As background, I bought these headphones to replace a six-year-old pair of
Bose QuietComfort 2 Acoustic Noise Canceling Headphones whose faux leather bits have literally disintegrated and also own a pair of
Sennheiser HD-280 PRO Headphones.
I always loved the sound of the QC2s, particularly their great bass and fantastic noise-canceling ability. I've seen many reviews putting down their sound quality, but, as I'm an audio layman, they're the standard to which I compare other headphones. They're also the most comfortable cans I've worn, an area where the HD-280s fall far short. While the 280s sound good, I get a headache from wearing them for extended periods because the padding around the cans is not very soft and the headphones press very firmly against my head.
When I went looking for new headphones, I wanted something that sounded and felt as good as the QC2s. One thing I found annoying when travelling with them, though, is dealing with the cable. I found only a few headphones similar to the QC2s in terms of features that also supported bluetooth audio, and decided to give the Sennheisers a shot based on the company's reputation and my experience with the sound quality of the HD-280s. Choosing between this particular model and the older MX-450 was simple: I wanted to see what the latest tech would offer.
Sound
These are hands-down the best-sounding headphones I can remember -- if you leave noise-cancellation and SRS off. In fact, these are the first pair of headphones that made me turn off the bass booster EQ settings in the iPod app because their natural sound is just so good. I don't know technical audio terms well enough to throw them around, but indulge me: the sound is very crisp, all of the details come through discernibly and the bass has depth but without overpowering the rest of the range. This is where they put the QC2s to shame. And the quality difference between wired and bluetooth? There is one, but they sound good enough over bluetooth that I never feel a need to plug them in.
Noise-Cancellation
Because the MX-550s have an over-the-ear design, they actually do a good job of keeping outside noise to a minimum without active noise-cancellation on. In fact, this is how I prefer to use them whenever possible because as soon as I turn on noise cancellation, sound quality becomes almost mediocre. Whereas the QC2s sound better with this feature on, the Sennheisers sound worse -- the sound loses its depth and bass all but disappears. Using SRS helps ever so slightly, but has problems of its own. As for noise filtering, subjectively I think it's not as good as on the QC2s, but does work well.
So why did I not return these headphones? What I said above is very true when there is not much background noise, but where these headphones really shine is noisy environments like on an airplane. I brought the 550s with me on several flights: they made the engine noise all but disappear when listening to music and softened it very significantly otherwise. Here they performed at least as well as the QC2s and the loss of sound quality from using active noise-cancellation just was not an issue for me. I suspect that the background noise makes it difficult for me to notice how "shallow" the headphones sound.
As for SRS WOW? These headphones may as well omit this feature because, in my opinion, it worsens the sound. In addition to decreasing the sound volume, I would describe the effect as muddling the bass and making the sound much less crisp. I don't mean to imply that this affect produces output that sounds mediocre compared to other headphones, just that it sounds mediocre compared to what these headphones are capable of.
Design
These headphones are actually more compact than I expected from looking at photos and feel extremely solid. And they look great, too. All of the buttons are pretty easy to get to, though they can be tricky to activate sometimes -- there seems to be a sweet spot that you have to press on for them to register. If I don't use the headphones for a while, I forget which button does what since I have to tell them apart by feel and their layout makes this a bit difficult. But these are trivial complaints, really.
Fit & Comfort
My biggest concern about the MX-550s was how well they fit and how comfortable they are given my experience with the HD-280s. I was very happy to find that they are almost as comfortable to wear as my old QC2s. The padding is very soft -- but not as soft as on the Bose -- and I don't feel any pressure when wearing them for hours on end. In spite of what other reviews have said about initial discomfort before the headphones "loosen up," I have not experienced that at all.
Bluetooth
Bluetooth works flawlessly: I've been able to pair these with an iPhone 3GS, Nexus One and Nexus S, and an iPad 1 and 2 with no issues. I've used them within about 20 feet of my iPad and through several walls with no noticeable interference. My one complaint is the presence of a faint clicking noise in the right can when the headphones are paired but nothing is being transmitted. If the room I'm in is quiet enough, it begins to bug me. This should not be a deal breaker, just something to be aware of (and hopefully fix in a future model).
Battery
With my usage pattern, a AAA battery in my QC2s could last for what seemed like forever. I was a bit concerned with the 8-hour rating on the battery in the MX-550s, but it has not been a problem in practice. I've gone on a 5-hour flight with bluetooth, noise-cancellation and SRS WOW turned on and still had enough juice to last me the next four days at my hotel with 30-min to an hour of use each day. At home, with about an hour of use most days, I can go close to two weeks without charging. My only complaint, however, is the difficulty of removing the battery. I can't press the little tab down far enough with my finger to release the battery module; instead, I end up using the 3.5mm connector from the cable that comes with the headphones.
Conclusion
This is a pricey gadget. Were I to put a price tag on all of its features, it would be $100 lower than what I paid. But that's not something I control and so there's not much point to mulling over it. After living with the MX-550s for three months, I do not regret the purchase in the least. Leaving out noise-cancellation, these headphones are absolutely brilliant. The noise-cancellation does not work the way I want, but it does work in the way I need it to -- I can listen to music or dialog on airplanes and the sound quality is very good if I don't try to compare it against what the headphones are capable of in a quiet room with noise-canceling off. If you can afford the price without feeling guilty, these are worth trying out.