Customer Reviews

The Short Bus: A Journey Beyond Normal

5 star:		(20)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(4)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Short bus. I rode a short bus. I hid in the bathroom during round robin reading. I faked sick on Spelling Bee day. I had teachers that were damning but I had teachers and parents who believed in me. I'm one of the "odd" people with ADD and a learning disablity. Now I teach kids with learning disabilities so I have the perspective from both sides. Mooney paints a vivid picture of the darkness a disibility can bring. I cried though this book, but I laughed too. I hope people read this book with a open mind. For every kid with a bad school experience there is a kid with a good one. I wish Mooney could move beyond his bitter anger and make lemonade from the lemons he is sucking on. I think his next book should focus on alcohol and drug abuse of adults with ADD and LD. He might learn something about himself. I gave this book 4 stars because it is beautiful but I wish a could talk to Jonathan and remind him that our world is better because of the stuggle people like us went through. More later, I need to think this one over.

I received the book yesterday afternoon and proceeded to sit down intending to read a just a few chapters and then get dinner on the table for my boys...5 hours later, I was still reading-- I could not put the book down. I ended up reading it cover to cover at the kitchen table. I haven't done that in ages. Luckily the boys are old enough to fend for themselves!!!

This is an emotional book. It's also a really wonderful book. Jonathan has really challenged me to look inside my own self and confront my own pre-conceived ideas and ways of looking at people who are labeled disabled. I really think this book should be required reading for educators and professionals who are dealing with students or clients with disabilities, it reminds you that behind the label there is an individual who brings with them their own unique gifts and wonderful qualities. We cannot.. no we must not forget that.

I didn't ride the short bus; I came from a previous generation. However, Jonathan's experience rang true. I didn't hear any false notes. Getting my doctorate didn't take away the scars from the educational system. But I came from a different era. That's why I couldn't believe my eyes when I read the one negative review posted by J O'neil.

Certain words have an emotional impact and are only said to hurt. To publically shame a LD person for mispelling something is familiar and one of the most abusive things we can experience. It's a not-so-sublte way in our culture to win an agrument or to announce to the world that you think someone is stupid. Spelling is a gift that many LD people don't have, even though we possess many marvelous gifts. Yet O'Neil, a principal of a LD program no-less, did this. What is most disturbing is that this person seems blind to the irony. There are good teachers who fight this sick system, where these attitudes are tolerated. Thanks to J O'neil, the problem is all there in a paragraph--everything that Jonathan articulated. As I said, I found his insights about school true and I thank him for expanding the conversation.

Jonathan also takes on the issue of "normal," something that gets kicked around loosely but seldom discussed in depth. His reflections allowed me to look beyond myself, again, to the bigger question of how we all fit in this larger community. He does this in a way that's both fair and sensitive. Thanks.

I have finished reading Jonathan Mooney's "Short Bus" and also several reviews of the book. I thought the book was okay - no more or less than okay. The concept - a former "sped" kid buys a "short bus" and travels the country talking to people of various disability - is interesting, but the execution was somewhat pedestrian and, as another reviewer noted, somewhat whiny.

The overall "message" (or theme) of the book is that people with disabilities have (rather than are) disabilities. There is, it's true, a certain inadvertent tendency in most of us to reduce people to their disability. Moody interweaves his own story of a dissatisfactory youth (he is ADD but was labeled stupid) with others' similar struggles: several parents of children he met on his journey were engaged in lawsuits against their child's school.

But Moody often takes a worthy idea too far, in suggesting, as he often does, that disability is more a social construction than a biological reality, and often gets quite "whiny" about this. He frequently lambasts those who try to "fix the disabled," such as believers in Cochlear implants for the deaf. (In a contradiction, he also chastizes teachers who don't recognize and accomodate for disabilities like ADHD, leaving us to wonder if we are damned if we do, and damned if we don't.)

Meeting the "characters" - an ADHD artist, a blind/deaf girl, a student with cerebral palsy confined to a wheelchair, etc - was interesting, but I never felt like I "got to know" any of them. In an irony, Moody's intent of letting us "get to know" the people behind the disaiblities backfires, because in the end, I felt like the only thing I DID get to know were their disabilities. The encounters were brief (one lasting only two pages) and Moody's "discussions" with the students were never really illuminating.

In the end, the saving grace of the book was the strong narrative and "story line" of it. Moody had an interesting concept and, while it never really delivered much of what was promised, it was interesting in its own right.

As a special educator, I am glad to see books like this (and films like "Autism: the Musical"), but really wished for a bit more insight into the "characters" and a bit less whiny preaching about the injustice of being disabled.

This book was a requirement for a graduate course I took on learning disabilities. The teacher had a copy on hand for us to thumb through the first day of class. After just reading a couple of paragraphs here and there I couldn't let it go. I had to borrow the book that night and devoured it immediately. I bought a copy anyway because I think that all adults who consider themselves educated could benefit from Mooney's writing. I learned more in this text than I had in dozens of expensive textbooks. My copy is worn from being lent out to friends, colleagues, and family.

Mooney does not simply teach the symptoms of disability. He teaches interaction, empathy, and most of all that as with all things a sense of humor is a must. I appreciated his tone and found comfort in the idea that while things can seem heartbreaking, it is always okay to laugh. I am beginning my journey in the field of special education. When finding my interactions with students awkward and scary, I can open this book to nearly any section and find insight and support. The people that Mooney discovers on his path are what makes our world colorful, imaginative, and fun.

This book is a must have for any educator, family of a person battling with "normal", or anyone that considers himself a well rounded human being. Buy it! You'll be better off because of it.

This author came to speak to my son's class in Oakland. My son came home raving about Jonathan and how he "really really gets it." I ordered this book and could not put it down. As a parent of twins with LD, I can tell you, he really, really gets it. My sons have had the same type of classes/teachers described in the book, and yes, they are out there and they do exist. I know,let's blame the parents for abdicating responsiblity and basically being the problem. All parents of special needs kids have heard the same responses from the employees of the public system. The system "sucks" and we/they continue to deny it. I plan on giving this book to all my friends for Christmas. Read it. Even if this is not your kid, I can attest to the fact that there are millions of these "lost kids" out there with no heroes out there to rescue them.

I had the pleasure of hearing mr. Mooney address the freshman class at university of Idaho this week. His book is the "common read" selection for this year for U of I. I read his book and was very glad my son is attending a school that is supporting the ideas expressed in this excellent story. Please read this book. It will let give you the gift of a new perspective on education, human dignity and how we as a society define normal (and the price we pay for that ridgid definition).

Mike

What a must-read for all of us! And I do mean all of us. In The Short Bus, Jonathan Mooney travels far outside his own experience and across America to discover for himself (and us) what it means to experience life in America if one is not "normal." His journey and the conclusions he draws from it provide profound contributions to America's self view as a society and culture. It offers a much needed look in the mirror.
The short bus for Jon, and for all students labeled LD, symbolizes the well intentioned but nonetheless painful humiliation administered daily to the children relegated to it. Our children were labeled and then separated from their peers and their classroom because they didn't fit or belong in the classroom with the "normal" kids. Hoping to rediscover and heal from the pain inflicted by these experiences, Jon tours some of America's other labeled individuals: a deaf and blind student who curses her teachers in sign language, an eccentric man with Aspergers who creates his own community connections in remarkable ways, and a young woman with Down Syndrome who is so unforgettable, her story continues to both haunt and comfort me long after putting the book down. With each individual, Jon explores his own feelings of wariness, prejudice and confusion that most of us experience but rarely admit when we confront folks who are clearly "not normal" or "disabled." He comes to know each of them, overcoming his feelings and soon understands their incredible gifts and how important they are to us as a community. We see, as he sees, the important and precious place each holds in the fabric of society. As we become increasingly engaged with our new acquaintances and learn to appreciate them in inimitable ways, we begin to cry out against "the tyranny of normalcy" because we discover how thoroughly the notion of "normalcy" threatens the heart of humanity.
It is a coming of age story, to be sure, but The Short Bus is far more important and much bigger than a personal journey. In addition, Jon's research and analysis provide us with a historical, medical and sociological context for the labels assigned to each of the marvelous individuals we meet on the short bus. Jon's voice is always honest and questioning, his insight intelligent and boundless, and of course, the book, like the author, is rich in humor.
The Short Bus is ultimately a celebration of life, providing a roadmap to empowerment and a deep appreciation for diversity, underscoring society's need to do so. It's an honest, painful, humorous and always engaging journey, and it's well worth the ride.

I purchased two books, wishing it had been 25, (one for the principals of our school's and one for the head of each SpEd room, plus a bonus book for the Superintendent). My spare, was a gift to the Director of Special Education, and if he can read it and empathize with (1) his students and (2) their parents, then "our academic world" will be a much better place.

The books arrived late Friday afternoon, and the Short Bus cover coaxed me into picking up Jonathan's book. I only meant to read a chapter, but two hours later as the sun was setting over the Rocky Mountains, I was half way through.

Jonathan's book reminded me of why we fight; that the fight is not even about getting our children an appropriate education per se--it's about the injustice of a system set up to embrace each and every child, and watching it for the past 7 years choose to ignore and marginalize the very children who need embracing the most.

Educators need to re-discover compassion and commonsense. Jonathan shows you that the hallway, the principals office, the write-ups and the taking away of electives, are no longer acceptable actions of behavior. The negativity surrounding special education students needs to shift. And shifting attitude does not cost money!

Jonathan tells it as it is. He stands in the shoes of giants, and gives a voice to the voiceless.

In fact, from now on, "they" can't be part of our IEP team, unless they have read "The Short Bus: A Journey Beyond Normal"!!

Bravo Jonathan!

For those who have never ridden a short bus this book is a must read; for those who have ridden the bus, this ride can be healing. In this book, Jonathan shares his personal struggles from being "labeled" as a child, and mends the wounds by riding the short bus again, this time from a different perspective, in control and in the drivers seat.

Within the pages you not only hear about Jonathan's personal journey of growth but that of others who have struggled because they were not viewed or treated as "normal". Infused in these stories of pain and hope Jonathan shares some history of how the "disabled" community have been marginalized by society . Whether it is having to wear the "label" of a disability, ride a short bus or legally enforced sterilization the history is not pretty. It will make you think differently when you hear words such as retarded, idiot or simple minded.

This brilliantly written book is an amazing journey that Jonathan shares with us and we all learn from his trip. What is normal and what does it mean to be normal? The lesson for anyone who has ever been treated different or felt different is to embrace your difference. Like we learn in the book from Jonathan's friend Kent; "normal people suck".