From Publishers Weekly
Set in 1897 during Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee, British author Roberts's eighth Sherlock Holmes pastiche captures the language and spirit of Doyle's originals while keeping the great detective and his legendary medical sidekick in character. Diana Fordeland, a well-known journalist who also served as governess to the children of the king of Mongkuria, calls on 221B Baker St. because she believes that mysterious men have been shadowing her and her granddaughter. With typical brilliance, the sleuth soon finds the roots of his new client's troubles in her past travels in Russia, which are of interest to various foreign factions, including the czar's secret police. While the relative slightness of the puzzle makes this effort a notch below Roberts's best work (e.g.,
Sherlock Holmes and the Harvest of Death), this highly enjoyable outing is far superior to 2004's
Sherlock Holmes and the Rule of Nine. Second only to Denis O. Smith among current writers at evoking the Watsonian voice, Roberts needs only a more complex plot to truly shine.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Roberts' latest entry in his imaginative series featuring Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson is the best yet. It's Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee, and London is filled with visitors from afar, including Mrs. Diana Fordeland, of Canada. But Mrs. Fordeland has a problem, one that she is sure Holmes can solve. She fears she is being followed, and she cannot find a credible reason to explain why. At first, Holmes thinks she is imagining things, but when he discovers that she is telling the truth and that one of the men following her is the diabolical Major Kyriloff, head of Russian intelligence in London, he becomes genuinely concerned. As Holmes concentrates his considerable powers on unraveling the case, he finds himself drawn into a decades-old tale of intrigue. The charismatically eccentric Holmes takes center stage, of course, but he's admirably supported by clever writing, an unusual plot, historical authenticity, and well-drawn characters. One of the most traditional--and traditionally satisfying--of the many series that update the Holmes canon.
Emily MeltonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved