Most Helpful Customer Reviews
99 of 116 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Badly written, self-obsessed drivel, August 22, 2001
This review is from: Shanghai Baby: A Novel (Hardcover)
..."Shanghai Baby" isn't so much a novel as a guidebook to the damp, sticky underbelly of Shanghai's nightlife. Unfortunately, Wei Hui misses the ironies and idiosyncrasies of this decidedly skanky scene and rather proceeds to fawningly gush and name-drop throughout. It's quite humorous to us here in Shanghai, as we all know every one of the bar and restaurant owners she repetitively refers to... That does sum up, however, the culture that Wei Hui is depicting. Ignore the ads: this is NOT representative of China, NOT representative of Shanghai, NOT representative of the "new youth" and NOT representative of China's budding Bohemian crowd. The lifestyle it documents is unique to the anorexic, gaudily made-up gals who lurk in expatriate bars hoping to snare Caucasian sugar daddies who will provide them with visas, condos, cars and/or cash. They'll sleep with a rock musician or artist once in a while to prove that they're "alternative" and not just party girls. Wei Hui does little to tone down the highly autobiographical nature of the book, which is the reason why it so lacks any sense of humor or perspective. She didn't even change the name of her foreign boyfriend from his real-life version. The author tries to prove her literary credentials by dropping references to great modern Western writers throughout the book, both in the text and in really random quotes at the beginning of each chapter. She particularly uses and abuses Henry Miller and Milan Kundera, who were extremely popular among Shanghainese college students during Wei Hui's student days. She name-drops three different writers within the first five pages of the book, and one Kundera quote gets repeated three different times. Editorial oops. What's most galling, though, is her supposed adulation of Henry Miller, who so despised the sort of artifice which fills this book to gagging. Much has been made in the Western press of how "Shanghai Baby" was a bestseller that got banned. Well, it was in the top 5 in Shanghai for a few weeks, but hardly registered as one of China's major successes in 2000. By the time it got banned, its sales and accompanying buzz had already dropped from any radars. It was banned not for its sexual or subversive content but rather because its main audience was teenybopper Shanghainese girls, whose parents complained in mass that the book was encouraging a perception that being going to sleazy bars and bopping middle-aged white men is cool. Sad that such a shoddy novel got picked up for English translation and distribution when so much better and more significant literature is coming out of modern China but never gets noticed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not Very Good, October 17, 2001
This review is from: Shanghai Baby: A Novel (Hardcover)
As an 1980's western punker/artist ( in the U.S.) of of Asian origins, I am just amazed by the clueless comments made by some reviewers who don't have a clue about a country and base their knowledge of a country on a self serving author who plays you into the age old stereotypes of East and West, this time magnified 100 fold (e.g. impotent male vs verile male). Because it was banned , the marketing hype calls the book "real China of today" and cool, and it represents modern China. You almost feel from the raving reviews that there is this great movement and turmoil and as if every one in Coco's age is like her. Perhaps you should see how the young really live in China, just like how the world perceives America vs how we really are. Good grief! The writing is hollow and hard to sympathize when one really knows what is happening in China. You would figure us to be more sophisticated.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Is there really one "real" China/Shanghai?, July 30, 2005
As everyone probably knows, this book was banned in China. Why? Well, Wei Hui writes about things like sex, drugs, unemployment, German men and masturbation. Basically things that lost their shock value about twenty years ago in America, but managed to drive some communists insane in 2000, when "40,000 copies were publicly burned, serving only to fan the flames of the author's cult status." The story goes something like this: Coco, the protagonist, is caught between two men: an unemployed, impotent Chinese man named Tian Tian and a horny, married German named Mark. The book reads a bit like a diary. It goes on and on about the sex she's had with Mark, what she did with her cool, modern friends and pointless details such as what people were wearing, what she bought at the grocery store, etc. The world she lives in is apparently Shanghai's underbelly, where drugs and wild parties flourish. In the end she must decide between Mark and Tian Tian. Each chapter starts with a few quotes. Some of them are interesting, but they didn't necessarily enrich the book. Coco takes a bit getting used to. She describes herself as her daddy's little princess. She says her parents spoil her. She sometimes brags too much about how attractive, clever and talented she is. Her actions are often difficult to understand, especially because she has a tendency to do things such as quit her job and have sex in a public bathroom at the drop of a hat. Hui's writing style is distinctive. She does have a talent for creating a mood and describing situations. The plot itself is actually pretty simple, a woman caught between two lovers. I don't think this book is terrible, I just don't think it's bestseller material. I also doubt that it truly portrays the "real" China. 80% of China's population still works agriculture, and most young people aren't as spoiled and rich as Coco/Hui. Overall I'd classify this book as light summer read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|