16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Horrific honesty, September 20, 2000
This review is from: Shut Up and Deal: A Novel (Paperback)
First, (most important) if you don't play poker you won't get much out of this book, if you do play... read on.
Good poker is a boring, often frustrating business, and this "novel" (like most first novels, it's fact thinly disguised as fiction) struggles with that reality.
Narrated by a jaded, yet moderately sucessful young pro named Mike (in the original manuscript he was probably called Jesse) its a frank honest look at the "glamourous" world of professional poker. Poker is a game of skill in the long term, but because of the high chance element, can be anything but skill day-to-day. As Mike says early on "the skill ain't hard, its mastering the luck that's difficult."
As the novel progresses we gradually realise that Mike isn't really going anywhere. At times he's quite wealthy, at other times he can hardly make the buy-in for a medium stakes game, but the only thing that distinguishes him from other skilled players, is his persistence; the gritty resolution to ride out the streaks of bad luck and keep going.
Like any cardroom, the book has its "regulars" - players who appear over and over again. Among them is the vividly drawn Bart Stone, who may be the devil - a reckless evil conman with occasional flashes of charm. Opposed to him is John, a mellow, amazingly talented player who's blown his winnings on cocaine and is making a comeback. The two play several times, eagerly watched by Mike, but the end result, like many a poker game, is less about winners and losers, and more about a few bucks up or down due to the cards on the day.
People complain (rightly) that "Shut Up and Deal" has no plot, and doesn't go anywhere. But its this honesty that makes the book so real. Pro poker players don't go anywhere - they work in the cardrooms, they put in long hours, and for obvious reasons they don't make many friends and their working hours don't encourage a social life. Casinos are magnets for misfits and this strange sub-group are no exception. The locations can change but the games, and even some of the players remain the same. If Jesse May can't plot this novel very well, he's got no such problems with description and atmosphere - you can see, feel, and even smell the grubby glitter of the casino cardrooms where the action takes place.
The final section of the book is the best description of being "on tilt" (i.e. playing badly from frustration, and not necessarily realising it) that I've ever read. Familiar to anyone whose played cards seriously for any length of time, the helpless reader is drawn into the irrational yet compelling innner voice of Mick, explaining everything away...
Flawed, yet very powerful and honest, "Shut Up and Deal" is the perfect antidote to yet another sugar-sweet article in "Card Player" magazine. Its also a must-read for anyone contemplating a professional career in poker.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Only if you play, January 16, 2001
This review is from: Shut Up and Deal: A Novel (Paperback)
For non poker players, I can't imagine that this is worth buying. It is completely focused on the world of poker playing, mostly in east coast casinos. For poker players looking for advice, techniques, and ways of winning, this book won't help much. It's not about poker strategy, it's about the poker world, or one part of it.
But if you are interested in that poker world, this book is fantastic. I swallowed it in one grim, exciting, painful gulp. As previous reviewers said, there is no real plot, no real story, just poker and the strange world it creates. It's almsot philosophical. It tries to figure out what makes people keep on playing, what separates the live-ones from the sharks (and how easy it is to cross back and forth from one to the other), it's zen and poker. As a poker wannabe I found it to be a powerful warning of where I could go if I tried to walk in May's footsteps.
I'd also love to meet the guy, which I think says something about his book.
Whatever you do, don't play with a guy named Bart.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Finally! A peak on the personal daily diary of a rounder!, February 13, 2002
This review is from: Shut Up and Deal: A Novel (Paperback)
I agree with the other reviewers that this book is for poker players only! The author uses lots of poker terms and jargon that is familiar mostly to poker players. And it's hard for a non-"rounder" to understand what's truly going on in the authors mind.adrenaline, excitement, bluffs, and that one critical decision that separates winners from losers! Personally, as a poker player, I enjoyed the book all the way to the end, got my adrenaline pumped up several times from just reading some of the action and decision making in the story.
Like I said, this book can be really entertaining if you are a rounder, however, the storyline lacks a progressive organized story plot, not terribly bad for a person who doesn't write for a living but the story and character development could've used some refining. It's more of a personal daily diary than a true novel...just keep that in mind while reading the book and you'll enjoy it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No