Most Helpful Customer Reviews
164 of 169 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Corrections to previous reviews, March 15, 2000
This review is from: Siemens 2420 Gigaset 2.4 GHz Complete Cordless Communication System (Office Product)
Overall, this seems to be an excellent system. First, let me correct a few inaccuracies in the other reviews. Mr. Mehlman states that you can't repeat or skip messages in the answering system remotely. The manual clearly states that you can. He also claims that you can't play back messages from the cordless handsets, but the manual also says that is possible. Mr. Szymonik and Mr. Doumet both claim that you can't transfer phone directories between the base and handsets, but I have done just that. What don't I like? First, there are no voicemail boxes in the answering system. Each line can answer separately, but you can't have boxes for different people on the same phone line. Second, while you can control the ringing frequency and volume for calls placed to different lines and the intercom, you can't change the ringing pattern. I would like one long ring for Line #1, two short rings for Line #2, and three shorter rings for the Intercom, for example. Third, the desk unit handset is so sleek and rounded that it's difficult to hold between your ear and shoulder. Fourth, the phone's user interface isn't intuitive at times or even consistent. For example, to add a new entry to the directory or send the directory, you hit the Dir button, then have to select a name, then scroll through the action list to find the appropriate action. Selecting a name should not be required for global actions. As another example, to page another intercom station from the handset, the menu shows the extension number and part of the name, but to send a directory to another station, you must enter the number without seeing the names. However, except for the lack of voicemail boxes, these are fairly minor issues, and should not detract from the review.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
61 of 62 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
4 1/2, really, but the mailboxes..., March 31, 2000
This review is from: Siemens 2420 Gigaset 2.4 GHz Complete Cordless Communication System (Office Product)
First of all, I also feel obligated to correct some inaccuracies in others' reviews. I didn't like reading these reviews that give the system a bad rating because of supposed shortcomings when the shortcomings aren't there! Yes, you can transfer directories (have done so), and yes, you can access your messages from the cordless handset (including to repeat and skip messages) - hit INT 9, it's on page 58 of the manual and it works. Transferring calls between base and cordless is also not that complicated! Plus, the manual has quite an extensive index, so finding whatever it is you're having trouble with is a snap (like that thing on page 58). As for the ringing, you can change the pattern on the cordless handet even though they term it as pitch, going through the choices will change the actual ringing pattern. True, oddly, this can't be done on the desk station. I've turned mine completely off, since I know where it is, and rely on the cordless handset's ring to inform me which line is ringing. The one significant drawback I did discover was that when calling in to check for new messages, both lines are treated as one, in other words, if I would like to call in and check for new messages left only on "Line 1" I am given any new messages - for Line 1 or Line 2. This may or may not be important to others but it seems that mailboxes would have been a smart and easy design feature to include. This is not so important to me but really should be part of an answering system like this. Overall, though, there are so many easy-to-use features, the system is powerful, flexible, sounds great, looks great, and while the base handset feels a little light, the base and cordless units feel great, buttons and such. If the mailboxes are important to you or your business, you're out of luck, but aside from this flaw, I feel the system is 5 stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
66 of 68 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Pretty Face, Poor Implementation, September 26, 2000
This review is from: Siemens 2420 Gigaset 2.4 GHz Complete Cordless Communication System (Office Product)
I own 2 of these phones and 6 handsets - bought them all at once for my home/home office. It is definitely the sleekest looking phone out there. However, for paying top dollar, it has some serious design flaws. To cut to the chase: Pros: - Beautiful design. - Handsets are light and easy to handle. - Range seems very good and voice quality is very good. - Adding handsets is easy and convenient - no jack required. Cons: - Cannot pick up a call from a handset after the answering machine has picked up (no call interrupt). - Cannot use other-brand external phones to join a call in progress. - When power is lost or unplugged, base phone loses time and date requiring reprogramming. VERY annoying and I cannot believe they overlooked this. The phone has a backup battery for crying out loud. - Answering machine does not recognize hang-ups resulting in lots of blank messages. - Transferring a call from one handset to another is a MAJOR pain requiring a bunch of keypresses. VERY poorly designed and non-intuitive. - Too easy to accidentally delete a new phone message if you press delete a bit too late. - Handsets are small and light, but not ergonomic or well designed for fitting to your hand. - I had two handsets die within about 4 months. Questionable quality. - Simple things like changing the volume on a handset during a call is very awkward and requires scrolling through a series of menus, so you can't change the volume without taking the phone away from your ear for about 10 seconds. Poor design. - Virtually everything is menu driven and requires a series of button presses and scrolling through menu items. Awkward. - Too many features are password protected on the base requiring entering a PIN every time. Is this really necessary? There's more minor flaws and annoyances, but for the price I would expect a MUCH more user friendly design. Whoever designed these phones was probably a "tecchie" - scrolling through screenfuls of menu options is ok for software, but not for cordless phones. Many often used features should be incorporated into buttons rather than menu items (like the handset volume). The number one thing that annoys me is trying to transfer a call to another handset. If I pick up a call one one handset, my daughter can't simply yell from another room, "I got it", then simply press talk on her handset. No - it's a series of button presses, etc. and about 75% of the time it doesn't seem to work or the call gets lost. Totally totally annoying and an inexcusable design flaw in my opinion. Overall, for the money you can do much better. If I was able to get my money back I would in a heartbeat. I'm stuck with a $1000+ phone system which is a real letdown overall. At least it looks nice.....
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|