4 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
She-Hulk has lost her way..., November 25, 2007
This review is from: She-Hulk Vol. 5: Planet Without A Hulk (v. 5) (Paperback)
Unfortunately, the new, improved She-Hulk series, revamped by Dan Slott, has lost its way - if you've read the last couple of volumes (including this one, "Planet Without a Hulk"), you've noted an unfortunate decline into abject wackiness. Slott has, throughout the series, displayed an appreciation and, perhaps, nostalgia for the weirder, more obscure corners of the Marvel Universe, and most of the time it has worked - not so now, I'm afraid.
"Planet Without a Hulk" finds She-Hulk wrapping up her latest adventure - the troubles with Eros, the titan of love - which ended in her "accidental" marriage to John Jameson, lately re-transformed into the wolf-like Stargod. Upon returning to Earth, Shulkie is drafted into the Hulkbuster unit of SHIELD, where she battles the Abomination, Zzzax, and even the Wendigo (for some reason, at the side of Wolverine), and engages in ad ill-advised love-affair with Tony Stark. However, things turn sour when the Jade Giantess discovers the reason behind the Hulk's disappearance form Earth and has her powers permanently removed by Iron Man. All this, and her law firm in defending The Leader. Also, we learn more about how She-Hulk's gamma-related powers have affected her psyche. And, if that wasn't enough, there are also superpowered dopplegangers from another dimension (I'm not kidding). That's a lot of ground to cover in one volume.
Add to this the fact that this fifth volume of She-Hulk also acts as a wrap-up of most of the series' loose plot points, including: Awesome Andy's recent origin and his resolution of his love for Mallory Book; just where did Pug go, and why (and what will be the fate of his relationship with Jen/Shulkie?); did comic book genius Stu Cicero really get vaporized?; and what is the story with the law firm's new boss, the robot-in-disguise Mr. Zix?
I'm afraid that this comic has just gotten too madcap for its own good. It started with a good premise: She-Hulk hits rock-bottom and starts anew as a lawyer practicing superhuman law, and embarks on a journey of self-discovery along the way. It got a little cosmic (that's fine), we ran into some beloved old foes (Titania, for example), and had some fun. Now, its just gotten way out of hand. Additionally, Rick Burchett supplies the art. Burchett has a distinct style, and he is excellent at what he does; however, I just can't see that his Bruce Timm-meets Disney renditions of characters works in a book that has equal parts comedy and pathos - it's just too cartoony.
I'm desperately hoping that She-Hulk will shortly find its way again. As it is, however, she's but a shadow of her former self.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Stay away this isnt worth it., November 20, 2007
This review is from: She-Hulk Vol. 5: Planet Without A Hulk (v. 5) (Paperback)
First of all I am a big fan of She-hulk and this new run was a blessing to me, the first few books were amazing but as they advance they get worse I have no idea why. WHY MARVEL? This one by far is the worst of them all the artiest are the same as far as I can tell through they are getting a bit sloppy even the mighty Greg Horn really messed up with the faces this time around. Story wise everyone is acting crazy just about everyone is acting out of character. They throw quite a few of jokes but honestly most fail to delver the laughter.
Start off with She-Hulk running around the glob capturing Hulk foes "Abomination" Badly badly out of character. All the way through bunch of no bodies. All that for Ironman to develop a weapon which neutralize the Gamma powered beings and use it on She hulk when she confront him of what he did to Hulk. After that it's all the way down the ally of silly characters silly twists I guess its there humor on the whole comics. But it really had gotten out of hand. I used to read the whole book fully it would grab me. But this one I keep forcing myself on it. Shame on you Marvel. Fans stay away.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No