Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An extinction to celebrate, December 26, 2009
This review is from: Smallpox- the Death of a Disease: The Inside Story of Eradicating a Worldwide Killer (Hardcover)
Smallpox reigned through history as one of the most destructive diseases the human species ever suffered. Hundreds of millions of people are estimated to have died from it in the twentieth century alone. Its eradication, twenty years ago this year, remains unique: no other disease has been eliminated, once and and for all.
To some extent, smallpox almost aided in its own demise. Unlike life-long HIV infections, smallpox runs its course, to survival or death, within a few weeks. Unlike bubonic plague, there is no animal reservoir for the pathogen - when no more people have the disease, it can't come back. Unlike influenza, for which new vaccines are needed every year, only one vaccine was needed during the decades of intensive eradication effort. The disease's deadliness was only one reason it was such an attractive target for elimination.
This book tells the story of that elimination effort, written by the man who led that effort. Not just a medical miracle, it required cooperation from every nation on earth plus the warring factions that controlled areas where smallpox was endemic. That feat of cooperation very nearly counts as a miracle in itself and represents, to my mind, Dr. Henderson's most stunning achievement.
That cooperation faced continuous threats through the decades of the eradication program. As in any field, funding was always uncertain - especially when so many 'experts' said the goal was impossible, and that the funds should be directed to other diseases. The funding agencies quarreled amongst themselves, too. In one case Henderson describes, a funding group refused to pay for fuel for the team's trucks, on the grounds that a different agency had provided the trucks. Then, the team faced challenges from the terrain they had to cover, often in remote and nearly inaccessible areas - or in areas of active war, where the medical team needed permission from both sides to vaccinate and monitor the population. Not just doctors, educators, and negotiators, Henderson's team had to be mechanics as well, to deal with the inevitable breakdowns days away from the nearest repair shop. Then, they had to change their way of working to accommodate the unique political environment of every country in which they worked.
But, in the end, Henderson and his team succeeded, except for samples in two laboratories. Henderson and his team previously documented their approach to the eradication in a World Health Organization document over a thousand pages in length. The story deserves a wider audience, however. This book presents a lively and very readable summary of that massive report. Today we face challenges of our own, from other pathogens. Techniques specific to smallpox eradication might not be appropriate to malaria, HIV, or other diseases. Any eradication effort, however, can learn from the creativity and heroic determination of the team that drove smallpox to extinction.
-- wiredweird
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Personal Account, September 19, 2009
This review is from: Smallpox- the Death of a Disease: The Inside Story of Eradicating a Worldwide Killer (Hardcover)
After reading several other books that explore smallpox eradication, Henderson's account appears more in-depth and personal. It places the reader in the situation, its stresses and successes. The reality of the narrative is supported by both strong personal biases and fast-paced anecdotes. The bias is shown in dark portrayals of bureaucratic figures that were shown to impede progress instead of assisting eradication. Henderson writes with strong, liberal voice that is true to life. He is blunt and decisive, and this is reflected in the text.
The anecdotal clippings that are boxed and scattered in the book depict unique struggles and solutions of the eradication campaign. Cultural and environmental barriers of the campaign are exposed in the brief accounts. "A novel way to detect hidden cases" is one example of an unusual solution; in order to reveal denied cases of smallpox, a vehicle was driven into deep mud to interest infected villagers, bringing them out of their homes.
Henderson also emphasizes the need for rule-breaking. He boldly suggests that certain conditions require radical action. His assertions are projected by scenarios and are proven valid by the ultimate success achieved by Henderson and other members of the campaign to bring the death of a disease.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
HENDERSON'S VIEWS ON SMALLPOX ERADICATION, June 24, 2009
This review is from: Smallpox- the Death of a Disease: The Inside Story of Eradicating a Worldwide Killer (Hardcover)
This book fills a gap on the smallpox eradication bookshelf.
D. A. Henderson, who was chief of smallpox eradication at WHO from 1966 to 1977, co-authored with Frank Fenner and colleagues the 1988 magnum opus, Smallpox and Eradication, an encyclopedic overview of the disease and its eradication. That WHO publication, now on the Internet, is as close to an official history of smallpox eradication as we are likely to see.
In this briefer, 300 page narrative, printed without the WHO imprimatur, Henderson looks at the people and institutions who, in his view, assisted or impeded the march towards smallpox eradication. He is not very kind to some people in some governments (he is especially hard on the Siyad Barre regime in Somalia, to some of the WHO regional offices, and to some people in the US Agency for International Development). He is unfailingly supportive of the compact teams in Geneva, CDC/Atlanta and the field who, with the governments of the endemic countries, gave us the world's first and last cheap disease eradication effort ($125 million in agency expenditure).
On the technical side, Henderson points to the innovations (vaccine quality control, the bifurcated needle, surveillance and containment, and smallpox identification cards) which moved the global program forward.
No book on smallpox can be exhaustive. [...]is a bit daunting at 1400 pages; some readers will prefer Donald Hopkins' briefer account of the historical consequences of smallpox, Horace Ogden's richly anecdotal CDC and the Smallpox Crusade, or Lawrence Brilliant's out of print book on the management of smallpox eradication in India. Henderson's brief bibliography is a good starting point for those who want to explore the subject more deeply.
If you can only read one book on the subject. this is the one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|