10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Annoyingly redundant, June 5, 2008
This review is from: Sex Slaves: The Trafficking of Women in Asia (Paperback)
I was asked to read and give my opinion of this book by a student who is about to embark on a masters course on this same topic. I therefore dutifully slogged through it, although I would have never finished it otherwise.
The topic of the book is primarily about the condition and circumstances of Asian women who have been trafficked into the sex industry for consumption by Asian men. As a book that brings focus on the abject abuse, imprisonment, slavery and torture of women, it is a welcome contrast to the more exploitive (read: crap) books on the market such as "Private Dancer," which tend to deal with the high end of Thai prostitution with western customers, all based more on fiction than on research. Brown's book is looking at the same coin from the opposite side. OK, that's about it for the positive comments I have to make about the book.
On the minus side, this book is so redundant, you need only read the first chapter, "The Market," to learn all you will about what Brown has to say on this subject. In chapters such as "The Management" and "The Law," Brown just spins a few interviews with Calcutta or Thai sex workers to send the same message of how horrible trafficking is and her disgust at the men who perpetuate it. I think she's spot on with her opinion and I had no idea of the depth of the problem, but more complete research might have given her more to write about each topic, and would have allowed me to read more than 4 pages before going to sleep.
As a case in point, there is a chapter titled, "The Customers." I was expecting to read data and observations based on interviews with the people who use prostitutes. Instead, all you read is more extrapolation of what she thinks men are thinking based on said interviews with the sex workers in Calcutta, the Philippines and so on. Her only published interview of a male seems to be the one young motorcycle taxi driver youth who said he went to brothels because he was "lonely." For this book to have increased substance and power to change and dismantle systems, interviews and insider information from all parties are required. In this same chapter Brown writes, "We should ask what these customers think about prostitution. And why they have to buy sex." Indeed, she should have.
As for her conclusion that prostitution should remain illegal, she ignores all of her evidence that it's precisely because it's illegal that police and other institutionalized corruption completely prevent the dismantling of the system. So which do you want? The unrealistic ideal of ending all prostitution while keeping it illegal at the expense of the continued state of women being kidnapped, cajoled, forced, sold and leveraged into accepting a fate (and by fate, I mean the end of their lives as they know it) of severe mental and physical abuse, confinement, rape and murder? Or do you try to help those suffering the most by legalizing and regulating it as an industry, with the intention of allowing more access of NGOs to inform, educate and help improve general working conditions in non-prostitution industries? This underlying confusion in her argument is really what annoys me the most about this book. I respect her passion for the subject, but she needs to take a reality pill, or at the very least try to draw conclusions that arise from her data.
In summary, as a person who purports to be tackling this as an academic, her research is weak and all of her conclusions seem to be based just on personal opinion and interviews with sex workers. As for her claim that her work is not meant to be sensational, with a title of Sex Slaves in bold red letters, and a cover shot of an Asian woman seemingly about to service some blurry unclothed man, it seems that sex does sell after all.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent overall information, not academic., September 14, 2010
This review is from: Sex Slaves: The Trafficking of Women in Asia (Paperback)
I have gone through other readers' reviews and I must agree up to a point, but mostly I disagree. The main problem of this book is that it cannot be used as source for any other report or study. This book neither offers statistical data, nor sociology theories that may be applied to the situation. It is mainly a collection of impressions, interviews with sex workers and helps to provide an accurate state of the human trade for sex in Asia.
I cannot agree with others that this lack of statistics makes it less valuable, though. As a researcher myself, it is easy to dismiss reports lacking hard data, but qualitative reports are as valuable as from-the-desktop graphics making. And in a case that this one, it is more so. I can access easier to the figures provided by different NGOs and international organizations than visiting low end brothels in Bangladesh or the Manila's casas. And there is where this book offers added value.
The book describes a real situation accurately, if not scientifically. It might be better a journalistic report, and it lacks many aspects, but it provides a good overview.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Would have been a great magazine article, January 30, 2010
This review is from: Sex Slaves: The Trafficking of Women in Asia (Paperback)
This book is simply not good. There is little academic rigor on display, plenty of emotional invective, and a thinly veiled contempt for the Asian male, some of which could be forgiven, if it wasn't so exasperatingly repetitive, cloying and one-dimensional. I just spent several minutes looking for one of my favorite lines, whereby the author suggests that some wildly gratuitous assertion be "taken as axiomatic". Sadly, I couldn't find it, but I am sure you'd have shared my bewilderment. Want axiom? The author's understanding of "Asia", or at least that which is found in the pages of this book, is as pedestrian and imbalanced as any on display. The problems with the book don't diminish the importance of the topic, but don't expect to be enlightened within its pages.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No