Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Shopping for Porcupine, June 13, 2008
This review is from: Shopping for Porcupine: A Life in Arctic Alaska (Hardcover)
Seth Kantner's second book, "Shopping for Porcupine: A Life in Alaska," is part autobiography, part historical narrative, part environmental treatise. His successful blend of all three creates a wonderful sense of place, a wilderness adventure and above all, an understanding of the land that is Alaska above the Arctic Circle.
Born in 1965, Kantner's 43 years on this earth, most of it lived in Alaska's north country, chronicles a pace of change--technological change, environmental change and cultural change--at a dizzying speed. The changes over his 43 years eclipse the changes of centuries. The proliferation of "Snow-Gos"(snowmobiles), replacing dog-teams, dog-sleds and mushers, the arrival of satellite television, the move to a cash-based economy from subsistence hunting, gathering and fishing--these changes have occurred in Alaska's north country since the 1960's.
In Seth Kantner's life, he lives the transition from the old ways of hunting and fishing, of dog-power and of a quiet life in the bush. He interprets this for readers in a style so gentle, so subtle that it kind of creeps up on you before you realize how radical and rapid these changes are.
"Shopping for Porcupine" includes a generous helping of utterly fantastic photographs of Alaska's north county. It is also a tribute the the traditional Inupiaq subsistence culture and way of life that with the passing of the elders--all of whom in 2008 are about 60 years and older-- will exist no more.
In 2001, I flew to Kotzebue, which is North America's largest village above the Arctic Circle. Kotzebue is the jumping-off point for wildnerness trips into the northwest quadrant of Alaska. Kantner's descriptions of life in Kotzebue and in surrounding native villages is right on the money.
After taking a bush flight out into the Noatak Preserve, I spent two weeks backpacking, hiking up mountains, wading across fast-flowing streams and hopping tussocks through wet tundra. For me, reading, "Shopping for Porcupine" was like re-doing my bush trek from my kitchen table chair.
"Shopping for Porcupine" is carefully written in a concise and parsimonious style. Every word counts. If Alaska Senator Ted Stevens would read this book, I would like to think he would have a much better understanding of Alaska's north country and greater respect for the land. He might learn something about the caribou migration. It might even change his mind on oil drilling in ANWR.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great non-fiction, July 12, 2008
This review is from: Shopping for Porcupine: A Life in Arctic Alaska (Hardcover)
When I saw that Kantner had a second book, I was skeptical. It seemed to come too hard on the paws of "Ordinary Wolves." I felt there'd be no way it was as good as "Ordinary Wolves", his first book and an instant Alaskan classic, that "Porcupine" would be just cashing in on the critical acclaim of "Wolves".
How wrong I was.
The non-fiction account of "Porcupine" gives Kantner both more and less latitude with characters and stories than "Wolves". In "Porcupine" he provides us the true backstory to the amazing story-line in "Wolves", in many ways both more satisfying and more interesting than his fiction. Here we can read the real-life version of living in a sod igloo as a youngster, the real people that inspired the cast of characters in "Wolves, real landscapes and interactions with them. After reading "Shopping for Porcupine" I had to re-read "Ordinary Wolves" and found it even better the second time.
The photos are stunning, but I like the writing more as Kanner's words convey non-visual emotions that photos miss.
I look forward to his next book, whatever it might be, as his bush upbringing offers us all a simultaneously fresh but surprisingly shared perspective on all things.
"Shopping for Porcupine" is well worth $30, if for no other reason than it will prompt this wonderfully gifted artist to write still more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Shopping for Porcupine, July 7, 2008
This review is from: Shopping for Porcupine: A Life in Arctic Alaska (Hardcover)
Shopping for Porcupine is a beautiful, thought-provoking book that defies genre.
It is more than an autobiography of Seth Kantner, who was born and reared in a tiny, mouse-infested sod igloo on a bluff above the Kobuk River in arctic Alaska. It is also a collection of essays and articles Kanter has published elsewhere. The result is a wonderful story of a boy growing into a man in one of the remotest places on earth, but it is also a glimpse into the lives and society of old-time Alaskans, both native and white, and how the 21st Century is warping the old ways. The book is a passionate statement about an environment in flux and in peril. It is also a love letter to an impossibly beautiful, brutal and unforgiving land.
Kantner's splendid photographs add greatly to his colorful and sensitive stories about pioneers, trappers, hunters, and the creatures he encounters in the far north. The striking images and Kantner's own gentle humor and insight seem to soften the often hard realities he writes about.
After reading Kantner's excellent novel, Ordinary Wolves, and this non-fiction work, Shopping for Porcupine, it became apparent that to call one fiction and the other real is plain silly. Kantner tells the truth in both. Sometimes his truth is hard to take, as when he describes "hunters" who fly onto the remote tundra to slaughter wolves from speeding snowmobiles. Sometimes it is honest and endearing as when Kantner flies with his wife and daughter to a gala event in New York City to receive a prestigious literary award and the best he has to wear are clean jeans and a Banana Republic T-shirt.
Kantner is modest about his own skills and toughness. He is more giving, more complimentary to others. The result is that Seth Kantner is a man you want to know better. A good beginning is to read his books, visit his website. You'll be glad you did.
--Dave Gilbert
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|