Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Clever and Consistent, December 8, 2008
This review is from: Silver: My Own Tale As Written by Me with a Goodly Amount of Murder (Hardcover)
Edward Chupack's Silver takes place long after the adventure on Treasure Island. Long John Silver has been captured, and is confined to his cabin, bound on his own Linda Maria to England and the hangman's noose. Ever the narcissistic rouge, he drafts his memoirs as an address to the Maria's new captain, a former hearty of Silver's. Chupack's novel (as it is written in the moment) takes place entirely in Silver's cabin - he never speaks directly with the captain, just the cabin boy Mollett as he brings Silver his daily meals and Silver sends him back with the pages of this memoir, subtitled "My Own Tale as Written by Me with a Goodly Amount of Murder." And Silver does tell of murder, as well as the sea, and the men he has met, and the treasure he has found, lost, and finally reclaimed and hidden.
Chupack's depiction of Long John Silver is clever and consistent. He has a strong voice that never wavers through the telling of his story. Chupack also succeeds in preserving the somewhat romantic qualities of pirate life - the freedom, the honor among thieves, the glory of the open seas. Even though the body count resides somewhere in the triple digits by the end of Silver's tale, it should be noted that the violence is not graphic and is often glossed over with something as simple as, "so I slit the tar's throat." The way Silver tells it, it's less like murder and more like an occupational hazard.
Despite the wit and charm of this book, I still feel there were a few weak spots. Early in his epistle to the Linda Maria's new captain, Silver condemns the fever that has started to grip him. What begins as a mere annoyance seems to become a real threat to his health, both physical and mental. He drifts frequently from his tale into self-absorbed rants and eventually hallucinations. At these points in the narrative, there is nothing much for the reader to do but soldier on, as there is little purpose or plot to follow. I was equally disengaged by the repetition of the clues leading to Silver's grand treasure. First the cipher means this, and then it means that, but it could perhaps mean something else altogether. Frankly, Chupack lost me in this wild goose chase, and I just floated through to the next spike in action.
I did find myself invested in the different vignettes Silver painted. I enjoyed reading how he came to be Long John Silver, and not just another boy living off the pity of others in Bristol. I enjoyed the many scenes aboard the Linda Maria as Silver moves from cook to captain, and the depiction of each of Silver's questionable mates. I also appreciated the subtle revelations near the end of the book, and how they tied so many pieces of Silver's history together.
I have read some complaints about Chupack's lack of loyalty to the Treasure Island story, but I was not affected by this in the least - probably because my only exposure to Treasure Island involves singing Muppets. If you are adamant about the two books being in harmony, then you might give pause before diving in to Silver. But if you can forgive some zigzags in plot and pace, and you enjoy a fun pirate tale, then this is certainly an enjoyable read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The pirate's due, October 25, 2008
This review is from: Silver: My Own Tale As Written by Me with a Goodly Amount of Murder (Hardcover)
Treasure Island is the pirate story to begin and end all pirate stories, and Long John Silver is the pirate to begin and end all pirates. But in Robert Louis Stevenson's fabulous tale, we learn very little about the black-hearted rogue at the center of the story, which focuses instead on the heroic adventures of young Jim Hawkins.
Edward Chupack sets out to tell Silver's tale, and Silver is a swashbuckling novel that suits a pirate through and through.
Silver is one of literature's great villains. But Stevenson and Chupack both could tell you he was no one-dimensional character; he has layers, and depth, and fathoms of fascinating history captured in the grime under his nails and on every bloody scar.
"My heart?" Silver tells his foe during a shipboard duel. "It ain't as big as a mustard seed."
He strides through this story larger than life, a pirate who could make a Blackbeard or Morgan eat his own heart for breakfast. And there is, of course, treasure, the grail to Silver's lifelong quest. Every ship he ransacks and burns is merely a step on the map to deciphering the clues and finding it.
There are weaknesses here, one of which is Chupack's decision to cull a few key figures from Treasure Island but discard the meat of the story. Most of Silver takes place long before Silver and Hawkins crossed paths, but once they do, the plot takes off in entirely different directions. And, while I understand Chupack's desire to create something new, I also question the wisdom of basing a novel on a book you then choose to ignore.
Silver also suffers from some repetitiveness and awkward randomness in narration that, while it suits the fevered state in which Silver recounts his past, can be a little prickly to get through.
The story, though, is a thrilling adventure, with enough swordplay and gunnery to sate even the bloodiest thirst.
by Tom Knapp, Rambles.(n e t) editor
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Prose that sparkles like so much pirate treasure, March 21, 2008
This review is from: Silver: My Own Tale As Written by Me with a Goodly Amount of Murder (Hardcover)
I'm one of those people that has somehow made it through life without ever having read Treasure Island, so I have no idea whether having that literary experience would make one appreciate this book more or not. Chupack says in his author's note that he took Robert Louis Stevenson's characters, especially some of the minor ones, and changed their characters and situations, using Treasure Island as a starting point. Critical reviews have noted that is neither a sequel nor a retelling of that book. I can only approach this book as a stand-alone read, but on that basis this novel absolutely delivers and entertains.
The Silver of the title is, of course, Long John Silver, a murderous, treasure-hungry pirate who says of himself "I am the dog that bites the other dogs. What do I fear? I am John Silver, and I am more dog than man and more dog than dog." When we meet him he has been taken prisoner by an unknown person and locked in his quarters on his own ship, from where, battling a raging fever, he writes his memoirs and tells the boy who brings him food about his search for a very special treasure. Silver's memoirs cover his early life on the streets of Bristol, his being taken on board the pirate ship by Black John, and his life as a murdering pirate. But most of all, it covers Silver's search for the treasure of a lifetime and the treachery that goes along with it.
The story itself isn't a terribly deep one and gets repetitive at times, while the mystery is not one the reader will want to work too hard to solve on his or her own. It's the language that makes this book sing. I could open the book to any page and find something wonderful to quote. It's also the details about the pirating life and the world of the late 17th century, from London to Spain and all the way to the Carolinas that held my attention right down to the final word. The characters are fabulously drawn, from the ratlike Pew to the alcoholic Billy Bones to Edward the dandy to Solomon the Jew.
Chupack's Silver may be a murdering, thieving scoundrel, but he's a charming and intelligent one and I only hope that Chupack is not too busy being a 21st century pirate (i.e., a big corporate real estate lawyer) to write more books. And no... I don't know him. I'm a real Amazon reviewer and I read and loved this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
