Most Helpful Customer Reviews
34 of 38 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A sympathetic view of Chávez, September 3, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: In the Shadow of the Liberator: The Impact of Hugo Chavez on Venezuela and Latin America (Hardcover)
Since there is no extended analysis of Chávez in English that I know of, this is the most complete version that can be found of the history of the Chávez phenomenon. The reader should be aware that the author makes little effort to hide his admiration for Hugo Chávez, and accepts without question the Chávez interpretation of Venezuela, which is to say that absolutely nothing good ever happened in Venezuela between the death of Bolívar and the coup attempt led by Chávez. No credit is given at all to any attempts to develop the country in the last 100 years, except perhaps during the Pérez Jiménez dictatorship. Just about all previous leaders were corrupt. The author fails entirely to see the continuities between the Chávez movement and previous political movements, which are many. In short, the book is totally biased. Despite its obvious defects, however, Gott does cover the basic facts of Chávez' origins and his strategy to gain power, so if the reader wants to find out what Chávez is all about, this is a good and even fascinating source. It's fun to read. If the reader wants to understand what Venezuela is all about, it is much less reliable. The book only takes us up to the approval of the new Constitution at the end of 1999 and really only covers the period up until about mid-1999. The author's biases mean that he is unable to see the fractures within the Chávez coalition which would eventually lead to the break with Arias Cárdenas and which will surely mean further fissures in the future. He also assumes that all opponents to Chávez are hopeless reactionaries, which is only about 50% true. Surely someone will write a better book soon, but for now, this book will be useful for anyone who wants to know what has been going on in Venezuela. But let the buyer beware. Gott obviously doesn't care much about democratic processes and seems to think that coups are okay means of bringing about change.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
37 of 49 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A good help to understand contemporary Venezuela., July 30, 2000
This review is from: In the Shadow of the Liberator: The Impact of Hugo Chavez on Venezuela and Latin America (Hardcover)
As the author says, few books have been written in English about contemporary Venezuela, and a lot of what is being written in Spanish, for readers abroad, is too biased, incidental and poorly researched to be of any help in order to understand the deep political changes that are taking place in Simón Bolívar's nation. With his book "In the Shadow of the Liberator, Hugo Chávez and the Transformation of Venezuela" Professor Gott contributes to foster an objective and deeper knowledge of the Venezuelan political process led by President Chávez. Gott analyzes Venezuela's recent history;the Carlos Andrés Pérez's Presidency and the "Caracazo" of 1989, the military rebellions of 1992, the Rafael Caldera's government, the fall of the Ancien Régime and the election of Hugo Chávez as President, the formation of the Constituent Assembly and the future of the Bolivarian dream that Chávez endorses, the economy, the Legacy of Bolívar, and the impact of Chávez in Latin America, in a well docummented story enriched with on-site experiences and interviews with leading Venezuelan politicians. Gott also writes about the Reform of the Judiciary, the rights of indigenous peoples, the military and civil society and other changes that Chávez is pushing through his political agenda to conclude, as a majority of Venezuelans do, that President Chávez is an honest man "with the interest of his people at heart" It is an excellent book, not the last word in English - I hope- about a history that is still being written, but a first and rather good approach by an English writing scholar that will undoubtedly help in understanding the present and future of Venezuela.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A good view of Venezuela's politics today, January 21, 2001
This review is from: In the Shadow of the Liberator: The Impact of Hugo Chavez on Venezuela and Latin America (Hardcover)
After more than 50 years of extremely corrupt leaders, Venezuelans finally got tired, and elected this former paratroop officer/attempted coup leader as their president. This book portrays the reason for his election, and the way in which he was brought to power quite accurately, if not totally unbiased. However, this book is not just some attempt from Chavez to hire a biographer to change his image (as some readers suggested), but an attempt to show that perhaps president Chavez isn't a spawn of satan, like the opposition claims. Taxing, anti-corruption campaigns, and communicating with the people who elected him (the true average Venezuelan) on TV every Sunday are just a few things that have led him to be called everything from a Fascist (in the pre-election era) to a Communist (in the post-election era). Definitely a good book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|