16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Complete, July 12, 1999
This review is from: Simone de Beauvoir: A Biography (Paperback)
Really, this book was a page-turner, a book of facts so well-written it made one want to know more, more, more, even when the knowing was almost painful out of de Beauvoir empathy. I wanted to read it as a companion to de Beauvoir's autobiographical series and was particularly grateful to Bair for pointing out incidents in which de Beauvoir "guilded the lily" when she recounted her own life. De Beauvoir's autobiography and this make perfect companions for a study on auto/biography and its subjectivication. (Also see Silent Woman by Janet Malcom.)
I had read previous biographical material on de Beauvoir, but none I ever felt was so complete, and helped me to know her so well. I strongly recommend this as history, literary criticism, psychology and philosophy.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Too repetitive, lacks analysis of her works and her ideology, July 6, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Simone de Beauvoir: A Biography (Paperback)
The value of this biography is that it adds new facts andcorrects some of SdB's own mis- representations of her life. But it'stoo repetitive, often concentrating on insignficant chronologies of her trips, etc. Lacks sufficient explanation of the stultifying catholic education she rejected early in her life (was it guilt-inducing jansenistic sexophobia, the doctrine of a caring God, etc) or of the basic existentialist tenets which guided her life, such as the self-creating life project, absolute responsiblity for choices, etc. Badly in need of a final summing up chapter listing and analyzing the very disparate opinions about the contradictions and import of this amazing woman, eg was it unfathomable tenderness or simply self-delusion that enabled her to transform the ecstasy she felt with Nelson Algren into the sublimest and most poignant love affair? In many aspects of her life SdB could be a example for many women, but after reading this book one is still left wondering how and why.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
THE DEFINITIVE BIOGRAPHY OF A MAJOR 20TH CENTURY INTELLECTUAL, December 22, 2009
This review is from: Simone de Beauvoir: A Biography (Paperback)
Deirdre Bair intereviewed de Beauvoir for five years, before producing this magisterial biography. Although de Beauvoir wrote four volumes of autobiography (
Memoirs of a Dutiful Daughter (Perennial Classics);
The Prime of Life: The Autobiography of Simone De Beauvoir;
Hard Times: Force of Circumstance, Volume II: 1952-1962 (The Autobiography of Simone de Beauvoir);
All Said and Done), Bair's account give much that de Beauvoir herself left out.
De Beauvoir explains the origin of her "Beaver" ("Castor" in French) nickname, which was given to her by fellow student Rene Maheu in honor of her "prodigious work habits" (i.e., "You're a little beaver"). When Bair asked about de Beauvoir's possible romantic relationship with Maheu in these early days, "The question produced a thunderclap of anger: 'That is absolutely not true ... I never even kissed a man on the mouth then, never, never, never!"
Of course, de Beauvoir's relationship with Jean-Paul Sartre is chronicled in some detail. Bair deals frankly with de Beauvoir's deference to Sartre: "Simone de Beauvoir declared repeatedly for the rest of her life that Sartre's intellect was superior to her own, and her remarks have caused consternation and anger in equal parts among those who study her life and work. This is probably because she frequently describes herself in ways which would make it seem that she never had a thought or idea that was not first given to her by Sartre." Bair notes that they DID originally discuss marriage: "He proposed, citing the budgetary advantages of being posted to the same city and living in the same quarters. She declined, refusing to give in to bourgeois standards imposed by circumstances."
Bair chronicles the unusual sexual relationship between them: e.g., "It was the first of a succession of intense friendships Simone de Beauvoir formed with her students, all of whom subsequently acquiesed to sexual liasisons with Sartre." Sartre "openly paraded all his other women in full public view," while she "kept all her affairs as secret as possible because 'It didn't look good for me to be with other men. People expected me to be faithful, so I pretended that I was.'" Bair writes the "She told (writer Nelson) Algren that she and Sartre had stopped being lovers after their first eight or ten years together because Sartre was 'never enthusiastic in bed,' but that their friendship had become strong and deep." (De Beauvoir denied---not very convincingly---sexual relationships with women.) Her romantic relationship with Nelson Algren broke up as she wrote about the relationship: "Algren's rage over 'The Mandarins' was nothing compared to his fury over what she wrote about him in the memoirs."
Concerning the enigmatic statement "I was gypped" at the end of the third volume of her autobiography, de Beauvoir explained to Bair, "It was as if everything Sartre and I had worked for meant nothing. We had very little hope in our lives, and I expressed it in my writing."
De Beauvoir admitted her heavy alcohol use in later life to Bair: "I like to drink very much.... I mean, I feel better when I drink something in the morning.... the drinking I do during the day and the evening---that, for me, is essential. I need that."
This is a very detailed, absorbing, and insightful biography of one of the 20th century's most important and influential writers and intellectuals.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No