Customer Reviews

Sleep and His Brother

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I found this book extremely strange, and to put it mildy, I was also bewildered. I didn't understand it most of the time, and then I'd read a bit further, and then understand what had happened previously, but some new bizarre thing would happen, and I'd be in the same boat. I did not "get" Pribble, and I didn't really get the ending either. Dickinson description of the cathypnic children is actually wonderfully done. He shows a great deal of understanding and tenderness when he describes these children. Peter Dickinson is noted for creating strange and fascinating worlds, and he has certainly done it with this book. That part of the book actually overshadowed the mystery when it did finally come. He also does an admirable job in his characterizations. His description of the eccentric millionaire is quite wonderful, but I found the strangeness of the book kind of took away from that a bit.

As best I can figure out Cathypnic is a real word--the reference aside from this book has something about cathypnic reactions in opthamology, e.g., "immobile contraction of the pupil identical with cathypnic contraction." I had no luck on etymology, though.

But I doubt if there really is a hereditary disease that makes children psychic for as long as they are alive and mobile, not asleep or in something like a coma.

And Jimmy Pibble seems to be viewed by his bosses as the equivalent of an incompetent Columbo, the guy to send in when they don't want anything discovered. Mind you, he's got a pretty good record after everything shakes out. I think that there are a small handful of Jimmy Pibble mysteries.

Which does make for peculiar reading. I first ran into it sometime in the 80's, I expect, and I'm rereading it now.

So, even back at first reading, I thought it was half-way to some kind of science fiction. How did Dickinson create this universe, with the children the two doctors and Jimmy Pibble. For me,it works as a story as well.