From Publishers Weekly
Curlee (Liberty; Rushmore; Brooklyn Bridge) broadens his scope from famous American monuments to global feats of antiquity. He opens with a poem by the Greek poet Antipater of Sidon, naming the septet of "wondrous marvels," then the author states "Seven was a mystical number to ancient people, and each of these spectacular sights was a masterpiece of architecture, sculpture, or engineering, famous for its great size, beauty, grandeur, and perfection." Ironically, the oldest of these, the Great Pyramid at Giza, is also the only one still standing. To emphasize its enormity, Curlee paints an image of Napoleon standing on the ruins of another nearby pyramid; thus, readers view how the "huge pile of carefully cut and fitted stones" was constructed as well as a sense of scale. The author then proceeds, chronologically, through the other six wonders, responsibly discussing various archeological theories. He confirms, for instance, that the foundations of a ziggurat at King Nebuchadrezzar II's palace were uncovered, but that experts disagree about whether sufficient proof exists of the hanging gardens at Babylon. Curlee also takes subtle stands: although he sketches four "versions" of the Mausoleum at Halicarnassus, he expresses his own preference with his full-bleed portrait of the structure. The expanse of his ambitious subject does not allow the author to delve into the kinds of details allowed by his single-subject volumes, but he certainly whets readers' appetites with this well-researched introduction. Ages 8-12.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 4-8-Like the author's Liberty (2000) and Brooklyn Bridge (2001, both Atheneum), Seven Wonders has a lucid narrative, complemented by full-page, full-color illustrations. However, it may be a harder sell. Unfamiliar names will stymie many readers (there's no pronunciation guide); students may also have difficulty following the trail of evidence that documents each structure's history and legend. A map of the ancient Hellenistic world is provided. A diagram shows the relative sizes of the wonders to one another and to modern structures. Meticulous, flat line work and a limited color palette of ochre, blue, and magenta create an austere visual impression. Curlee transports readers unflinchingly from past to present with drawings of a scuba diver exploring toppled undersea fragments of statues from the Pharos, and jets whizzing through the sky over the Great Pyramid. He concludes gravely: "Perhaps many centuries from now- archaeologists will uncover the ruins of the marvels of our own modern age-." A book for students with a sure grounding in history and a love of the fantastic.
Mary Ann Carcich, Mattituck-Laurel Public Library, Mattituck, NYCopyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
