Customer Reviews

Sixty Saints for Girls

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Being of a generation that remembers the treat of reading this book, I am delighted to see it return to print. For the very young reader, it can be a wonderful daily visit with various heavenly friends, and one to spark the imagination and perhaps a bit of devotion here and there.

The stories are basically selections from legends or particular aspects of saints' lives, presented in a rather "story hour" fashion. In fact, the narrative seems more like a favourite aunt telling a story than prose. The tales are not historically accurate in many cases, but there always is enough of solid underlying themes to get kids to learn them in spite of themselves.

My one caution is that this is strictly an "early reader" book. It is not accurate or thorough enough for anyone old enough to be doing research for a religion class, and anyone above the age of 8 is likely to find the constant definitions of words annoying. Nor is it a "read aloud" book for tiny ones. Joan's manner of expression, which basically has her "telling" the story in her own style, would make the words sound stilted in another's voice.

Joan Windham is an engaging, witty writer, and young girls of the current generation should enjoy this work as much as did their grandmothers.

My girls love this book both because of the style and the incidents in the lives of the saints. It is a very friendly book - which is unusual in a 'lives of the saints'. It has the added advantage of not having wretched illustrations!

I'm currently 48, but am looking to buy these books (..for Girls and ...for Boys) for my 2nd grade CCD class. I recall loving this book as a kid. It was my sister's, sent to her by her Godmother for First Communion, I think. I read the book very frequently. I too recall the odd capitalizations, but I was not bothered by it.
This (..for Girls) book is one of my fond childhood memories!

I wanted extra copies to give as gifts. As long as I was ordering, I decided to try Sixty Saints for Girls. Joan Windham's colloquial story-telling voice is very unusual and I find it captivating. I was an English major in college and her quirky capitalization and explanation of words doesn't bother me one bit. I was able to find only one copy at a reasonable price and so I'm keeping it for my grandchildren.

My Dad brought this book back from a trip to England in the early 1960s, and I read it over and over again. I can still remember parts of it by heart ("Winifred has left the taps running, tiresome child!"). The old-fashioned British style of writing may take some getting used to, but the stories are wonderful, and children who read the book will learn a lot about the saints.

While the book does have bad grammar...and yes they capitalize words in the middle of the sentence AND explain the more difficult words, the stories are entertaining. I have read it to students in Kindergarten and Grade One, and they seemed to enjoy the stories, in fact they ask for more! I agree that the author isn't perfect, but she is entertaining and I would like to read more of her books.

This book is great (if your seven!!). The grammar is so bad and they capitilize every other word and explain simple words as if we were all some kind of idiots. In closing, this book is so bad that you should give it to your worst enemy for Christmas and annoy her by reading it to her every day.