142 of 147 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fascinating character study, November 23, 2005
This review is from: Shaman's Crossing (The Soldier Son Trilogy, Book 1) (Hardcover)
I'm a fan of Hobb's other books, but I avoided reading this book for a while due to the negative reviews I read here. But I finally decided to try it, and I just finished it last night, having stayed up four hours past my bedtime to do so.
The main criticisms that other reviewers have brought up so far have been that the book is slow and dull, that nothing really happens, that it's only a setup novel, and that the main character, Nevare, is uninteresting. I find none of these to be true. Actually, based on the negative reviews, while reading the book I kept expecting to get bored or bogged down. I didn't. In almost every chapter there's something happening, something changing, something moving forward. You'd have to be blind not to see it.
Other reviewers have remarked on Nevare's lack of uniqueness. I really do not understand this. Sure, there's the distinct absence of a stereotypical prophecy saying that he's destined to save the world, but there's no dearth of interesting things about Nevare. One reviewer said that "Nevare does not question his society, his role, his society's racism or destructive policies; he is as stuffy as most of his kind." Another noted that he is "shallow and accepts things as they come." I must disagree. I feel that there is tension in Nevare's personality stemming from his being disgusted with the state of affairs (e.g. the way Plainspeople are treated; the destruction of the forest), and not understanding why things are the way they are, yet being commanded by people he respects to accept those things. This polarization of his character -- on the one hand, firmly believing in the rightness and immutability of his place in the world, and on the other, deeply questioning it -- is at the heart of the story, and is a theme that surfaces again and again and again. What is the right thing to do? When should one have faith, and when should one question? When is it right to obey, when to rebel? When do you accept and when do you question authority? There is a place for both; how ought one choose to do each? What do you do when doing the right thing will lead only to punishment?
Like any of us -- like FitzChivalry -- Nevare forgets or denies what he knows to be true -- quite often, in fact. This frustrated me in the Fitz novels as well as this book, but it's realistic.
I found Shaman's Crossing much like Assassin's Apprentice. They are both character studies at heart, following a protagonist through a variety of different, quirky experiences that come to shape who he is. In all of Hobb's stories, the character is what shapes the plot more than vice versa. These character-driven plots tend to meander into places that violate the conventions of standard fantasy because there is no grand prophecy to fulfill; the chips fall where they will. I find this to be no different between Fitz's story and Nevare's. One difference between Fitz and Nevare is that Fitz started out with more overtly interesting qualities, e.g. he has magical abilities, is a prince's bastard, and is trained as an assassin. Perhaps some readers of Shaman's Crossing will feel comparatively stifled by Nevare's commitment to his obligations and responsibilities, by his lack of political importance or magical abilities. But for reasons I've already outlined, I think there's plenty about Nevare to interest. It doesn't at all require patience or interest in philosophical topics to do so.
I also find fascinating how Hobb subverts our preconceived ideas. For instance, I mentioned earlier that there's no prophecy that Nevare will save the world. Actually, though, the whole experience with Dewara and then Tree Woman makes clear that each of them expects him to save their world. But this once again begs the question of what it means to do the right thing. What does it mean to "save the world," if saving one world will destroy another? There's no clear-cut answer.
The setting is a bit strange to me, as the government is feudal, with kings and lords, yet many aspects of it resemble 18th or 19th century United States, with muskets and spiritualistic seances and such. It's a strange juxtaposition. And you have Plainspeople who are clearly a parallel to Native Americans, and many of the social issues are the same. I was a bit nervous that Hobb would take the easy way out and simply set up a Natives-good colonists-bad dichotomy, which is just as stupid as the old Natives-evil colonists-good thing. But this gets very tangled and confused in a very satisfying way, as both sides (more than two, actually) are willing to cause death and violence to achieve their ends. Again, through Nevare's eyes we come back to the question of what is right and just and honorable, how much do you accept of your reality. Who's good? Are the Plainspeople good? Is Tree Woman good? Are the colonists good? It brings up the question of why people do what they do -- again, the heart of the story.
I think that those who saw only a flat, boring story didn't explore what the story offered. Unlike in the Fitz stories, nobody dies except from plague. No great wars are waged. Nevare is not in contact with people in power. But much is happening.
So, in closing, I'd like to reiterate that I disagree with the negative reviews, as I think a tremendous amount of importance occurs in the book, and that it is yet another fascinating character study from Robin Hobb. I recommend it and I look forward to the next in the series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
60 of 64 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mixed Reaction, February 26, 2007
I am a solid Robin Hobb fan and was thrilled when I found that she had a new trilogy out....and I read this book, cover to cover, with no skimming even when I hit the parts that did actually bore me - something I never thought Hobb could do - because her incredible descriptive abilities are almost mesmerizing and hold me glued to the page....even when a voice in my brain is screaming, "is she going to go through the bit about soldier's sons and noble's sons one more time?!" She must have gone over and over several issues pertinent to the story as though this were the second book in a trilogy and she needed to keep reminding you of this...that, or she thinks her readers are incapable of remembering the basic relationships on which her story is based (duh!)...it borders on insulting at times, Robin!
I think that the repetitiveness throughout the book is what causes a lot of the slowness and dryness and sense of boredom that prior reviewers complain of....there is simply no reason to keep repeating over...and over...and over....and over.....how the battle lord's sons and noble's soldier sons differ.
While this certainly isn't the most interesting of Hobb's worlds I've lived in......it is crafted as fully....and drew me in as completely....and that is what I look for in a book....to go somewhere different, have some different experiences and marvel at how someone can think up all that!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
91 of 101 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Slow Start to What Could be a Great Series, September 19, 2005
This review is from: Shaman's Crossing (The Soldier Son Trilogy, Book 1) (Hardcover)
I have read all of Robin Hobb's books and have noticed that all of her series tend to start out with a whimper and end with a bang. I read "Assassin's Apprentice" back when it first came out and was unimpressed. It was only years later when I went back and was able to read the entire Farseer series in one sweep that I became a diehard Hobb fan.
"Shaman's Crossing" is a setup book. It revolves around a young man Nevare who as second son to a noble is destined by his culture to become a soldier. The first half of the book deals with his training at his father's estate and the latter half deals with his experiences at a prestigious millitary school for the children of nobles.
The book sets up all the protagonists and antagonists. One struggle will involve a struggle between the old nobles and new nobles(Nevare's father). Another story arc will be between Nevare's people and a race of sorcerous forest dwellers called dapples whose lands Nevare's people are invading.
Overall the excellence of this book will depend on the quality of the finished series. This is rather an excellent building book to a great series or the first book of a series that will drag on to an uninteresting conclusion.
The reason for the four stars and not five is that even in a book that is a building block to a larger story I like a little more contained story, but upon finishing this book I immediately wanted to read the next book of the series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
