142 of 152 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Simon's Odyssey, August 27, 2004
This review is from: Simon Lazarus (Paperback)
This is a wonderful coming of age story, with all the classic elements, but with a few twists. Simon tends to the see the world in absolutes. He is quick to idolize or demonize people, and, as a result, he finds himself frequently confused or disappointed when the disparity between his ideal and the actual person is revealed. The genius of the novel, to me, is how seemlessly it presents this characteristic of Simon, while at the same time allowing the reader to discover, through Simon's narration, that he does the same thing with himself. He is his own harshest critic, and as we are learning about the divide between Simon's perceptions of those around him and actuality, we start to see the divide between Simon's perceptions about himself and reality. We largely learn these things from what others say in Simon's presence, not through anything he tells us himself. Whereas Simon feels awkward, incompetent, and easily embarrassed, we learn that he is more complicated than that, and cooler and more multi-dimensional than he seems to think. This lesson comes just as Simon is learning that the world is more complicated and multi-dimensional than he understands.
The story is about Simon's awakening, or as the book's tilte suggests, his rebirth. Simon plunges into a type of post-Gen-X odyssey -- complete with sirens and trials of all sort -- initiated (probably subconsciously) by his father and with the encouragement of his surrogate father, a therapist that he has begun seeing just prior to the beginning of the events described in the book. In many ways, it is a quest book -- a book in which there is a final truth, and which, it turns out, is exactly what the character has been searching for. There are some rabbit holes along the way, the either go nowhere or end abruptly, but in the search, he learns what we've learned for 323 pages -- that the world, and the people in it, are complicated, as he is himself.
The quest motif is what keeps the pages turning, and it's a very difficult book to put down. But at bottom, I think, this is a story about fathers and their sons. The women in the novel -- primarily Simon's family -- are all characatures, and Simon's chief romantic interest is so heavily idealized by Simon that we really don't know much about the real her at all. The relationships most heavily explored are the four father/son relationships that spread over five generations in Simon's family. The thread is woven around an object -- which serves as the catalyst to Simon's odyssey -- from the war that took the first father's life, and that nearly took the third son's. In the string, we see (1) the grief and despair of a son who has lost his father to war, and the consequences of that loss, (2) his relationship with his own son, who has turned out to be disappointing, (3) that man's son, who was never good enough for his father, and carries the guilt of perhaps being the cause of his father's greatest loss, and (4) the fourth son -- Simon -- who has the chance to act as surrogate to find for his father the redemption that has alluded him, and to mature in the process. Woven in to the story are some incohate thoughts about the need of men to get in touch with their emotional side, which to me were a little less satisfying than the father/son threads.
Anyway, he's a great character to get to know, and the trip is worth the ride. It reminded me very much of another book, Rule of the Bone, which explores very similar themes in a very similar way. If you enjoyed that book, you'll almost certainly like Simon Lazarus, and comparing the two main characters -- Simon and Chappie -- is a great deal of fun.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
92 of 97 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Have a great trip with Simon Lazarus this summer!, May 6, 2004
This review is from: Simon Lazarus (Paperback)
Taking a trip with a self-centered nineteen year old is not on the top of anyones "to do list", especially if you want to have a relaxing, good time. That is exactly what I am proposing for book lovers to do this summer! And you will have a fabulous time! When Simon starts his adventure he is a person you would love to leave behind but very soon his wonderful metamorphus begins to evolve. His character grows exquisitely,and captures the reader with lots of humor, zesty conversation, and enjoyable storytelling. Simon gains a depth of spirituality along his way that is enticing to the reader. Other characters in Simon's world are so rich that you would love to pick up your next book and learn about them as well...I ask the author to please give us more stories about these well manicured characters...Simon's father, sister, grandfather, and girlfriend...I for one was not wanting the book to end!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
51 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good read-- beginning to end, November 6, 2006
This review is from: Simon Lazarus (Paperback)
This strange little story started with a few huffs and puffs. I wasn't so sure about this one (so many others have ended up duds). I didn't quite know what to think of the dark pensiveness of our protagonist, Simon, but heck if the kid doesn't have a lively voice, albeit a warped sense of humor? Perhaps, this kept me in the game--but it took about 50 pages in before I really began to like Simon Strayhorn and his sharp take on the world around him.
I found it hard not to laugh. I could not resist the other characters, either, and I think this is what is so special about this read. The assortment of types from the rich-kid and nerd-brain roomies, to the middle-aged, balding Boyce, the Fleetwood Mac-gen parents, and on to the many others that populate our hero's odd adventure. Maybe this read isn't exactly for everyone--but I surely enjoyed it. And far more than Augusten Burroughs' repetitive memoirs or the many day-in-the-life novels for the assumed (by the publishers, it seems) navel-gazing, 20-something crowd. It's a smart read that also entertains. That, in itself, makes this novel so special by today's "anything goes" standards.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No