21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I've Never Read A More Vivid Biography, January 6, 2000
This review is from: The Shameful Life of Salvador Dalí (Hardcover)
Most biographies I've read, the opening chapters are a bore of mundane details of the person's childhood that are uninterestnig and nearly always read the same. In contrast, Ian Gibson's writing style is so lush, that even the detailed history of the Dali family before Salvador was born are compelling. Gibson gives you the feel of the Spanish countryside and the era in which Dali and his forefathers lived. Gibson is a careful biographer as well. Instead of taking Dali's own autobiography, "The Secret Life Of Salvador Dali," at face value, Gibson researches Dali's life and points out discrepencies and exaggerations of Dali writings. It led me to reread Dali's own writings and gave me further insight into the mind of the artist. I enjoyed reading about Dali's relationships with other painters (Surreal and otherwise), writers and poets such as Lorca, and his love of jazz. Far from a dry outline of a famous person's life, this book makes Dali come alive.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Gibson has contributed a flawed book to Dali studies., September 28, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: The Shameful Life of Salvador Dalí (Hardcover)
reprint from Isthmus (Madison, WI) Vol. 23, No. 31, July 31-August 6, 1998, p. 19.
Dead almost ten years now, Salvador Dali (1904-89) remains one of the most talked about artists of the 20th century; pause quietly and you may hear the cascade of all that talk still drift softly upon his coffin. Dali was and still is, a household name - a rare thing for artists in their own lifetime, let alone immediately after their death. But despite name recognition, only Dali seemed aware of Dali's genius. A literal outcast among the avant garde's own putrid outcasts, Dali seemed not prepared or capable of fitting anywhere, whether within the faux freedom of Andre Breton's Surrealism or in the realm of post-war America's not-joking-around art world.
Despite a career that lasted until 1983, Dali only produced good work between 1929 and 1933. At least, that's what most art historians, curators and critics would have you believe. Dali's autobiographical fiction, public antics and impeccable talent for self generating PR has tended to color the way many artwriters have looked at his art: commercial kitsch painted by a hack fraud. Dali is possibly the only major artist of the modern period who hasn't been thoroughly reassessed. Thanks to several recent contributions (like R. Radford, H. Finkelstein)it seems Mr. Dali's cultural contributions, rather than public charades and smoke screens, are at last being assessed. Ian Gibson's unbalanced new biography contributes perceptive analysis of Dali's early years, but is savagely prejudiced about nearly everything else.
Gibson's young (1904-1924) Dali is better understood than ever. Dali's formative years are conjured in a dreamlike, magic realist narrative contextualizing the artist's Catalan background. Gibson goes to fantastic lengths to credibly account for the Dali's childhood precocity, recurring obsessive themes and paranoias, attempting to sort the fictional from the actual - no simple task when dealing with the most deliberately elusive subject any biographer could select. Much good use was made of Dali's correspondence and other personal papers; he is approached with a clinical eye for biographical reality rather than myth. But Gibson falls apart and reveals his animosity for his subject over the rest of Dali's long life. This is a flawed book, written at times in a condescending tone and irresponsible in parts. Gibson announces that he will avoid the later work outright (he confesses to reader that he will do so as he launches into the post-war period) calls his practice as a biographer into doubt. How long will Dali remain a taboo for art historians? R. Cozzolino END
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Unflatering Portrait of a Neurotic Genius, December 6, 1999
This review is from: The Shameful Life of Salvador Dalí (Hardcover)
Well researched revisionist biography of one of the century's great artists. As the title implies, the author suggests that a key to understanding Dali is his feelings of shame. Dali suffered from almost paralizing bouts of shame as a child, and struggled (not always successfully) to work around or overcompensate for them. Those with a casual interest in Dali should start off with the artist's own "The Secret Life of Salvador Dali" for many insights and a more entertaining read. The "Shamefull Life" tries to find the story behind the story. My biggest objection to this book is Gibson's almost total dismissal of Dali's art after 1940, which I fear is a prejudice based more on politics than the Dali's art itself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No