6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
At times a bit too much like Harry Potter, May 31, 2006
This review is from: The Seventh Mountain: Chronicles of a Magi (Paperback)
Don't get me wrong, I liked and enjoyed (in my case) listening to the book, but it was at times annoying to realize how much the story was like Harry Potter. The basic story line and premise it almost exactly the same. For those of you who read both books, you probably understand what I mean, for those of you who only know Harry Potter, here's a comparison:
Magi = Wizards
The 7th Mountain (a school for Magi) = Hogwarts (a school for wizards)
tribes (each student is chosen for a tribe at the beginning of their first year) = houses (each student is chosen for a house at the beginning of their first year)
Mark Young & friends (the hero and his friends) = Harry Potter and friends (the hero and his friends)
Slone and his bullies = Draco and his bullies
Benra (a bad magi wanting to kill Mark) = Voldemort (a bad wizard wanting to kill Harry)
Flags (a sport played by magi) = Quidditch (a sport played by wizards)
Mr.Diefenderfer & Mrs. Shadowitz (the warmhearted intelligent heads of the school) = Albus Dumledore and Minerva McGonagall (the warmhearted intelligent heads of the school)
Harmoniuous Thorpe (the ill-humored and spiteful teacher) = Severus Snape (the ill-humored and spiteful teacher)
a moat with weird creatures in it = a lake with weird creatures in it
see what I mean? ;-)
Anyways, if you enjoyed Harry Potter you'd probably like this book too. But I wish the writer had proven a bit more imaginative.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Seventh Mountain by Gene Curtis is a story told well, May 17, 2011
The Seventh Mountain by Gene Curtis is a story told well. While there are similarities between Seventh Mountain and Harry Potter it is not so exact as to be distracting. The author does a very good job telling this story. The writing is well done and the plot is compelling. This is one book that you will enjoy until the last pages.
Any fan of the Harry Potter series would enjoy The Seventh Mountain. There is nothing inappropriate in the content making this book a good one for readers of all ages.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great Start, December 15, 2006
This review is from: The Seventh Mountain: Chronicles of a Magi (Paperback)
It intrigued me from the first and I have to say, it's a darned good story. I believe some people will say that it's a Christian Harry Potter knock off but I can't say I agree. True, at first I wondered if it was indeed a re-telling of a Harry Potter type tale with a Christian twist but as I got deeper into the book I found it was something quite different.
Curtis does a good job on the magic system in the Magi world, making it understandable and realistic. The setting of Seventh Mountain and it's surroundings is also very well developed. To be honest, the characters were a bit wooden at times and the dialog was awkward in places. I often felt that Mark understood concepts and acted far beyond the scope of his 12 years of age. Yet I was still engaged and my interest was held to the very last page.
There are enough questions in the book that you want to keep reading, want to find the answers. The bad guy is really bad and the good guys are really good. This work should appeal to a wide audience. It's young enough that a child will understand and enjoy it but it's got enough depth that an adult will enjoy their time reading it as well.
Bravo to Gene Curtis and well done on his first published novel. I look very forward to reading future installments of the Chronicles of a Magi series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No