Customer Reviews

She Has No Strings Apollo

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

When an artist deals in a limited palette, especially for as long as the Dirty Three have, any minor change is bound to be seen as a major revelation (and occasionally, as a welcome surprise).

For those unfamiliar with the band in question, they might be summed up as such : a classically trained violinist with no hang ups about proper "tone", an unconventional guitarist with a predilection towards drones and a percussionist who more often than not plays his kit with assorted rattles and mallets as opposed to plain vanilla drum sticks. The trio play mournful old world ballads that are continuously upended by a serious urge to freak out.

She Has No Strings Apollo may very well be Dirty Three's greatest accomplishment to date, at least since 1996's classic Horse Stories. The dreary repetitive grind that was Ocean Songs and the limited instrumental palette of Whatever You Love, You Are have been replaced with what one could guardedly call a sense of variety. Keep in mind, this is still the Dirty Three we're talking about, so it's not that much different than their other releases, but it is a bit more varied.

The opening strains of bowed violin and plaintive guitar picking may sound familiar enough, but once the band establishes its groove -- complete with overdubbed pizzicato violin, distorted guitar chords and looped background arpeggiated motifs -- you'll know something has changed. Overdubbing is nothing new for the trio. Whatever You Love, You Are featured Warren Ellis's dueling overdubbed violin lines on a number of tracks. But on this here platter the band has decided to add instruments heretofore absent from their arsenal. Piano, organ and bass all make an appearance alongside the usual guitar, violin and trap set.

The first track "Alice Wading", starts off sprightly enough, and only continues to build momentum until the inevitable climax. The most surprising thing about this album, however, is the groups' newfound embrace of varied rhythms. Granted there are plenty of the pre-requisite dirges and wailing drones propelled along by Jim White's free form drumming style that typify the Dirty Three sound, but there is an energy here that seems lacking on their last few releases.

In other developments, "Long Way To Go With No Punch" may actually be the single sweetest melody ever written by the trio, complete with simple piano figures and minimal, almost orchestral drumming. Personally, the biggest shocker for me was the closing cut "Rude (and then some slight return)", in which the band starts off playing one of its trademark rubato, mournful, rustling percussion dirges. But when the proverbial "chorus" kicks in ... it's straight four-on-the-floor with crunchy guitar chords from Mick Turner and all that it implies -- straight up rawk. It is as surprising in its straight forwardness as in its effectiveness.

For those unfamiliar with the band's work, this is the perfect place to dive in. For those that already have a fondness for them, this will not disappoint.

-- Troy Collins

I'm having a hard time getting this out of my cd rotation. "She Has No Strings" is about the most compelling violin music I've ever heard. The sound violinist Warren Ellis produces is so, so sad. Aching, sorrowful. Guitarist Mick Turner's guitar companion piece, which near the end overtakes the violin, cries for release. At the end, both violin and guitar are weeping. Jim White's drumming on this is almost militaristic, but perfect for keeping everything tightly together.

This was my first exposure to Dirty Three and I have to say, I like what I hear. Rich, emotive storytelling music without the words. Try it.

The first time I listened to this cd I thought it was unimaginative and tedious but all it took was a second listen to realize it may be the best thing they've done so far. The title track in particular is amazing. I am a courier at night and this cd never left the player for the whole 8 hours of my shift. My only gripe is that it didn't have more songs on it. A band should be forbidden from releasing two 7 song albums in a row but this one is so good i'll forgive them.

There are a couple of wonderful tracks on this one. She Has No Strings is a whirling and tremendously powerful piece and the aptly titled Long Way To GO With No Punch is a truly beautiful piece that could roll and roll for hours without tiring the listener. But somehow the magic of Whatever You Love You Are and Ocean Songs, and even their rawer early effort Horse Stories, has deserted this record. Perhaps there is too much reliance on minimalist techniques of repetition - the music never seems to find those secret and entirely unexpected places that make the aforementioned records unique. They performed a big tour on the back of this one so perhaps there was a tendency to find music that would sound big on stage, thus the subtlety and complexity of arrangements on, say, Whatever You Love You Are has necessarily gone missing. I don't know. I only know that the Dirty Three are one of the very few makers of music in this world who matter and we who love them cannot help but expect much.

I think that this is the best thing that they have done. Thats not easy to do.

This album started off strong with the first song, but then it started to drag and drag for a bit, I'm usually very patient with bands like the Dirty Three and their albums, but this one seemed a bit mediocre, atleast for their standards. Go buy 'Horse Stories' or 'Ocean Songs' instead of this and see them live if you can, they are great.