Customer Reviews

Sibelius: Symphony No. 5 (Cambridge Music Handbooks)

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This book is very informative. It gives a good insight on Sibelius' attitude to composing, his fears and his view of his standing to his pears. It also gives a good overview on the Symphony and an interesting approach to Sibelius' form. Those interested in Sibelius' metronome markings on the Symphony from 1947 find a good comparison to the most recordings, which is very revealing.
A very helpful book for me to get close to the piece for study and hopefully for a good performance of it next week.

Jean Sibelius' Symphony No. 5 is one of the great achievements of late Romanticism and stands as the Finnish composer's most widely loved works in that genre. It is a piece ingenious in its internal workings and with a great history behind it and, and James Hepokoski presents this all to us in his entry in the Cambridge Music Handbooks series.

Before even talking about the symphony itself, Hepokoski gives us a great deal of background. We see Sibelius, the composer of the radical Fourth symphony where dissonance is unleashed, meets the music of Schoenberg. He realizes that he can't compete in that area and decides to blaze his own unique path. This, Hepokoski notes, was only one episode in a great encounter between "modernists" (the generation of the 1860s) and makers of the "new music" (the Second Viennese School and others). Out of this encounter Sibelius fashioned between 1912 and 1915 five central concepts for his music: content-based forms ("fantasias"), rotational form (varied multisectional strophes), teleological genesis ("phenomenological" reflection), Klang meditation, and the interrelation and fusion of movements.

One all this is established, Hepokoski gets to the Fifth itself. We follow the long course the symphony took towards completion, amply illustrated by extracts from Sibelius' diaries and correspondence. Many of his musical sketches are here, and it is remarkable how so much of the material that Sibelius was writing during this time found its place in the Sixth and Seventh symphonies, making this guide useful for fans of those as well. The exact modifications Sibelius made in the rewriting of the Fifth in 1916 and 1919 are clearly explained, and the reasons for these changes are suggested from the critical reaction to the earlier two performances. The commentary on the music itself of the 1919 version is relevatory, for although Sibelius' symphony is quite accessible and its main lines quite elegant, Hepokoski can draw your attention to little details that make it all the more enjoyable.

A final chapter discusses the different editions published and Sibelius' own tempo markings set down late in life. Hepokoski compares some widely available recordings of the Fifth. Vanska's recordings of Sibelius' orchestral works are increasingly seen as the cream of the crop, and it is a pity that they could not be included in the discussion of performances here. In fact, most of the recordings that Hepokoski examines are those made with foreign conductors like Karajan, Davis, Ashkenazy and Bernstein who arguably distorted the work by making it too generically Romantic and expunging it of Sibelius' unique character.

It's a pity that there isn't any section on the impact of Sibelius' Fifth on later composers. Per Norgard has stated that the scoring of the Swan Hymn's second appearance in the third movement, where the bass plays the theme at the same time as the horns at one third the speed, was a major inspiration for his own multidimensional thinking.

One should have a score of the final version at hand to follow Hepokoski's commentary, as he often refers to bar numbers. And though he wrote the book at a time when the only recording of the 1915 version was a tape passed around in the academic community,readers today are fortunate that a BIS CD is available where Osmo Vanska leads the Lahti Symphony Orchestra in a performance of both the 1915 and 1919 versions.

The Cambridge Music Handbooks series offers insightful and thorough analysis of the best works within the classical music repertoire (and baroque/modern for that matter). I purchased this book for class and really appreciated how much more Sibelius' process in composing his 5th Symphony had become to me.

If you're a composer, read this in order to gain insight into another technique/form for writing long concert orchestral works.

Bought this book for a class. If you are into 20th Century Analysis or Sibelius or like 20th Century Music then this book is for you. Otherwise you will not enjoy reading this. The book clearly states the emotions of Hepokoski's take on Sibelius's composition as well as a breakdown in the score.