9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A little bit twisted, but a good page-turner, August 11, 2005
This review is from: Small Town (Mass Market Paperback)
I suspect that the reason this novel hasn't received a higher overall rating on Amazon is because of the character, Susan Pomerance, who is -- to put it politely -- sexually kinky in the extreme, and whose exploits doubtless were a turn off to many Lawrence Block fans, who don't expect this kind of soft porn in his books.
I didn't much like Susan either. At first I thought Block had made a major error in giving her a prominent role in the novel, and even after finishing Small Town with a considerable degree of satisfaction I still think it would have been a more comfortable book without Susan. That said, I have also come to realize that Block included Susan for the express purpose of making his readers uncomfortable. After all, Small Town is a book about the aftermath of 9/11, a time during which no New Yorker I know was anywhere near comfortable. Those of us who survived the attack -- whether or not we had family and friends who perished -- were all affected. Ultimately, life went on, just as it does for the characters in Small Town, but life was surely different, and probably always will be.
I think Block's view is that 9/11 literally unhinged many New Yorkers. The blasts at the Towers shattered our assumptions and expectations every bit as much as they shattered steel, glass and human lives, with the result that some of us, including Block's characters, dramatically changed our life views and, consequently, our behaviors. Seen in this light, Susan's behavior becomes more understandable, if not acceptable.
And Susan aside, the others characters, particularly the Carpenter, are very well drawn. They operate in what is essentially a new world, which changed within the space of a couple of hours and which forces them to confront their fears and privledges in a way they never have. And the plot offers all of the suspense and credible detail we have come to expect from Block. It kept me turning pages into the night, which is, for me, the acid test of a good book.
So, if you enjoy a good story and don't mind being challenged by an unexpected anti-heroine like Susan, read Small Town, whose main character is, in the end, New York City itself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
OVER THE TOP SEX AND LOOSE ENDS GALORE, May 14, 2003
By A Customer
Despite all the favorable reviews I read in this space, I thought this was an awful book. Major plot lines were left hanging. Heroine has outrageous sex with many people in bizarre and embarrassing ways, ends up loving the protagonist -- who still may be a murderer. Everybody ends up happy when they shouldn't, when in reality they wouldn't. The 9/11 stuff is so unreal. There is no motivation here that makes sense. This is the kind of stuff that Harold Robbins was famous for, but at least he tried to tie things together; Block doesn't even make the effort. If this is the kind of stuff you guys are reading and enjoying, you need to
move up in the world and try other authors of some quality.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Compelling Read -- But It's Not For Everyone!, May 31, 2003
Overall, I enjoyed Small Town a lot. It's a very compelling, interesting and somewhat challenging read. In Block's Small Town, New York City in the aftermath of 9/11 is really a small town filled with men and women from all walks of life whose aspirations fears, disappointments and triumphs are all interconnected by bonds as unspeakable as they are unseen. The plot involves a series of apparently unconnected serial killings, which in the warped viewpoint of the Carpenter are intended as "sacrifices" in order to help the city and its dwellers to be reborn out of the chaos and destruction caused by 9/11. Block is at the top of his game in terms of plot development and character development; however, Small Town represents a big departure from what fans of his books have become used to. Small Town is not, as is obvious if you've read the very mixed reviews by other Amazon readers, a book for everyone. Many criticize it for its very graphic and erotic sexual passages as well as for the ending leaving too many threads untied. While I understand how the book could be criticized for these reasons, I, personally, didn't share these opinions. In fact, I think the sexual relationships, while very graphic, were integral to the main story line. And while it's true that some sub-story lines are not as closed as readers expect in a novel, in real life not all stories have a clear, precise ending. As I said, earlier, Small Town is a somewhat challenging read in that you have to really pay attention to some of the small clues Block provides. If you don't, you might find, as I did, that you'll have to go back and reread some areas to understand its connection to the outcome. I hope this review is helpful to you in deciding whether Small Town is a book for you -- because it's not for everyone.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No