28 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
4 1/2 You Decide, March 17, 2005
This review is from: The Silly Book (Hardcover)
With such diverse opinions about this book, I thought I'd excerpt a few representative lines to give you an opportunity to preview it. Author/illustrator Stoo Hample originally put out "The Silly Book" in 1961; Candlewick published this edition in 2004. Not having seen the original, it's difficult to say how the two compare. In general, I think that nostalgia and memory make the booklover's heart grow fonder. However, Candlework's typical high production values (thick glossy paper, quality book materials) may actually work against the frivolity of the book; a cheaper 'zine (slang for low-tech magazine) format may have been more consonant with the throwaway silly humor. Here's an example:
SILLY STORY
I want to see my mommy a minute,
My mimmy a monnit. My mommy a minnit.
I want to see my mommy a minnit.
To sing her a little song,
To sing her a little.
To ling her a sittle,
To sit her a lingle long.
(I think my mommy will like it
Because it's a very short long.)
Nothing extraordinarily clever here--you're not gonna get something akin to the "Mozart effect" (in which parents play Mozart for their infants, hoping to stimulate their brains). No, when Hample titled this "The Silly Book." he meant it.
Here are some examples. Note how some of these riddles and word plays are now very formulaic for adults. The example immediately following is the kind of riddle that helped build one adult comedian's (G.C.) reputation.
SILLY QUESTION
If people get chicken pox, What do chickens get? SILLY ANSWER People pox.
ANOTHER SILLY QUESTION
If Mommy eats a Popsicle, What does Daddy eat? ANOTHER SILLY
ANSWER A Momsicle!
A few other examples follow:
SILLY MILLIE
"I am silly,/You are silly, All of us are silly,/ Willy./ All of us but cousin/ Millie./ She's upside down." (The poem is next to a picture of Millie, upside down, holding a flower labeled, "Tillie.")
SILLY RECIPE
"Cook three pieces of/spaghetti in a pan of/water for two years.
Add one teaspoonful/ of chocolate syrup/ and mix well.
Spread on bread/ and freeze.
Feed to teddy bear."
More than most books, this one depends on the interaction between the reader and the audience. When read with the right expression and tone to a receptive, language/sound fascinated boy or girl, this may be great fun and build future warm memories. Read cold off the page, many of the riddles, poems, and other prose come off as familiar word play. (By the way, the accompanying illustrations are generally simple, although sometimes drawn with clever dialogue or captions). Perhaps in 1961 this book was somewhat ahead of its time; the utter nonsense of these books may have been a refreshing change for some. Soupy Sales, a somewhat comparable visual and linguistic entertainer, was still a few years away from TV. Soupy, however, has a few more layers of meaning--there's a sly wink at the adults not seen here-this book centers around little kids only. "The Silly Book" will not ruin your audience's language; instead, it has the potential to increase their enjoyment of language, and, most importantly, to build lasting memories of reading and silly time. Given that context, I can recommend this book, especially for those adults who can add the enthusiasm that comes from finding an old favorite ready for a new generation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No