank's first full length novel and as such, there are bound to be a few bumps in the road. However, based on this novel and Chain of Fools, I am willing to take a look at his next novel to see what, if anything, he has learned. Fans of the Dragonlance world will probably want to pick this up, but they should temper their expectations as well. Fans looking to start reading in the Dragonlance world would be best served by starting with the class Dragonlance Chronicles and working out from those. When all is said and done, this is an average Dragonlance novel, but the author does show some promise as a writer.
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Sellsword Sells...Somewhat, May 4, 2008
My husband and I have been reeading the Dragonlance novels since their earliest beginnings with the trilogies with Hickman & Weis writing groundbreaking fantasy.
But since then, tons of writers have come onto the scene, and the Dragonlance franchise took off like a bat out of hell, forcing us to cpick and choose our Dragonlance novels carefully, since there had been a host of writers we personally didn't care for.
But some we liked.
And newcomer Cam Banks in this debut novel, The Sellsword, Volume One in the Anvil of Time trilogy, is placed somewhere in the middle of the two for us. There was a lot we liked, and didn't like at the same time.
Vanderjack, or the Journeyman, as he is called, something along the lines of a time-travelling mercenary, is an interesting concept for a string of novels, and Cam Banks does a reasonable job at breathing life into this character.
There are a lot of other colorful characters he engages with throutghout the novel, from gnomes to dragons, and Banks seems to derive great pleasure at showcasing his vast knowledge of the Dragonlance world and its environs. And that is important.
But on the other hand, this novel didn't capture the bloody action/adventure type of writing that we like. For a novel filled with everything from pirates to gladiators to Draconian warriors, the action sequences weren't as thrilling as some other authors we've read.
But hey, for a first time novel, it was adequate. I think it was the overall concept and colorful world-building and characters that eventually won us over. Perhaps with time and practice, Cam Banks shows that he has great potential in becoming a huge success in the fantasy field. (We have certainly read much worse!)
We have mixed feelings with the next two books of this trilogy having seaparate writers. But i suppose we will have to see whether or not they can take this concept of the Anvil of Time thing and twist it into one of the most memorable of the tons of other trilogies that the Dragonlance Universe is filled with.
Or at the very least, make it stand out.
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Cam Knows Dragonlance, April 25, 2008
I have a long history as a Dragonlance fan. I began as a player in the late eighties, and became a DL reader shortly after. I've got quite a few under my belt.
The quality has always been very inconsistent, the range being from true fantasy classic to absolute trash--sometimes reaching both extremes in the same trilogy. In my reading experience, the reason for this has mainly been because a Dragonlance story has to both fit in with the details of the setting (difficult for a series with over a hundred novels, numerous game products, and a fan base that is religious in their attention to, "canon"), and it must adhere to a certain thesis.
All too often, Dragonlance novels either get details wrong, such as the color of draconians, or they ignore the thesis.
I'm sure some will disagree with me, but Dragonlance has always been about finding faith. Sometimes it's faith in the gods--In Dragonlance, gods take an active role in the lives of mortals. Other times, the quest is for faith in yourself, or in an ideal, or in your friends--whatever the individual quest, it is always about finding faith. The truly great DL novel has to fit into the world of Krynn, be well written, and on some level be a story about finding faith.
Cam Banks has a knowledge of the setting that is beyond comparison. His attention to detail in THE SELLSWORD is amazing. The novel is set in the years immediately after the War Of The Lance, and everything is just right. He knows the history of the world, he knows the obscure nationalities, he knows the monsters, and he knows the key players. I know the world very well myself, and I couldn't find anything that deviated from what is known and accepted about the world or the people on it.
Mr. Banks has also managed to expand certain elements, further enriching the world and opening new doors--the nation of Nordmaar has been brought to life, and fits with what is already known from past novels and game products. Monsters have also been expanded, and without giving anything away, Mr. Banks has found a place for a classic Dungeons & Dragons creature, giving it a unique identity for the world of Krynn.
As to the quality of the writing, I find it a wonderful read. It is his first published novel and great ability and potential are visible. My one criticism would be that I think Mr. Banks needs to work on his romantic threads. I did not become fully invested in the romantic subplot--it was very subtle, overly so in my opinion. When it resolved, I'm not certain that I believed in the resolution.
Aside from that... Conversations were both engaging and natural, while still being heroic and fantastical. Narration was clear and descriptive, allowing me to get a clear picture without shanghai-ing my imagination--it was a good balance.
Finally, Cam Banks proves he knows DL by keeping the faith. It appeared from the beginning that we had a very un-Dragonlance-like story. By the end, with just the right amount of predictability (enough to make the reader feel smart and still managing to surprise), we see the author's work revealed and see that as fun a shake up as this was, it is still Dragonlance.
I give THE SELLSWORD 4 stars, taking one off for a romance that needed some more attention. It is a wonderful read, and I hope that Cam Banks continues with writing, making frequent returns to The World of Krynn.
Wizards Of The Coast should certainly look to Mr. Banks should they choose to develop more novels or game products.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Lucien Soulban
by Jean Rabe
by Douglas Niles
by richard a. Knaak
