Customer Reviews

Sign of the Crooked Arrow (Armada S)

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This review concerns the original 1949 edition, as well as the revised 1970 edition which is merely a shorter version of the original. The Hardys investigate a group of criminals who are boldly robbing pedestrians in Bayport and other towns. Also, Frank, Joe and Chet go to New Mexico to help Mr. Hardy's cousin Ruth when cowboys start mysteriously disappearing from her ranch. Are the two mysterys connected, well of course they are, but you have to read the book to find out how. The book was pretty good; it was well-written and the setting of New Mexico was used effectively without the book sounding like it was a tour guide. There were a number of interesting characters and a good amount of action. There probably would not be too many Hardy Boys fans that would be disappointed after reading this book.

With the "Secret of Skull Mountain" the Hardy Boys series picked up in quality. The most noticeable feature of the last couple of books is the simpler mystery as compared to the previous books where the mysteries were often very complicated. The author (a fellow by the name of Andrew Svenson wrote the original, and Priscilla Baker-Carr wrote the revised version) also improved the pacing of the stories, with the action helping to move the book along reasonably briskly.

This mystery begins with the boys investigating the mystery of a car that was left at Slo-Mo's garage in Pleasantville. Slo-Mo has asked Fenton Hardy to find the owner of the car. The car is missing its license plates and the engine serial number is gone. The boys call in the local police, and then search the car, finding a portion of a watch band and a tie clasp with a crooked arrow design on it. After the boys complete their search of the car they are about ready to leave when a man attempts to take the car from Slo-Mo.

Shortly thereafter the boys witness two men in conversation. Suddenly, one of the men slumps to the sidewalk, apparently passed out. When the boys assist the man, they learn the other man robbed him. Frank and Joe learn from their father that there is a gang robbing people along the East Coast by using a similar technique. Before the investigation can proceed further Fenton Hardy is shot with an arrow!

The trail leads the boys to a tobacco shop where they are able to buy "Arrow" cigarettes for $5 each. The boys learn that a man by the name of Arrow Charlie brings the cigarettes around from time to time. Before the boys can pursue the lead further, an urgent letter from their Cousin Ruth in New Mexico causes Fenton Hardy to send Frank, Joe and Chet Morton to investigate. Cousin Ruth runs Crowhead Ranch, and her cowboys have been disappearing without a trace one at a time.

Another airplane follows the boys as they travel to the ranch. They also encounter engine trouble. To their surprise, the boys also see the same crooked arrow symbol formed by trees as they fly toward the ranch. It appears that Arrow Charlie and the robberies in Bayport may somehow be related to the mysteries on Cousin Ruth's ranch.

As Frank, Joe and Chet continue their investigation, someone tries to shoot them with a poisoned arrow. The boys also encounter a flash flood. Someone sets fire to their Cousin Ruth's ranch. The boys also learn where the missing cowboys went in an action packed ending for this book.

The increasing pace of the action in this book, with the nicely focused mystery, make this book a good read and one of the better entries in this series. I recommend this book for those looking for a sample of how interesting the Hardy Boys can be.

The Hardy Boys series is recommended for ages 8 to 12 because the series is relatively tame for the previous target audience of ages 10 to 14. However, the series still contains some interesting moments and will keep most readers guessing the answers to the mysteries until the final solution is revealed.

Published in 1949 - Crooked Arrow is a great adventure story by "Hardy standards". What drags this book down is the first 6 or so chapters. However, by page 85 this volume picks up in a hurry and from this point forward is an excellent adventure story set in the west. It mirrors Wildcat Swamp in some respects. The book chronicles the brothers adeventures on a western ranch. Tandy's artwork is exceptional as always. Great book certainly worth reading. RATED A-

This book is one of the better written ones in the series as the Hardy boys find the true meaning of the crooked arrow and uses New Mexico well as the backdrop for this mystery.

yo yo this book is off the chang yang ya herd. this book is so gettow. my friend said this book was gay but i told him it was so cool yo.