16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
highly recommended, January 11, 2006
This review is from: Shostakovich: The Complete String Quartets (Audio CD)
If you have read this far, you must be serious about your Shostakovich, so I will cut to the chase. For me this box set, surprisingly unreviewed until now, is one of four highly recommendable sets of DSCH's quartets.
The 1st and 2nd Borodin sets need no further comment from me; they breathe an intensity and authenticity whilst getting to the heart of the music. The Fitzwilliam set, with its amazing recording quality, clarity and expressionistic gestures, is the best non-Russian cycle, and continues to wipe the floor with more recent sets by the Emersons, Brodskys and Manhattens etc. whose effects-driven performances largely miss the variegated depth of meaning therein.
This cycle by the Shostakovich Quartet, recorded between 1978 and 1988 in Moscow, has fuller tone than the Fitzwilliams, and the ensemble plays with a more romantic intensity than any other except the Borodins. The interpretations themselves are, as to be expected, more 'Slavic'. What become virtuoso showcases for other, non-Russian ensembles (e.g. parts of Quartet no. 8 and the end of no.9) here are transformed into unhinged Russian folk dances.
Throughout these quartets, this ensemble has the measure of Shostakovich's soundworlds whilst having a solid command of the musical structures, resulting in compelling performances that never dull the interest (the Fitzwilliams, whom I love, do tend to make my mind wander in particular slow movements).
Unfortunately, Quartet No. 8 has a rather underpowered 2nd movement, though this may be the fault of engineering; the rest of this quartet is very well realised.
Especially fine interpretations of No.s 6, 9 and 14 help this set to stand out from its competitors.
In sum, if you are looking for a complete cycle, I highly recommend this Shostakovich Quartet set. If you are looking for fireworks (but without real emotional engagement), go for the Emersons or Brodskys. If you are looking for an equally valid alternative to the Borodins, this is it.
This cycle is the genuine article, well recorded, authentically Russian, effortlessly played. Rather meagre packaging, however.
Ignore this set at your peril!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No