Customer Reviews

Sherman's March and Vietnam

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Reston (son of long time NYT reporter, columnist, editorial board member James, "Scottie" Reston) compares the tactics used by the much maligned General Sherman in his infamous "March to the Sea" at the close of the American Civil War, with the tactics used by Westmoreland in Vietnam.

Reston's bottom line is that the horrors allegedly committed by Sherman are exaggerated, but he clearly redefined modern warfare, by making it a legitimate tactic to terrorize civilians in order to undermine the enemies "will to resist." This tactic found its ultimate expression in Hiroshima, but was strongly echoed in Vietnam.

One of the great ironies Reston focuses on is that the south generally decries Sherman, but extols Westmoreland.

The book is now obviously dated--it would be very interesting for Reston to do a "post 9/11" edition. But the lessons Reston draws from Vietnam and Sherman's march are well worth applying to our current occupation of Iraq.

If you believe that the American soldier committed unspeakable atrocities in Vietnam this is the book for you. His Civil War history is so off it is not even funny. He gets basic stuff wrong like the order battles took place in. If you are interested in Sherman or Civil War history read James McPherson or Lee Kennett. If you are an ex-hippie that wants to feel good about your wasted youth this is the book for you!