24 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A STORY RELATED WITH GRACE AND BEAUTY, March 17, 2001
This review is from: Singing Boy: A Novel (Hardcover)
As his debut novel, The Music Room (1990), garnered both critical and popular acclaim, Dennis McFarland soon found himself named among America's premier wordsmiths. His next two novels, most notably School For The Blind (1994), ensured his standing.
Readers anticipate this author's supple, compelling prose. Such expectations are fulfilled with Singing Boy, a poignant exposition of grief in which Mr. McFarland again touches upon his recurring themes of death, forgiveness, and the mercy of time.
Following a dinner at which he has been honored, Malcolm Vaughn, with his wife, Sarah, and Harry, their eight-year-old son, is driving home through a quiet Massachusetts night. Malcolm's attention is caught by an old Corvair blocking their passage through an intersection. When he goes to investigate, he is shot and killed by the Corvair's driver, a stranger. Harry watches as his father is slain, and Sarah cradles her husband as he bleeds to death on the street.
Upon arriving at the hospital, Sarah calls Deckard Jones, a black Vietnam war veteran, who is Malcolm's best friend. Deck, as he is called, is approaching fifty. He has spent time in a detox unit, is haunted by the horrors of wartime carnage, and has recently lost his girlfriend. His life, it seems, is going fast but headed nowhere.
"Spontaneous murder," according to the police, is the classification for Malcolm's death. However, this is not the story of a crime but a powerful tale of how three bereaved souls respond to tragedy. Each retreats in a different way, unable to contemplate let alone cope with their shock and grief.
Sarah, a chemical engineer, is immobilized, incapable of decision making, unable to offer Harry parental affirmation, even a modicum of guidance.
Of Sarah Mr. McFarland writes, "No one will understand that her grief is what she has left of him, and if she were to lose that, she would have nothing at all."
Young Harry conceals his trauma behind a mask of normalcy - he doesn't cry, he speaks politely when spoken to, reiterating that he is fine.
In analyzing Harry's behavior, Deckard concludes, "There was something too smooth about it, too business-as-usual, too no-problem."
Confronted with a grieving Sarah whom he is trying to nudge in a "back-to-normal direction" and a child who seems so extremely normal that it's worrisome, Deckard assumes the role of protector, repressing his mourning for a friend's death until personal crises threaten to pull him under.
Related with truthfulness and compassion the struggles of three people become a reflection of our own periods of loss. Many can relate to the words Harry utters as an adult: he remembers the summer of his father's death as a time when "he'd learned the word `inconsolable,' and what a deep deep well of a word it was."
Mr. McFarland has said that in this story he wanted to honor Sarah's "right to be inconsolable, her right for claiming as much time for grieving as she needed......I wanted to show that it's impossible to shape and pace grief through an effort of will."
He has accomplished this with with grace and beauty. For this we are grateful.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Book Leaves This Reader Torn, September 26, 2001
This review is from: Singing Boy: A Novel (Hardcover)
I'm reading this book and thinking already of the review I am going to write. That's not a good sign I wouldn't think. Here's the problem I read the inside jacket and the whole concept of the story drew me amd I wanted to get to know these characters and even care about them. Now I am almost finished(less than 20 pages) and I still have a lot of questions about Sarah, Deckard and Harry. The author gives you perspective from Deckard and Sarah, but I wonder what it would have been like to get inside little Harry's mind and hear from him. I really don't want to give the idea that this is a bad book but it left me wanting to know the real story and to dig a little deeper.
Finally, I must say I'm still mad that I read a reviewer on Amazon that decided to reveal the ending for all who read his or her review. Thumbs down to you!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No