Customer Reviews

Shinbone Alley

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Back in 1954 there appeared a short but charming long-playing record on the Columbia label entitled "archy and mehitabel," which put to music some of the stories and sketches originally created by New York journalist Don Marquis. The twenty-five minute mini-production on side a was absolutely charming, and it was complemented on side b by an eighteen-minute additional series of songs and musings called "echoes of archy." The lp featured the voices of Carol Channing and Eddie Bracken, and was a veritable masterpiece featuring witty lyrics, catchy tunes, and outstanding performances all around.

Unfortunately, the old Columbia catalogue of musical shows has not been treated kindly by new owner Sony Music, and so "archy and mehitabel" has never been re-released on cd. The original production was, however, expanded in 1957 into a short-running Broadway show entitled "Shinbone Alley," which featured Eartha Kitt as Mehitabel. This show included the music from the original "archy and mehitabel," plus some additional tunes, most of them fairly undistinguished. "Shinbone Alley" was released on cd in 1993, but has gone out of print since.

Consequently, the only version of the original "archy and mehitabel" music and story currently available is this oddly produced 1971 animated production. The good news is that the cartoon features once again the voices of Carol Channing (the quintessential Mehitabel, in my humble opinion) and Eddie Bracken. It also faithfully includes most of the music from the original 1954 lp release, and features some charming moments in which the animation and music blend together splendidly.

The bad news however, is that overall, this production seems disjointed and at times, choppy. For whatever reasons, the vocal performances of both Bracken and Channing pale beside their 1954 originals; by 1971, apparently Channing's vocal range had contracted to the point where she had to change keys to sing some of the songs, with sometimes disquieting results. More inexplicable is that the animated presentation omits one of the most memorable numbers from the original lp production, the defiantly romantic duet between Mehitabel and her love-of-the-moment, the tomcat Bill. Finally, whereas some of the animation is imaginative in its creation of a modernistic and somewhat abstracted urban alley-cat setting, all too often the approach used during the songs themselves is to fall back upon what appear now to be highly dated Peter Max-esque psychedelic doodlings ranging from the mildly interesting to the just plain silly.

For those of us who continue to treasure the original recorded production of "archy and mehitabel," our aging copies of the 1954 vinyl lp will remain preferable to this cartoon production. For anyone else interested in this still-charming urban fable, however, the animated version of "Shinbone Alley" currently remains the only game in town.

I decided to jot down a few thoughts about this gem of a film after viewing it the other night. I had recalled enjoying it immensely as a child, and this time I was definitely not betrayed by memory! The story is all about Archy, a plucky and bold yet intensely romantic-souled cockroach/poet, and his good friend Mehitabel the sexy and independent alley cat. You would not think that one could get so involved with animal characters of this sort, but you do, due to the fascinating viewpoints & quasi-human features of the cats, bugs, and rodents who inhabit Shinbone Alley. Although Archy and co. still maintain some basic traits which are representative of their species, they also operate as fable-esque types who satirize many human traits. Mehitabel steals the picture with her sassy, liberated philosophy of life, graceful dancing, and lively singing{ her voice is charmingly supplied by Carol Channing}. You can`t help but love her: she`s a fetching hybrid of Mae West, Eliza Doolittle, and everyone`s favorite stray cat. One of the story`s running plots involves Archy`s unrequited feelings for her, and you really do find yourself rooting for him: his wistful efforts to help her find a place as a house cat are constantly thwarted by her show biz ambitions and her many boyfriends. Despite some quarrels, the pair remain close, and this makes this the rare animated film to depict the ups and downs of a friendship. Mehitabel and Archy are always there for each other, no matter what the crisis. Highlights of the movie include gorgeous, bright visual depictions of Archy`s poems,and thesong "Flotsam and Jetsam", in which the pair take a joyous ride down the rivers of New York on a trash can lid. I should add that much of the material is PG in nature, but much of it will also go over a child`s head{i.e., Mehitabel`s covert sexual flirting, a few mild alcohol references}. Also highly recommended: Don Marquis`witty and touching poems, on which the musical that was adapted into this film was based.

I loved Shinbone Alley. It was one of my favorite movies as a child and I was so happy to find a copy of my own. I love the bittersweet relationship between Archy and Mehitabel, and Mehitabels steady stream of tom cats remind of a lot of lonely women that I know. I especially love Archy's soap box speeches, and the music in this movie makes me want to snap my fingers.

I saw this movie as a child so I was expecting to enjoy it again. You can never go back! That is not the worst of it.... the quality on the dvd is pretty bad, like it was recorded from a vhs and burned from someone's laptop. pathetic

Archie the cokroach poet first called himself to public notice in 1916 when he began leaving notes on the typewriter of New York Sun columnist Don Marquis (pronounced MAR-kwess, incidentally).

Since the typewriter was a manual model, archie had to type (quite slowly) by climbing up on top and jumping on the keys one by one. He couldn't handle the shift key, so he used no capital letters.

Besides being a "vers libre bard", archie also was a raconteur, rather in the style of Will Rogers, and often told tales of the goings-on in Shinbone Alley, where he and Mehitbel the alley cat (a reincarnated Cleopatra) resided.

The columns featuring archie and mehitabel were quite popular, and were first collected in book form in 1927 ("archie and mehitabel") [still in print], followed by more volumes in 1933 ("archies life of mehitabel") and 1935 ("archiue does his part").

The books were illustrated by George Herriman, creator of "Krazy Kat", and his lanky loose-limbed but tight style fit the characters and material beautifully.

There were stage productions in the 50s and 60s (Mel Brooks was involved in the Broadway version), with first Carroll Channing and then Eartha Kitt as Mehitabel (Eddie Bracken played archie opposite Channing.)

And then, in 1971, came this film.

The animation (except in one sequence) is simplified in style compared to Herriman's art and Mehitabel is a caricature of Channing rather than basically a Krazy Kat klone (sorry), but it captures the feel.

My own favourite moments:

John Carradine as the old-style theatre cat who saved the day for a famous Shakespearean actor (i fear i have forgotten whom) when a jealous understudy hid the star's beard just before the performance. The cat, as he explains, knowing the show must go on, leapt to the star's aid... and clung to him throughout the performance, playing the beard.

Archie's declaration of war against humanity, in which the animation drops into full Herriman-style.

And Archie's report of his interview with a moth, trying to fathom why moths fly into candle flames. "Have you ever seen the beauty that exists in the heart of a flame?" the moth asks in turn, and archie concludes:

"...and, boss, i wish there

were one thing that i

wanted half as much

as that guy

wanted

to fry..."

Wonderful film -- but do not make the mistake of assuming that "It's a cartoon -- it's a kiddie film." As a quick rule of thumb, if you can't or don't want to pre-screen it, call it PG13, though i wouldn't hesitate in showing it to younger kids if i thought they would enjoy it and understand some of the issues raised.

Or, on the other hand, perhaps it ought be labelled, as a shelf card in the bookstore in one of Will Shetterley's "Bordertown" stories reads: "Children and Unusually Perceptive Adults"

(To give credit where credit is due, i consulted Don Markstein's massive online reference, the Toonopedia, for the relevant dates opf archie and mehitabel's first and subsequent appearances.)

This is based on the great Don Marquis's long running newspaper columns about a fictional cockroach and his impossible love for a (very) alley cat. The Marquis material, in several collections, is priceless and well illustrated by the great Herriman (of Krazy Kat). The original LP of musical material (issued in the 50s and now on CD) was very good and Channing and Bracken excellent in the roles. This cartoon can't decide if it's for children or adults (it could have been a very sleek and sophisticated "Fritz the Cat"); what's worse the production values are Saturday morning level, the kids won't notice. The imaginative sequences really betray this. But there are several songs here that are not on the LP/CD; there are also several songs on the Bracken / Eartha Kitt complete live double CD missing on either. There was also another animated version with Tammy Grimes as Mehitibel that was released on a bootleg LP, which I've not heard or seen. But a really good stage or animated version of the source material remains to be done. It certainly hasn't dated. The ravages of human behavior are more widely recognized in popular entertainment than they were when Marquis began this tale around the time of the FIRST world war. The only filmmaker I can imagine now who would do it right would be Terry Gilliam, who might benefit from going back to animation too.

It starts off with an attempted suicide, but that is just the beginning. don marquis' archy & mehitabel comes to life on this video (unfortunately I've never seen it in a theater). Carol Channing was one of my favorite actresses. Her voice is totally unmistakble. Who else could have done Romeo & Juliette with such zest? archy's wonder at the passions and the drama of life at the lowest level is a great way to comment on life at marquis' level. Flotsam & Jetsam is one of my favorite musical scenes. Music vidoes now don't reach this level of creativity. archy and mehitabel show a great lust for life even as they experience extreme hardship. I've shown this film to my nieces, who at the time were about 7 & 8 yrs old. They quickly became fans too. There are many things that are too sophisticated and would be missed by children, but there is enough for them too.

Shinbone Alley is based on the Don Maquis characters archie, the human-poet who turned into a cockroach after dying, and mehitable the stray alleycat. This rare cartoon contains surreal themes and visuals, as mehitable's wonton ways are chalenged and archie, who now writes esseys on a newspaper editor's typewriter, wows her but is fustrated with her attitude. Often "Shinbone Alley" isn't the best of all animated films. The animation is colorful and has a lot to offer, but usually has some flaws, the biggest one is where archie for the first time discovers that he's a cockroach which appeared completely stiff to me. But there are some amusing moments here, some comedy and a few nice songs. mehitable is the best thing about the movie, though. Carol Channing did her voice, which combined with work and performances of mehitable's animators, creates for some slick catish charm and sensual appeal to the character. When she gets to play Juliet from "Romeo and Julet" is the most humorous part of the film. So it may be OK seeing for young and old alike

Many years ago I owned a Columbia LP called "archie and mehitabel" with Carol Channing, Eddie Bracken and David Wayne as cat, roach and "boss" respectively. Foolishly I lent it to a student and never saw it again. When the Broadway play came out titled Shinebone Alley, it used all the songs from this 25 minute (or so) LP side and added more songs of less distinction. I never heard the original cast LP of that show at all. Since then I have hunted high and low for the original LP or the Shinbone Alley LP with Eartha Kitt. If anyone out there has either for sale, please let me know right quick. This video, then, was a blessing to me in that I at least have all the songs back again. I still cannot understand some lines sung by the chorus and Channing does tend to bury enunciation under her singing style. So I could use a copy of the script also. Help, anyone?

Well, having just seen this film, for the first time, last week, I can safely say, that it is something of a mix for me. First, Id like to point out what was wrong with the film. It is a bit on the weak side, when it comes to animation. Much of the work, though professional, is shakey. Secondly, for some reason, and this entirely my own opinion, I felt the Carol Channing as a voice, was not the best choice for Mehitabel. Who I would have chosen, will remain with me. Also the songs as sung by the voice actors, just didnt seem to me, to be all that good, as tunes. But, before I see someone tear this review apart, I would like to relate what was right with this movie. First, it had a semi tragic element, that made the movie appeal to me. Though the songs were not particularly tuneful, their message of LIFE, and the survival of its trials, was abunbundantly clear. None of the characters give in to complete depair, even though at times they come terribly close, especially archie, but they come back for more. Mehitabels theme song is a good example of this. She, despite my feelings towards Ms. Channing, is the key to the movie as a whole. This film grew on me, despite my initial doubts about it. I gave this movie four stars, because of the courage it must have taken, to put it together, in the face of all the cute stuff Disney put out, knowing that there was an audience out there somewhere, who would appreciate this film.