Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Solid, Entertaining Book, September 15, 2004
This review is from: The Sleeper: A Novel (Hardcover)
Neil Gordon's review of "The Sleeper" in the Washington Post Book World is a farce. What is the point of defining what a novelist's main goal should be ("to see the truth of the world around him and convey that truth to the reader"), and then faulting the author being reviewed for betraying this arbitrarily chosen "prime directive"? The whole thing smacks of an egomaniacal English professor spouting dictums that we should accept on faith because he knows who "Stendhal" is. I'm sure Gordon's copy of "The Sleeper" had "Show, don't tell!" scribbled frantically all over the margins. For readers that have actually formed their own ideas of what makes a good novel, his peremptory verdict is a bit premature.
Gordon's rant about Dickey's fictional Saddam possibly providing Kurt, the lead character, with WMD's is equally absurd. "Would Dickey print this outrageous canard in Newsweek? Of course he wouldn't... But why is he printing it here?" Because Dickey made it up! That's why it belongs in his novel, and not in Newsweek. Where is the issue there? Should we be shocked that it would be more exciting to read about a world where Saddam might have given out a WMD or two? Should we be outraged that in Dickey's fictional writing there is actually some, well, fiction? "The Sleeper" may have important truths to convey, but if you're going to look for these truths in a literal interpretation of its plot points, you probably shouldn't be reading fiction in the first place.
To put it bluntly, novelists have to make stuff up, or else they wouldn't be novelists, they would be historians. To go back to Stendhal, "The first qualification for a historian is to have no ability to invent." Gordon knows that he can't really get away with panning Dickey for having fiction in his fiction. So he backtracks, saying that he's not upset about Dickey making stuff up, he's upset that Dickey is making stuff up and then using his investigative credentials as a selling point. (A point which should have at least been made at the outset, before the histrionic complaining about Dickey's flights of fancy.)
But the point about Dickey's credentials is that he is well suited to write about this stuff, not that we should believe everything in his book as fact. Steven Hawking would probably be good at writing a sci-fi book revolving around the physics of time travel. That doesn't mean that when he does we should all assume that he's saying that time travel is possible. ("Would Hawking print this outrageous canard in his next physics text book? Of course he wouldn't...) Is Dickey supposed to write a book of political intrigue and not mention on the book sleeve that he's been reporting on terrorism for over 10 years? ("Christopher Dickey lives in Paris and loves fruit-filled crepes and small animals...")
Regardless of the absurdity of Gordon's review, the very fact that someone who uses the phrase "Stendhalian representation of truth" didn't like this book should tell you all you need to know. Here is the low-down, stripped of ivory tower hot air: If you are looking for the straight truth about the Iraq war, don't read this book. That's what non-fiction is for. If you want to read an exciting book that creatively draws from the facts about Iraq and Homeland Security to tell an enthralling story (or as J. Peterman says "a ripping good yarn"), then you might like this book. You might not. Who knows.
I don't think this book is trying to communicate some deep spiritual message about the meaning of life. It's just a fascinating exploration of what happens when you take a couple of "what if" situations and let them play out. To whine about it not being "art" is like complaining that Will Smith isn't as good as Sidney Poitier while watching "Enemy of the State."
Daniel P. Bana (danbana@gmail.com)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Resonant with the ranging pulse of a post-9/11 American, September 13, 2004
This review is from: The Sleeper: A Novel (Hardcover)
I found Christopher Dickey's "The Sleeper" not just to be an a lucid narrative of a renegade patriot putting his own peace on the line for his family, but a compelling portrait of what it means to be an American today, sure of our need to fight but in question over who and what to fight against, used to wars when there are clear absolutes and defined goals, and faced with a climate where the professed enemy ("terror") is no more tangible than the values of freedom and liberty we are out to protect and defend.
Like "The Sleeper" 's protagonist Kurt Kurtovic, 9/11, at least temporarily, wiped out all the soul-searching, the jagged roads and winding pasts that many of us Americans took to sleep the night before, bringing us that next day to a jaw dropping impasse where nothing seemed the same and everything felt up in the air. And we wanted to do something, in whatever ways we could be of most service- for Kurt, it was going back into the bowels of the terror trade, a world in which he once thrived and which he is now ready to thrash in name of peace. And through his scavenger hunt from Kansas to Kenya for clues and old contacts, in search of honey merchants and jihadi training camps, his global pursuit of bad guys spawns more and more doubt if there are any good ones, even amongst those he trusts and answers to. And in the end... well, I don't want to be the "Spoiler" so I'll leave that to you.
The only main qualm I had with the book might be the depths at which the Dickey goes into the violence and torture used by and on the terrorists, but it is perhaps my own taste for the comforting that still finds such graphic details unsettling to fully conceive of, even if they are done in the name of saving lives. It's easy to forget the dirty work that comes with the territory of hunting down mal-intended extremists; back rubs don't make people talk and terrorists don't always just fall into our lap like the headlines often seem to indicate. The book might be fiction but it has the power and commands the empathy of the (all too) real world in which we now live in.
As an active reader , there are many things that press the "brew" button on my pot of skepticism, but here are three. One, book reviews full of judgment without any mention of substance about the story's content or any indication the reviewer read the book whatsoever. Two, labels affixed to genres of prose predicting the emotions a reader will have (you will be thrilled, you will "feel good"). Three, the flurry of journalists and authors implicitly or directly purporting themselves as "experts" on terrorism since that horrible morning 3 years ago when pre-9/11, like most of us, Al Queda sounded more like the name of a relief pitcher for the Expos than it did a well funded international network of Islamic fundamentalists hell-bent furthering the world divide by any means necessary.
This being said, while the Sleeper was definitely gripping, I wouldn't call it a thriller, but more mental and emotional fuel. Pardon the pun, but I wasn't much of a sleeper myself with all the threads of thought I was left to process after finishing it. And, knowing Mr. Dickey's work, as a Newsweek foreign correspondent and editor , including his book `Expats" on his travels in the Middle East, not to mention from a simple web search, the scores of articles he's penned from datelines around the Arab world since the 80's, it seems no stretch to count him amongst the most informed Western commentators on the changing landscape of the Anglo-Arab relations as well as the evolving nature of the war with those whose embrace terror as tactic. And clearly, as he footnotes in the book, his chameleon-like immersion as a globetrotting journalist into the circles of power-playing international statesmen and the ears to the pavement operatives at the heart of the post 9/11 world have been put to great imaginative use here, yielding a profoundly engaging and clear-headed story."The Sleeper" is certainly a telling look at the war of one individual but is also evocative of the many wars the bulk of us haven't realized we are fighting to this day.
Whether you fly through "The Sleeper" on a long airplane flight like I did or choose to digest it slowly from the tranquility of your bedroom, I'd highly suggest giving it a good read.
A.G.T.E.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
enthralling thriller, September 1, 2004
This review is from: The Sleeper: A Novel (Hardcover)
In Westfield, Kansas on September 11, 2001, Kurt Kurtovic turned on the TV to see his world collapse along with the Twin Towers. He knows that was just the beginning as the terrorists have further plans because he was once one of them and knows how they think. Part Muslim and working in the Special Forces, he was drawn into the Arab propaganda when he fought in Bosnia. Kurt even met Bin Laden before returning home carrying a weapon that would kill many Americans. However, he no longer believes in the Jihad as he relishes his tranquil life with his wife Betsy and their daughter Miriam.
However, he knows Al Qaeda is coming again gathering all their cells and operatives to help with the next attack. Kurt meets with old contacts and learns that ships are coming with weapons to kill many Americans. Arrested and flown to Guantomino Bay, he serves as a mole providing Intel until his release back to his family so that he could be the bait to lure and trap the deadly leader THE SLEEPER.
The protagonist believes he made many mistakes in his youth, but when he realized his errors he refused to join the mass murdering of innocents. Because he was one of them, he understands how they think and more important how they feel; he becomes an unsung hero willing to take them on in his town to stop the plots. THE SLEEPER is an enthralling thriller that takes plausible concepts as stated by Homeland Security and puts them into a fabulous frightening story.
Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|