11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
World History from the viewpoint of wines, February 1, 2004
This is definitely an exciting book for anybody interested not only in wines but also in history. With a bit more than 300 pages Rod Phillips paints a fascinating journey of wine from its unknown origins the politico-economic-cultural-medical scenes of today. The task is not small. Rod Phillips does an excellent job. To write history of this nature you must be a historian, which is the author's trade; without this background the intricate connections between world history and wine would remain shallow. In a way the book is a (limited) view on world history. The book is well written and contains many delightful stories in the long history of wine. I would have enjoyed the book even more if some additional editorial work had been done. For a reader the trends and economic significance of wine could have become more clear with tables or figures summarizing the abundant information contained in the book which is further blurred by the unsystematic usage of measures; litres, hectolitres, gallons, not to speak about ancient hard-to-understand measures are being used in parallel complicating matters unnecessarily. I personally would have appreciated a sepatate treatement of vines.
I am sure wine tastes different after having read this delightful little book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting choices, December 20, 2006
This review is from: A Short History of Wine (Paperback)
A 'history' of wine is necessarily a matter of elimination.
What to leave out? What to include? Rod Phillips has chosen
to focus on the political and social context in which wine
and the wine trade developed. Fortunately, wine is at least
as much a cultural product as an agricultural one so his
effort is both appropriate, necessary and a bit overdue.
The author is a historian, so we get sharp attention paid
to some things that are left out of most wine histories:
*aside from Patrick McGovern's Ancient Wine, no one has
done as literate a treatment of the questions surrounding
wine in prehistory and the Classical Period. It's refreshing
to see an author acknowledge the Mycenaean roots of winegrowing
in the Mediterranean.
*in a very few pages, the author deals with the intricate
nature of the relationship between Bordeaux and England.
In the course of the explanation, he underlines the
significance of trade in the development of wine regions
and styles.
*the chapter called Wine and Its Enemies quite rightly
deals with anti-wine forces in the natural world (phylloxera)
and in the cultural world (prohibition).
*the chapter on the wine revival in the late twentieth
century gives due emphasis to the rôle of corporate mergers
and huge drinks companies in the development of wine.
The author is on less sure footing here with the cultural
underpinnings of the wine revival. Did the upheavals of
the Sixties have anything to do with it? Is this not also
the time of a wine decline as consumption decreases in
wine's traditional european homelands?
This book would have benefitted from closer proofreading
and a slightly more generous application of maps. On the
other hand, the cover is a work of pure genius. I have
never seen a wine book cover that so effectively evoked
wine's pleasures, its wetness and (yes) its redness.
--Lynn Hoffman, author of THE NEW SHORT COURSE IN WINE and the
forthcoming novel bang-BANG from Kunati Books ISBN 9781601640005
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No