5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb descriptions of C18 British Army Life, May 19, 2011
This review is from: The Sergeant Lamb Novels (Robert Graves Programme) (Hardcover)
Robert Graves' Sergeant Lamb novels are a brillant recreation of British army life in the late C18. The story is that Graves, himself a veteran of the Royal Welch [sic] Fusiliers, found the memories of Roger Lamb, a veteran of the regiment from the War of American Independence, and, thinking that the story had been reedited from an evangelist Christian perspective before publication, decided to recreate the "real story". The results is an exciting and informative tale told in C18 English.
The only reason that these novels are not more famous is that they have never been well-received in the US. Graves' recreation of Lamb's story figures the American colonists as rebels and treacherous ingrates, and so contradicts 200 years of American patriotic narrative (he even treats Benedict Arnold with some respect!).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting Perspective Somewhat Boringly Presented, August 30, 2005
This review is from: The Sergeant Lamb Novels (Robert Graves Programme) (Hardcover)
Originally published in England under the title "Sergeant Lamb of the Ninth", this is the first half of Graves' retelling of the life of a British soldier fighting against the American revolutionaries. As regimental historian in the Royal Welsh Fusiliers, he had come across the real Sgt. Lamb's record of service. Twenty years later, while living in America, Graves was near broke and casting about for an idea for a popular book when he remembered Sgt. Lamb. He then duly immersed himself in Revolutionary War history to create order to create this faux memoir. This first volume starts by recounting the childhood of the protagonist, an Irish boy raised near Dublin's docks and given to dreams of adventure. Seemingly destined for a life at sea, his hopes are derailed by his father, who has already lost one son in naval battle and refuses to lose the other.
But the boy Lamb finds his way into the military nonetheless, and ends up a redcoat infantryman. The first third or so of the book outlines his path to the army and then training. This is followed by a lengthy background on the American Revolution, from the perspective of a British citizen of the time. For Americans, this is probably the most interesting part of the book -- a quite different perspective on events than one generally receives as a youth. Highlights include the venality of the "Founding Fathers" and the nastiness of the Boston mobs. Once Lamb actually gets to North America, the book started to lose my attention. His picaresque adventures aren't that enthralling, and while some of the detail of daily life in Canada is kind of interesting, it's not enough to grip one. One episode has him sent off to learn the ways of the Indians so that he may return to impart them to the redcoats, who were fairly hapless against the revolutionaries' guerilla tactics. Another plotline is his rivalry with a fellow soldier, revolving around a woman they both wooed in Ireland and the other married. This descends into melodrama of the Thomas Hardy type.
Written in the stilted, formal style of a semi-educated 18th-century Englishman, the prose does a better job of mimicry than of actually being readable. While Lamb's fair-minded assessments of the Continental Army and its success make for a novel perspective, one would have to be greatly interested in Revolutionary War history to make reading this worthwhile. The bits and pieces about British vs. American tactics are decent, but scant. This first book ends with the capture of Lamb and his comrades at the Battle of Saratoga. His escape from prison camp and subsequent adventures are described in "Proceed, Sergeant Lamb", which I will not be reading. There are also editions available which combine the two books.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No